Best Management Practices For Raptor Conservation During Urban . - Gov

Transcription

MOE BMP SeriesBest Management Practices for RaptorConservation during Urban and RuralLand Development in British Columbia31 March 2005Prepared by:Mike W. Demarchi, MSc, RPBioandMichael D. BentleyLGL Limited environmental research associates9768 Second StreetSidney, BC V8L 3Y8Revised by:Lennart Sopuck, RPBioBiolinx Environmental Research Ltd.1759 Colburne PlaceNorth Saanich, BC V8L 5A2For:B.C. Ministry of EnvironmentEcosystem Standards and PlanningBiodiversity Branch

This page has been intentionally left blankii

PrefaceAcknowledgementsGrant Bracher of the B.C. Ministry of Environment (MOE) served as thecontract monitor, and provided important guidance and comments on draftsof this document. Original text for the provincial document was completedby Mike W. Demarchi and Michael D. Bentley, LGL Limited environmentalresearch associates. The document was revised in 2005 by Lennart Sopuck,Biolinx Environmental Research Limited. Marlene Caskey (MOE) and EricaMcClaren (MOE) provided important materials and advice, and commentedon a draft of this document. Michael Chutter, Karen Morrison, MargaretHenigman and Susan Latimer of MOE reviewed all or portions of thisdocument. Jared Hobbs of Hobbs Photo Images Company, Susan Latimer,Erica McClaren and Don Doyle of MOE kindly provided photos of raptorsused in this document. Gary Searing (Wildlife Biologist with LGL Limited)provided additional information on raptor conservation and management.Peter Wainwright (Biologist with LGL Limited; Councillor with the Town ofSidney) provided insights to municipal government processes. Lucia Ferreira(GIS Technician with LGL Limited) assisted with mapping. This documentis based on a template prepared by Debbie Webb, formerly with MOE. Someof the information herein builds upon that presented in a BMP guide forraptors on Vancouver Island (Manning, Cooper and Associates 2003).Photographs credited to LGL Limited and Hobbs Photo Images Companyare copyrighted.Cover photos (left to right): a juvenile Osprey at its nest, residential and transportationdevelopments near raptor habitat (in background), an adult Barn Owl, and a Townsend’svole (an important prey species for raptors). Photos provided by LGL Limited.PrefaceBritish Columbia is recognized globally for its exceptional wildlife, diversityof ecosystems and its rich natural resources. The Ministry of Environment(MOE) works to maintain these valuable natural assets, which are at the heartof many recreational and economic activities enjoyed by British Columbiansin all regions of the province.MOE has responsibility for the protection and stewardship of BritishColumbia’s environment. To achieve this goal, the Ministry develops policyand legislation, regulations, codes of practice, environmental contracts andcovenants (legal agreements). In addition, the Ministry sets science- andresults-based objectives and standards for activities that affectbiodiversity. It monitors and reports on selected species and habitats, andacquires information on habitat and species health.Clear goals, objectives, meaningful performance measures and science-basedtools guide Ministry actions in improving environmental management.iii

PrefaceRegulatory frameworks allow headquarters and regional staff to set andreport on standards for environmental quality, and for discharges andemissions to air, land and water. Regulatory compliance is addressed throughpolicy development, enforcement and publicly reporting the results ofcompliance monitoring.An Increasing Role for StewardshipWhile the Ministry takes a leading role in the protection of BritishColumbia’s natural resources, species, and habitats, environmental protectionand stewardship is the responsibility of all British Columbians. Stewardshipof natural resources is key to maintaining and restoring the province’s naturaldiversity, and achieving the Ministry’s important environmental mandate. Astewardship approach involves all British Columbians taking responsibilityfor the well being of the environment by acting to restore or protect ahealthy environment.The Ministry is actively pursuing opportunities for sharing the responsibilityof environmental protection. As a Ministry, MOE looks to establish vitalpartnerships and move forward together to protect the environment and thehealth of all British Columbians. MOE is listening to and developingpartnerships with governments, First Nations, communities, academicinstitutions, industries, volunteer organizations, and citizens. Theinvolvement of these partners in the shared environmental protection andstewardship of British Columbia’s resources is essential because of their localknowledge, resources and expertise. The environment will benefit as a resultof an increased level of responsible environmental stewardship ethics,immediate and long-term improvements to environmental health and anincreased awareness of ecosystem needs among the partners.A Changing ProcessOver the next several years, the Ministry will be making strategic shifts(changes in business practices) towards: Shared stewardship between the Ministry and other stakeholders; Clear roles for gathering environmental information and achievingenvironmental objectives; Integrated MOE program delivery based on the best available scienceand an ecosystem-based approach; and Clear, reasonable environmental outcomes, with discretion as to howto achieve these outcomes.This is an interim document that will likely change in the future. Changes tothe delivery model of this information are also expected, through themovement towards Internet-based access.iv

