WAVES

Transcription

WAVESOF CHANGEA report of the Metropolitan Beaches CommissionProduced for the Metropolitan Beaches Commission of theGeneral Court of the Commonwealth of Massachusettsby Save the Harbor / Save the BayJune 2014

ABOUT THE METROPOLITAN BEACHES COMMISSION AND THIS REPORTSenator Thomas McGeeCO-CHAIRRepresentative Carlo BasileCO-CHAIRKip BeckerBOSTON UNIVERSITYBarbara BishopSPEAKER DELEO’S OFFICERepresentative Garrett BradleyTHIRD PLYMOUTHThe Metropolitan Beaches Commissionwas created in 2006 by the Massachusetts Legislature to take an in-depthlook at the metropolitan region’s public beachesin Nahant, Lynn, Revere, Winthrop, East Boston,South Boston, Dorchester, Quincy and Hull thatare managed by the Department of Conservationand Recreation (DCR). In 2013, the Commission reconvened to examine the impacts of thereforms and recommendations made in its firstreport, released in 2007, and issue additionalfindings and recommendations to better leverage these resources for more than one millionregional residents. This report documents theCommission’s most recent findings.The Commission is comprised of elected officialsand community, civic, nonprofit, and businessleaders from Boston and the metropolitanregion’s beachfront communities and waterfrontneighborhoods. It is co-chaired by Senator TomMcGee and Representative Carlo Basile, and ledand managed by Save the Harbor/Save the Bay.In 2013, the Commission held 10 public hearings—two at the State House and eight in Bos-Representative Nick CollinsFOURTH SUFFOLKton’s waterfront neighborhoods and the region’sbeachfront communities from Nahant to Nantasket. Nearly 1,000 people attended at least onehearing, and shared their thoughts about how toimprove their beach. The Commission also retained the services of the CPA firm Raphael andRaphael LLP, whose findings and recommendations are summarized in this report.In 2014, the Commission invited all those whotook part in its process to review preliminaryfindings and recommendations, in order to makecertain that we got it right. This report reflectsthe hard work and commitment of so many whocare deeply about the beaches and are dedicatedto improving the quality of life in our communities. The Commission is truly grateful to all whohave participated in this effort.Copies of this report, related appendices, stickynotes and other supporting materials on whichthis report is based are available at Save theHarbor/Save the Bay’s website:www.savetheharbor.org/MBC2014.Mark CullinanNAHANT RESIDENTPaul GroganTHE BOSTON FOUNDATIONDouglas GutroQUINCY CITY COUNCILCarol HaneyREVERESenator Robert HedlundPLYMOUTH & NORFOLKRepresentative Bradford HillFOURTH ESSEXSenator John KeenanNORFOLK & PLYMOUTHManny LopesEAST BOSTON NEIGHBORHOOD HEALTHCENTERChris MarchiEAST BOSTON COMMUNITY ADVOCATEJoan MeschinoHULL RESIDENTPaul F. NuttingSAVIN HILL SHORESDaniel O’ConnellMASSACHUSETTS COMPETITIVE PARTNERSHIPSamantha OvertonDEPARTMENT OF CONSERVATION ANDRECREATIONSenator Anthony PetruccelliFIRST SUFFOLK AND MIDDLESEXRobert TuckerFRIENDS OF LYNN AND NAHANT BEACH

TABLE OF CONTENTSLetter from the Chairs.1Progress Since the Commission’s 2007 Report. 2Key Findings and Recommendations.5Findings and Recommendations by Community. 17Lynn and Nahant.18Revere.19Winthrop. 20East Boston.21South Boston. 22Dorchester. 23Quincy. 24Hull. 25Next Steps.26Copies of this report, related appendices, sticky notes and other supportingmaterials on which this report is based are available at Save the Harbor/Save theBay’s website: www.savetheharbor.org/MBC2014WAVES OF CHANGE A REPORT OF THE METROPOLITAN BEACHES COMMISSION  i

