Transcription
Data for 504 Completed Trials with MTAPartiesLiberty Mutual Insurance v.Progressive CasualtyBloomberg v. Market-AlertsPty LtdVolusion v. VersataDevelopmentVolusion v. VersataDevelopmentsalesforce.com, Inc. v.VirtualAgilityChicago Mercantile v. 5thmarket, Inc.Search America v.TransUnion IntelligenceGroupON v. Blue CalypsoStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, FWDMotion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)N/A, WDY, al 0378CBM2013-000449CBM2013-00049International SecuritiesExchange v. Chicago BoardOptions Exchange Inc.73564989/6/20133/2/2015FWDN/A, CancellationonlyN10CBM2013-00050International SecuritiesExchange v. Chicago BoardOptions Exchange ernational SecuritiesExchange v. Chicago BoardOptions Exchange Inc.82660449/6/20133/2/2015FWDNS1SS
PartiesAmerican Express v.MetaSearchPNC Financial ServicesGroup v. IntellectualVenturesAmerican Express v.Harvey LunenfeldMotionPoint v.TransPerfect GlobalCoreSource v. QualityHealthcareMotion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)NStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, quest DN/A, 2Trial urce v. 2/19/2016FWDNS23CBM2014-00182The Jewelry Channel v.America's CollectiblesNetworkSquare Inc. v. ThinkComputer Corp.Mitchell International v.Audatex North AmericaMitchell International v.Audatex North AmericaMitchell International v.Audatex North AmericaSquare Inc. v. ProtegrityCorp.Request forAdverseJudgmentRequest 2
No.24Trial 004734CBM2016-0004835CBM2016-00081PartiesTravelers Lloyds of Texas v.Integrated Claims SystemsTravelers Lloyds of Texas v.Integrated Claims SystemsEpicor Software Corp. v.Protegrity Corp.Informatica Corporation v.Protegrity Corp.Google, Inc. v.Contentguard Holdings, Inc.Chicago Mercantile v. FifthMarketGlobal Tel*Link Corporationv. Securus Technologies,Inc.Interactive Brokers LLC v.Chart TradingDevelopment, LLCCQG, Inc. v. Chart TradingDevelopment, LLCCQG, Inc. v. Chart TradingDevelopment, LLCCQG, Inc. v. Chart TradingDevelopment, LLCSAP America, Inc. v.Lakshmi ArunachalamStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, WD840228110/7/20144/18/2016FWDMotion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)N/A, CancellationonlyN/A, 2016N/AN/A78602225/19/201511/15/2016Request N/AS
No.36Trial 0039PartiesFederal Reserve Bank ofAtlanta v. BozemanFinancial LLCBally Gaming, Inc., d/b/aBally Technologies v. NewVision Gaming &Development, Inc.Bally Gaming, Inc., d/b/aBally Technologies v. NewVision Gaming &Development, Inc.Apple, Inc. v. UniversalSecure Registry LLCApple, Inc. v. UniversalSecure Registry LLCMiami InternationalHoldings, Inc. v. NASDAQInc.Miami InternationalHoldings, Inc. v. NASDAQInc.American Express Companyv. Signature Systems LLCConnexions Loyalty, Inc. v.Maritz Holdings Inc.Investors Exchange LLC v.Nasdaq, IncTerminationTypeFWDMotion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)NStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, 1/19/2019DismissedN/A, WithdrawnN/A85778135/3/201811/26/2019DismissedN/A, /2/201811/13/2019FWDN/A, FWDNS4
No.46Trial -00026IPR2012-0002757IPR2012-00042PartiesGarmin International, Inc.v. Cuozzo SpeedTechnologies LLCNichia Corporation v.Emcore CorporationIllumina, Inc. v. NationalScience FoundationIllumina, Inc. v. NationalScience FoundationIntellectual VenturesManagement, LLC v. Xilinx,Inc.Intellectual VenturesManagement, LLC v. Xilinx,Inc.Intellectual VenturesManagement, LLC v. Xilinx,Inc.Ariosa Diagnostics v. IsisInnovation LimitedIntellectual VenturesManagement, LLC v. Xilinx,Inc.Microsoft v. Proxyconn Inc.IDLE Free Systems, Inc. v.Bergstrom, Inc.Synopsys v. MentorGraphicsTerminationTypeFWDMotion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)NStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, /A, 0122/19/2014FWDNS5