PrefaceWhat will this document do for me?This document will assist you in being a steward of the environment. Theinformation herein will help to ensure that proposed development activitiesare planned and carried out in compliance with the various legislation,regulations, and policies. This document focuses on the conservation ofraptors (birds of prey) and their habitat during land development withinmunicipalities and regional districts.v

Table of ContentsTable of ContentsAcknowledgements.iiiPreface .iiiTable of Contents.vi1 Introduction.12 Purpose.13 How to Use This Document.24 Background .34.1 What are Raptors?.34.2 Why Raptors are Important .54.3 The Role of Local Government in Raptor Conservation.65 Key Issues of Concern and Conservation Opportunities .75.1 Vancouver Island/Lower Mainland.85.2 Thompson/Okanagan .85.3 Kootenays .95.4 Cariboo.95.5 Omineca/Peace. 105.6 Skeena. 105.7 Range-Wide Concerns for Migratory Species. 116 Legal Requirements. 117 How to obtain Information on Raptors in your Area . 138 Best Management Practices . 18BMP 1. Retain Existing Habitats and Features; Minimize Loss ofNatural Vegetation. 24BMP 2. Protect raptor nest sites. 28BMP 3. Protect raptor roosting/perching sites and foraging areas. 32BMP 4. Avoid disturbance of sensitive habitats during and afterdevelopment . 32BMP 5. Manage, restore or enhance raptor habitat and features. 34BMP 6. Minimize the risk of accidental mortality. 36BMP 7. Avoid the use of pesticides and herbicides. 37BMP 8. Educate the public about the importance of maintaining raptorsin urban and rural environments . 379 Monitoring and Reporting . 389.1 Why is monitoring necessary?. 389.2 What is involved in setting up a monitoring program?. 3810 Species Accounts. 4110.1 Turkey Vulture (Cathartes aura) . 4210.2 Osprey (Pandion haliaetus) . 4510.3 Bald Eagle (Haliaeetus leucocephalus). 48vi

Table of Contents10.4 Northern Harrier (Circus cyaneus). 5210.5 Sharp-shinned Hawk (Accipiter striatus). 5510.6 Cooper’s Hawk (Accipiter cooperii). 5710.7 Northern Goshawk (Accipiter gentilis). 6010.8 Swainson's Hawk (Buteo swainsoni) . 6310.9 Red-tailed Hawk (Buteo jamaicensis) . 6510.10 Rough-legged Hawk (Buteo lagopus). 6810.11 American Kestrel (Falco sparverius) . 6910.12 Merlin (Falco columbarius) . 7210.13 Peregrine Falcon (Falco peregrinus) . 7410.14 Prairie Falcon (Falco mexicanus) . 7810.15 Barn Owl (Tyto alba) . 7910.16 Flammulated Owl (Otus flammeolus) . 8210.17 Western Screech-Owl (Megascops kennicottii) . 8310.18 Great Horned Owl (Bubo virginianus) . 8610.19 Northern Pygmy-Owl (Glaucidium gnoma). 8810.20 Spotted Owl (Strix occidentalis). 9110.21 Burrowing Owl (Athene cunicularia). 9310.22 Barred Owl (Strix varia). 9410.23 Long-eared Owl (Asio otus). 9710.24 Short-eared Owl (Asio flammeus) . 9810.25 Northern Saw-whet Owl (Aegolius acadicus) . 10110.26 Other Species . 10311 Glossary. 11012 References . 11313 Additional Information Sources . 12114 Appendices. 12514.1 Legislation . 125vii