THE COMMISSION WOULD LIKE TO THANKALL THOSE WHO HELPED TO SHAPE THE FINDINGS ANDRECOMMENDATIONS CONTAINED IN THIS REPORT.Patricia Abbate Chickie Abdallah Michael Abrahams ElaineLouis Elisa Gareth Ellis Kennedy Elsey Coleen Elstermeyer Abrams Hope Abramson Christopher Adams Fred Ahern BeverlyEleanor Engel Arwa Eshaq Toni Esposito Elaine Fallon Rep.Alba Marsha Allen Thomas G. Ambrosino Gerard Anderson SamMark V. Falzone Tom Farina James Fatseas Ray Faucher RayArnold Brian Arrigo Felix G. Arroyo Chris Austill Iris Ayala Rep.Faucher City Clerk Maureen E. Feeney Pat Feeney Andrew FelperBruce J. Ayers Ayah Badran Elle Baker City Councilor Frank Baker Peter Felt Ann & Joseph Felzani Rep. Robert F. Fennell Robert Antonio Barletta Robert Baron Rep. Carlo Basile Scott Bassy Ferrara Scott Ferrara Daniel Fielding Daniel and Michelle FieldingLouise C. Baxter Michael Beattie Diana Beaudoin Kip Becker Patrick Finn Laurene Flaherty City Councilor Michael Flaherty Brenda Bee Bill Bell John I. Benson Bruce Berman Ryan BettezRobin Flint Anita Flintoff Barbara Flockhart Toros Flynn Patricia Tiffany Bevis Tanya Bhargava John Biannan David Biele LarryA. Foley P.J. Foley Peter Forbes Tom Forcier Sophia Forgione Bingaman Barbara Bishop Lisa Bishop Andrew Bisignani JacobRay Foucher Bob Fowkes Ciro Franchese Andrew Francis RachelBombard Phil Boncore Annette Bornstein Kitty Bowman EileenFrenkil Jordan Frias Richard Fuller Joseph Gaeta Suzanne GallBoyle Rep. Garrett J. Bradley G. Brandenstein Paul Brennan Marsh Mark Gallagher Dominic Gallucio Maureen Galvin DavidPeter Brennan Gary Briere Kaitlyn Leahy Brohel Alyssa BromleyGass Amy Gaylord William Geary Priscilla Geigis Sal Genovese Marci Brown Stephen Buckley Thomas Butler Jr. Robert Butman Annissa Essaibi George Nick & Marie Giacobbe Carl Giambusso Karen Buttiglieri June Byrne Jane and Tom Cahill City Councilor Susan Giannotti Taylor Gibson Peter Gill Rob Gilman NancyDaniel F. Cahill Linda Calla Joe Cappuccio Barbara Caristo JohnGirard Seth Gitell Michael Glasfeld Jacob Glickel Bob Grohl Carli Marta Carny Maria Carrasco Fredi Carroll Phil Carver AnnKevin Golden Anne Goldstein David Gomez Guillermo Gonzalez Carver Marie Carver Gia Casale Christopher Cassani MichaelAnn B. Gordon Fredda Gordon Jim Gordon Amanda Gourgue Celona Jamie Cerulli Rep. Tackey Chan Senator Sonia Chang-DiazNick Gove Pat Graney Kristin Grazioso Annie Greenspan Marie Rachel Charnley Edlyn Chavez Paul Christner Heather Chucas Greig