Purpose1 IntroductionMany species of raptors (birds of prey) have been adversely affected by urbanand rural land development in British Columbia (Campbell et al 1990).However, raptors can often coexist with people in human-modifiedlandscapes if certain practices are adopted. This Best Management Practices(BMP) document was produced to assist local government staff, thedevelopment community, and landowners with the conservation of raptorsand their habitats in urban and rural areas of the province. It is a companiondocument to Environmental Best Management Practices for Urban andRural Land Development in British Columbia prepared for the BritishColumbia Ministry of Environment (MOE).Raptors are valuable components of terrestrial ecosystems and occur innearly all terrestrial habitats of British Columbia. Historically, people haveheld strong, often polarized views about raptors, resulting in actions rangingfrom reverence to persecution. Currently, raptors are recognized as anintegral part of ecosystems in much of the world, including British Columbia,and are legally protected. In British Columbia, conflicts between habitatrequirements of raptors and urban and rural developments have beenfrequent because the valleys and shorelines that are ideal for settlement alsocontain important raptor habitat. Logging, agriculture, urbanization, miningand hydroelectric developments have greatly modified landscapes over largeareas, often adversely affecting raptors. The cumulative effects of small-scalehuman activities, ranging from simple disturbance to cutting down a nesttree, can also reduce the abundance and number of species of raptors in anarea. In many cases, critical habitat features required by raptors can beprotected or restored during land development, so that opportunities tomaintain or enhance raptor biodiversity in urban and rural environmentscan be realised.Preserving and managing raptor habitats within urban and rural landscapesbenefits more than just the birds. Many of the habitat features required byraptors add aesthetic and market value to real estate developments, and thepresence of wildlife, including raptors, enhances the quality of life forresidents (see Section 4.2 for more information on the ecological and socialvalues of raptors).2 PurposeThis document provides guidance on how to help maintain raptorpopulations and their habitats during and after land development in urbanand rural environments. The information is pertinent to all MOE Regions1

How to Use This Documentand, in particular, to southern areas of the province where urbanization andother developments have greatly reduced the quantity and quality of raptorhabitats. The target audience includes municipal and regional governments,land developers, naturalist groups and other non-government organizations(NGOs), and individual landowners. The document provides non-biologistswith a basic understanding of raptor conservation and the tools available tohelp maintain raptor populations and to protect, restore or enhance theirhabitats. This document will also be of interest to biologists and scientists,but it is not meant to be a comprehensive treatise on the ecology andconservation of raptors in British Columbia.The specific objectives of the document are to: Explain what raptors are, their value to society and the roles they playin ecosystems (Sections 4.1 & 4.2). Explain why it is important for local governments and thedevelopment community to participate in the shared stewardship ofthe environment and to incorporate raptor conservation measures inurban and rural land development (Sections 4.2 & 4.3) Describe the roles and responsibilities of local governments,developers, and the public in the shared stewardship of raptors andtheir habitats (Section 4.3 & 6) Describe the key conservation issues and opportunities forconservation in urban and rural areas for raptors in each region of theprovince (Section 5) Describe Best Management Practices (BMPs), applicable to allregions of British Columbia, that help maintain raptor populations inurban and rural environments and protect or restore key habitatfeatures during and after land development (Section 8). Provide monitoring strategies for MOE, local governments andNGOs to see if BMPs are being followed and to determine if they areeffective in maintaining raptor populations and habitats (Section 9) Provide current information on raptor ecology and conservationstatus in various regions of the province (Section 10). Describe the relevant provincial and federal legislation that protectsraptors and their habitat (Sections 6 & 14.1).3 How to Use This DocumentThis document provides easy-to-follow guidelines and measures to helpensure that developments in urban and rural areas are sensitive to theecological needs of raptors. In many cases, a developer or landowner canmake a significant contribution to the biodiversity of an area if the relativelysimple guidelines in this document are followed. There are also limitations tothis guidebook. Interactions of raptors with their environment, including2

Backgroundhuman developments, are very complex, and the measures presented in thisdocument should not be viewed as a comprehensive description of allpossible management actions. For large or complex projects, a developer isencouraged to seek advice from a professional biologist.The document is organized as follows: Important background information ispresented in Sections 1 through 5, and Section 6 summarizes legalrequirements and limitations pertaining to raptor habitat protection in BritishColumbia. BMPs intended to protect, enhance or restore raptors and theirhabitats in urban and rural environments are presented in Section 8.Recommended monitoring and reporting strategies to evaluate theeffectiveness of BMPs are presented in Section 9. Species accounts in Section10 provide information on the life history and conservation status of theraptors of British Columbia. Important technical terms are highlighted withinthe body of the text and defined in the Glossary (Section 11). Scientificinformation upon which this document is based is presented in Section 12.Additional information available on the Internet, covering a wide range ofraptor-related topics is presented in Section 13.Hyperlinks (indicated by words underlined and in blue) to relatedinformation in the document or on the World Wide Web occur throughoutthe document. For example, the first hyperlink in each species accountconnects to a raptor photograph on the Internet. To return to the BMPdocument after visiting an external link, click your Internet browser’s “back”button.4 Background4.1 What are Raptors?Figure 1. The Bald Eagle is animpressive raptor often used assymbol of power and freedom. Itnests in large trees close to fishbearing waterbodies and prefersundisturbed foraging areas free ofharassment by humans and pets.Raptors are predatory birds that include eagles, hawks, falcons, and owls. Theterm “raptor” is from the Latin word rapere meaning, “to take by force”.Predators kill the animals they eat. Scavengers find and eat animals that arealready dead, or nearly dead. Raptors typically hunt and kill their prey, thoughsome species regularly scavenge too. An example is the Bald Eagle, whichcommonly kills birds and fish, but also feeds on the dead and dying bodies ofspawned-out salmon. Raptors are equipped with sharp talons (claws) and ahooked beak that assist them in their predatory way of life. Sharp talonsassist with the capture and holding of prey, while the beak helps tear fleshand other tissues.The Turkey Vulture, a scavenger rather than a predator, was once consideredto be related to hawks and eagles, but is now placed in the same group asherons and storks. They are included in this document because they havesimilar requirements as some true raptors and sometimes occur in urban andrural environments.3