Philip Griffiths Paul S. Grogan Liz Gunderson Carroll CityJohn Ciccarelli Liz Cloonan Linda Cohen Meg Colclough MichaelCouncillor Doug Gutro Deirdre Habershaw Chris Haley LaurieColecchia Bill Collins James Collins Jim & Mary Collins Rep.Hamill Susan Hamilton Susan Hamilton Carol Haney CathyNick Collins City Councilor Richard C. Colucci Linda Conley JimHanley Michelle Hanly Jack Hart, Esq. Judie Hass Senator BobConroy Jennifer Constable Kevin Conway Katie Corbitt SylviaHedlund Joan Helfman Dick and Pat Herbert Christian Herbosa Corin Wendy Corkhum City Councillor John R. Correggio PaulAnne Herbst Ana Hernandez De Leon Jimmy Higgins Rep.Costello Kate Costin Kelly Coughlin Rich Coviello Emily CowanBradford Hill Nancy Hill Joanne Hillman Kevin Hollenbeck Kevin Jim Cowdell Lisa and Kevin Cox William F. Coyne, Jr., Esq. JohnHollenbeck Kerri-Anne Hollingshead Richard Honan RichardCoyne Conrad Crawford Jack Creahan Brendan P. Crighton Horn Carol Houghtaling Annette Hoyt David Hubbard SueLynne Crosby City Councillor Paul Crowley Mark Cullinan TomHuberman City Councillor Kirsten L. Hughes Rep. Dan Hunt DanCullinane Tom Cullinane, Jr. Amanda Curley Robert Curley Hunt Kathleen Hurley Jackie Indrisano Barbara Isola JenniferVanessa Curran Josephine Cuzzi Steve DaCorta Tanji DaigneaultJackson Roger Jackson Joseph James Ian James Evan Valerie Dalton Patricia Daly Kelli D’Amato Amy Davidson CoreyJarashow Yudan Jiang Elizabeth Joffe Richard Joyce KristinaL. Davis Ernani DeAraujo Susan DeFelice Speaker of the HouseKalabokas Susan Kane Rhoda Kanet Ryan Kearney LawrenceRobert A. DeLeo Antonio Dello Laceno Daniel Delpapa Nick andKeegan Jr. Senator John D. Keenan Stephanie Keller Mary KelleyCathy DelVento Kathryn Depaola Ed Devean Ed Deveau Richard Leo Kelly and Margaret Milne Julie Kelly Kathy Kelly Mary KellyDimes Brittany Dixon Christina Doctoroff Christina Doctoroff Brian Kelly Dennis Kelly Dan Kenary Kennedy Elsey MayorChief Gene Doherty Ruth Dollarhide C.A. Dolph-McKenna JoeJudith Flanagan Kennedy Miles Kennedy Jess Kenney RichardDomelowicz Phillip Donadini Sen. Linda Dorcena Forry RobertKing Ann Kirby Alda Kirsis Dan Kistler Gail Klimas Janet KnottDougherty Sean Driscoll Edward Duggan Emily Dulong John Mayor Thomas P. Koch Katerina Koudanis John Krall NancySwinell Lee Dzedulionis Rep. Lori Ehrlich James Eisenberg Kramer Lee Krikorian Virginia Kropas Kristen and Mark Ladas ii   WAVES OF CHANGE A REPORT OF THE METROPOLITAN BEACHES COMMISSION