BackgroundFalcons, hawks, and eagles are active primarily during daylight hours, whereasowls are mainly active at night. However, there are exceptions to this pattern,since the Northern Pygmy-Owl, Northern Hawk Owl and Short-eared Owlmay be commonly seen during the day.Figure 2. In contrast to most owls, the Northern Pygmy-Owl (shown holding a mouse)commonly hunts during the day. It nests in tree cavities such as those created bywoodpeckers.Figure 3. Fish-bearing lakes, large trees near the shoreline, and coniferous woodlandsprovide raptors and their prey with important habitats. LGL Limited photo.4

Background4.2 Why Raptors are ImportantFigure 4. Barn Owls often nest in oldfarm buildings in agricultural areas.They consume large numbers of smallmammals such as voles, mice, rats andshrews.Raptors play important roles in ecosystems and are valued by society inseveral ways:Aesthetic Values—A species’ natural beauty and artistic appreciation. Raptorshave many attributes admired by the public including a striking, nobleappearance, remarkable flying ability and keen senses. The aesthetic values ofraptors are often portrayed in the work of artists and photographers.Spiritual Values—A species’ relation with and role in human culture, spanningscales ranging from an individual to an entire society. Bald Eagles, Golden Eagles andother raptors play a significant spiritual role in many Native Americansocieties. Throughout history, raptors have been an emblem of strength,courage and freedom, and are frequently the namesake of sports teams,automobiles, and aircraft. Humans first landed on the moon in a modulenamed “Eagle” (Link). By viewing wild raptors in urban and rural areas,people are able to maintain an important psychological connection withnature.Recreational Values—Qualities stemming from recreational pursuits associatedwith the species. Economic and non-economic aspects are included. Examples ofrecreational values of raptors include bird-watching and falconry. Raptors arerenowned for their ability to attract bird-watchers (e.g., the annual gatheringof Bald Eagles near Squamish, British Columbia; Link, and concentration ofmigrating raptors at Beechy Head on the southern tip of Vancouver Island).Educational and Scientific Values—The study of raptors allows a betterunderstanding of the world around us. This understanding may simply add to ourknowledge base or be used to improve the quality of human life and ecological conditions.Because of their top position in the food-chain, raptors serve as barometersof environmental change and overall ecosystem health. They typically requirelarge areas and healthy prey populations for survival. As such, measures thatconserve raptors can provide an umbrella of protection for many other plantand animal species. The quality of raptor health is a measure ofenvironmental health. For example, environmental contamination with DDTresulted in adverse effects on many species of raptors. By discontinuing theuse of that pesticide to conserve raptors (and other species), environmentalconditions for humans and other animals have improved.Ecological Values—The roles that species play in the ecosystems they occupy.Raptors consume a wide variety of prey including small mammals, birds,reptiles, amphibians, fish, and insects. Hence, they play a role in regulatingprey populations and in nutrient cycling. Raptors are also importantcomponents of biological diversity. The variation among different speciesand the genetic variation within individual species of raptors (i.e., the “genepool”) contribute to the biodiversity of a region. Because research intoraptors is ongoing, the full range of ecological values will not likely be known5