Kathy Lafferty City Councillor Margaret Laforest Brett Laker CityOrlando Perilla Senator Anthony W. Petruccelli City Councilor JohnCouncillor Salvatore LaMattina Edward M. Lambert, Jr. Ed Lane Timothy Phelan Leonard Piazza Sean Pierce Susan Plawsky Chris Lange Ted Langill Noel LaPierre Frederick A. Laskey Jeannie Polino Paul Polito Matthew Pollock Joe Poniatowski Michelle Lavoie Robert Lawlor Tricia Leahy Meghan Leahy DougAngela Ponte Dennis Poole Thomas Powers Rosemary J. PowersLean Pat Lee Heather Legere Philip Lemnios Laurie Leone John Powers Larry Powers Margaret Poydock Eric Prentis CityMichelle Leone Corinne Leung Emma& David Levy Vivien Li Councillor Ayanna Pressley Maria Puopolo Allyson Quinn BarryDon & Nancy Libby Russell Lindenfeltzer City Councillor BillRabinovitz Julia Radice Anne Raponi Elizabeth Regan SeanLinehan Donna LoConte Patrick Loftus Simon Lohmann RichardRegan Karen Regnante Patricia Reid Betsy Reilley Selectmanand Jane Lombard Saean Longiaru Frederick Looper MannyJohn Reilly, Jr. James Reilly Kathi-Anne Reinstein NathalieLopes Janelle Lott Carleen Loveday Mary Lowe Pat Lucia Rengifo-Alvarez Andrea Rex Kevin Richardson Mayor DanielArlene Lucid Erika and Matt Luksa Peter Luongo CongressmanRizzo Amy Rodriquez Patrick Ronan Chris Rooney Mark RooneyStephen F. Lynch Jen Lynch Barbara Macdonald Owen MacDonald Ian Ross Joe Rotondo Polly Rowe Carol Rubbicco Jill Rudnicki Erin Mackey Adrian Madaro Daniel Maguire & Adrienne Sacco Paul H. Rupp Mr. & Mrs. Larry Russo, Sr. Drew Russo KennyMaguire Dawn Mahoney Denny Mahoney Margaret Mahoney and Mary Ryan Brenda Ryan William Sabat Diana Sablone Christine Maier Duncan Maitland Douglas Maitland Jane ManningDebbie Santiano-McHatton Peter Sasso Laura Savard Kathy Kerry Manning Monica Manning Greg Mar Chris Marchi FrankSawtiawo Peter Schofield Christian Scorzoni Diane Scott &Marchione Steve Marcus Rep. Ronald Mariano Senator EdLawrence Nelson Maggie Scott Rachel Sensenig Richard SerinoMarkey James Marsh Jamiese V. Martin Maryellen Martin Paula Domenico Sestito James P. Shine Jason Silva Jeffrey SimmonsMatrinko Donna Mavromates M.F. Mayberry John Mayer Linda Dwayne Simmons Michael Sinatra Daniel Siracusa StevenMayo Roseann Mazzuchelli Katherine McAuliffe Mary McAuliffe Smalley Bill Spain Keith Spencer David Spillane Chris Spillane Kate McAuliffe Paul L. McCann, Jr. Rita McCarthy Neil B. McColeEllie Spring Allan Stein Marie Stein LaRoque John Stewart Patricia E. McCormick Travis McCready Joanne McDevitt EllenDebbie Stewart Jim Stewart Jeremy Stiles Rick Stockwood McDonough Joe McDonough Senator Thomas M. McGee MarkKaryl Stoia Charlie Storey Edmund Street William Strigler StefanMcGonagle Paul McGrath James McKenna Ronda Ivy McLeod Strojwas & Denise C. Whall-Strojwas Rebecca Suciu Richard K.Janeen and Stephen McNail Maureen McQuillen Thomas McShaneSullivan, Jr. Patricia Sullivan Joyce Sullivan Kaari Sullivan Sheila Meanley Doug Meccliter Mary Jo Meisner Manuel RonaldWilliam Sullivan Jacqueline Sussman James Sutherland JohnMendes Joan Meschino Sandy Meschium Rep. Aaron MichlewitzSutich Brian R. Swett Bob Sykes Nancy and Joe Tarantino Patricia Milano Doreen Miller Gail Miller James D. Mills TomJanice Tenzin Richard Terenzi Mark Thompson Cheryl Tobey Mills Amanda Miner Gigi Mirarchi Rose Mirasolo VickashMatt Tobin Lee Toma Ernie Torgersen Jody C. Tozier RichardMohanka Eric O. Moore Tim Moore Kerry Morris Kevin Morris Trubiano Robert Tucker J.R. Turco Carol A. Tye Robert Upton,Colby Morrissey Michael and Joanne Morrissey Michael C.Jr. Jared Val

tained the services of the CPA firm Raphael and Raphael LLP, whose findings and recommenda-tions are summarized in this report. In 2014, the Commission invited all those who took part in its process to review preliminary . findings and recommendations, in order to make certain that we got it right. This report reflects the hard work and commitment of so many who care deeply about the beaches .