Backgroundfor many years. Thus, it is prudent to conserve raptors to retain both theirknown and presently unknown ecological values. Such an approach followsthe precautionary principle.Economic Values—How raptors affect the lives and livelihoods of people. Byhelping to control prey populations, raptors can directly benefit humans byreducing pest species (many of which are non-native) such as rats, mice,rabbits, starlings, house sparrows, pigeons, and grasshoppers. Eagles andVultures help reduce the spread of disease by cleaning up dead and rottinganimal carcasses. Travelling birdwatchers spend considerable amounts ofmoney on food, drink, lodging, gasoline and other local services. Raptors arehighly sought by birders and communities with large raptor populations canbenefit economically. The Bald Eagles of Brackendale near Squamish are asignificant source of tourist revenue for the surrounding community (Link).The presence of raptor habitat (wooded areas, wetlands, old fields) can addto the economic value (marketability) of a property. Falconers use raptors toscare other birds from airports to reduce the risk of birdstrikes and aircraftdamage, reduce crop damage, disperse pest species at landfills, and reducepollution of urban parks by keeping geese away from sports fields andswimming beaches.4.3 The Role of Local Government inRaptor ConservationLocalgovernments arewell positioned toconserve raptorsusing provisionsin the LocalGovernment Actand CommunityCharterCurrent legislation at the provincial level protects birds, their nests and eggs,but provides little, if any, protection for their habitats—especially on private,municipal and regional lands. This poses a problem for raptors in urban andrural environments where most land is privately owned. So, while theProvince retains jurisdiction over raptors in British Columbia, local(municipal and regional) governments are often in a better position to serveas stewards of raptor habitat in urban and rural areas. Through the LocalGovernment Act and Community Charter, local governments have the authority toregulate development within their jurisdiction. The role of local governmentsin the maintenance of raptor populations is vital because much of BritishColumbia’s best land for development also contains critical raptor habitatused for breeding, migrating/staging and wintering. This overlap typicallyoccurs in the lowlands and valley bottoms, which contain productive raptorhabitats. Such land is relatively rare in British Columbia; a provincedominated by high, rugged mountains with harsh climates, and limited foodsupply for raptors.The role of local governments and the development community in protectingraptors is expected to expand in the future. For example, the CommunityCharter empowers municipalities with the ability to take a leading role inwildlife stewardship. Local governments need to address the habitat needs ofraptors and other wildlife when regulating development. The responsibilityfor stewardship is shared among several parties, including the ProvincialGovernment.6

Key Issues of Concern and Conservation OpportunitiesMany opportunities exist for local governments to protect raptors and theirhabitats: Local development regulations and guidelines can be adopted basedon information obtained by identifying and mapping importantraptor habitats, which can be carried out together with othergovernments and NGO groups. This approach not only benefitsraptors, but it also provides developers with a degree ofunderstanding and certainty regarding what developments might beacceptable in a given area, so saving time and money for developers. Official Community Plans (OCPs) can be used to delineate UrbanContainment Boundaries, Environmentally Sensitive Areas, andDevelopment Permit Areas. Zoning can dictate acceptable land usesand by-laws can provide habitat protection (e.g., stream set-backs andwildlife tree protection). OCPs can be used as a mechanism toprotect important raptor habitat features, including nest sites,foraging areas, roosting sites and surrounding protective buffers. Local governments can facilitate the establishment of ConservationCovenants, which protect habitats. Density transfers and densitybonuses can be used to reduce urban sprawl and allow theestablishment of wildlife conservation zones. As guided by this document and/or as assisted by expert advice, localgovernment staff unfamiliar with raptor ecology can gain confidenceto assess, amend, approve, or reject a development application.Further information on how local governments can help conserve wildlifehabitats and natural ecosystems is presented in Best Management Practices forUrban and Rural Land Development and Nowlan et al. (2001; Link). Henigman(2004) describes in detail how local governments can protect raptor nestsites, using Bald Eagle nest trees on Vancouver Island as an example.5 Key Issues of Concern andConservation OpportunitiesA major threat to raptor habitat in British Columbia is the large-scaleconversion of agricultural lands and natural areas to land uses that typicallyinvolve impermeable surfaces (i.e., pavement and asphalt) and buildings.Between 1971 and 2001, the total area of urban land in B.C. increased fromabout 1750 km2 to 4050 km2 (Statistics Canada 2005), resulting in the loss ordegradation of productive agricultural land, valley bottom habitats andgreenspaces. Intensive agricultural practices, such as expansive greenhousedevelopments, are also reducing raptor habitats. The Lower Fraser Valley and7

Key Issues of Concern and Conservation OpportunitiesDelta tra

maintain or enhance raptor biodiversity in urban and rural environments can be realised. Preserving and managing raptor habitats within urban and rural landscapes benefits more than just the birds. Many of the habitat features required by raptors add aesthetic and market value to real estate developments, and the