No.58Trial 1IPR2013-00050PartiesIllumina, Inc. v. NationalScience FoundationRIM v. Mobile Media IdeasLKQ Corp v. ClearlampChimei Innolux Corp. (CMI)v. Semiconductor EnergyLaboratoryXilinx, Inc. v. IntellectualVenturesCBS Interactive v. HelferichPatent LicensingChimei Innolux Corp. (CMI)v. Semiconductor EnergyLaboratoryCorning, Inc. v. DSM IPAssets B.V.Corning, Inc. v. DSM IPAssets B.V.Corning, Inc. v. DSM IPAssets B.V.Corning, Inc. v. DSM IPAssets B.V.Corning, Inc. v. DSM IPAssets B.V.Corning, Inc. v. DSM IPAssets B.V.Corning, Inc. v. DSM IPAssets B.V.Statutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, rminationDate3/6/2014TerminationTypeFWDMotion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, dN/AN/A717110311/15/20125/1/2014FWDN/A, MootN/A696150811/15/20125/1/2014FWDN/A, MootN/A633966611/15/20125/9/2014FWDN/A, 20125/9/2014FWDN/A, MootN/A629818911/15/20125/9/2014FWDN/A, MootN/A632325511/15/20125/1/2014FWDNS6
No.72Trial 110IPR2013-00111IPR2013-00112PartiesChimei Innolux Corp. (CMI)v. Semiconductor EnergyLaboratoryChimei Innolux Corp. (CMI)v. Semiconductor EnergyLaboratoryAdidas AG v. Nike, Inc.Chimei Innolux Corp. (CMI)v. Semiconductor EnergyLaboratoryAvaya Inc. v. Network-1Security Solutions, Inc.Muchkin and Toys "R" Us,Inc. v. Luv N Care, Ltd.Oracle v. Clouding IP, LLCOracle v. Clouding IP, LLCMotorola Solutions, Inc. v.Mobile ScanningTechnologiesSmith & Nephew v.Convatec Inc.Oracle v. Clouding IP, LLCSmith & Nephew v.Convatec Inc.Scotts v. EncapSATA GmbH v. KANEKOXilinx, Inc. v. IntellectualVenturesStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, tion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, FWDSettledNN/ASN/A621893012/5/20125/22/2014FWDN/A, 0145/20/20146/26/2014FWDFWDFWDNNNPSS7
No.87Trial NumberIPR2013-00116PartiesGnosis v. 117Gnosis v. osis v. osis v. IPR2013-00122LaRose v. CapriolaInVue Security v.Mechandising 66351962/1/201396IPR2013-00136IFF v. US Dept. ofAgricultureIntelligent Bio-Systems v.Illumina, Inc.Dynamic Drinkware v.National GraphicsZTE v. ContentGuardHoldingsFWDRequest 00155Veeam v. SymantecVeeam v. SymantecVeeam v. SymantecVeeam v. SymantecEcowater Systems v.Culligan tion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)N/A, CancellationonlyN/A, CancellationonlyN/A, CancellationonlyN/A, CancellationonlyNN/AStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, P,N/A)N/AN/AN/AN/ASN/AY, Grant-in-partSFWDNS9/12/2014FWDN/A, 20147/29/20146/24/2014Request forAdverseJudgmentFWDFWDFWDFWDFWDNNNNNSSSSS8
No.102Trial R2013-00248PartiesZynga v. PersonalizedMedia Comm.Zodiac Pool Systems v.Aqua Products IncAthena Automation Ltd. v.Husky Injection Molding SysAthena Automation Ltd. v.Husky Injection Molding SysBAE Systems v. CheetahOmniSyntroleum v. Neste OilScentAir Tech. v. ProlitecGoogle/Apple v. JongeriousPanoramic TechSAP America v. Pi-Net Int'lSAP America v. Pi-Net Int'lSAS Institute v.ComplementSoft, LLCInvenSense v.STMicroelectronicsRackspace Hosting v.Rotaatable TechnologiesTerminationTypeSettledMotion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)N/AStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, edN/AN/A63269784/12/20139/19/2014FWDNSThe Board denied Patent Owner’s motion to amend on June 26, 2014. The Board granted the motion to amend on remand from the United StatesCourt of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.19
Statutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, on to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, 1310/30/2014FWDN/ANo.115Trial 8PartiesInvenSense v.STMicroelectronicsIntelligent Bio-Systems v.Illumina, Inc.MotivePower v. Cutsforth118IPR2013-00270MotivePower v. 272MotivePower v. ledN/AN/A128IPR2013-00400Athena Automation Ltd. v.Husky Injection Molding SysMicrosoft v. SurfCastJDS Unlphase Corp v. Fiber,LLCRespironics v. Zoll MedicalCorp.Tandus Flooring, Inc. v.Interface, Inc.JDS Uniphas Corp. v. Fiber,LLCSpectra Logic Corp v.Overland StoragePalo Alto Networks, Inc. v.Juniper NetworksGeneral Growth Properties,Inc v. George PeschkeN/A, CancellationonlyN/A, CancellationonlyN/A, N/A10N/AN/AS
No.129Trial R2013-00575142IPR2013-00578PartiesRiverbed Tech v. Silver PeakSystemRiverbed Tech v. Silver PeakSystemToyota Motor v. AmericanVehicular SciencesToyota Motor v. AmericanVehicular SciencesToyota Motor v. AmericanVehicular SciencesAtlanta Gas Light v. BennettJohnson Health Tech v.ICON Health & FitnessFacebook v. SoftwareRightsTrivascular v. ShaunSamuelsApex Medical Corp. v.RESMED LimitedTandus Flooring, Inc. v.Interface, Inc.Target v. DestinationMaternityDeLaval International AB v.DaritechNeste Oil v. SyntroleumStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, rminationDate12/30/2014TerminationTypeFWDMotion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)Y, Grant-in-part83705836/28/201312/30/2014FWDY, Grant-in-partS76502107/8/201311/12/2014FWDN/A, WithdrawnN/A80195017/8/201312/5/2014FWDN/A, WDN/A, A60075758/5/201312/3/2014FWDN/A, CancellationonlyN/A, /A64430949/6/20132/20/2015Request DNS11N/APN/A
No.143Trial R2014-00088PartiesUnified Patents, Inc. v.CloudingYamaha v. Black Hills MediaBroadcom Corp v. EricssonBroadcom Corp v. EricssonGoogle v. B.E. TechnologyMicrosoft v. B.E.TechnologyGEA Process Engineering v.Steuben Foods, Inc.Guangdong Xinbao v.Adrian RiveraCrocus Technology v. NewYork UniversityFacebook v. B.E.TechnologyFacebook v. B.E.TechnologyGEA Process Engineering v.Steuben Foods, Inc.Veeam Software Corp 1210/9/20136980469Motion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)NStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, P,N/A)PN/AFWDFWDFWDFWDN/A, DN/A, 2/20133/20/2015FWDNP12SSPPP
PartiesVeeam Software Corp v.SymantecInternational SecuritiesExchange v. Chicago BoardOptions ExchangeMedtronic, Inc. v. Troy R.NorredMedtronic, Inc. v. Troy R.NorredSilver Peak Systems, Inc v.Riverbed TechTerminationTypeFWDMotion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)Y, Grant-in-part 2Statutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, DN/A, /AN/AN/AN/ANo.156Trial ilver Peak Systems, Inc v.Riverbed /19/20134/1/2015SettledN/AN/A165IPR2014-00183Micro Motion, Inc. v.Invensys systemsMicro Motion, Inc. v.Invensys systemsMicro Motion, Inc. v.Invensys systemsAutel U.S. Inc. v. ServiceSolutionRequest forAdverseJudgmentRequest FWDNSThe Board denied Patent Owner’s motion to amend on April 23, 2015. The Board granted‐in‐part the motion to amend on remand from the UnitedStates Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.213
No.166Trial R2014-00393179IPR2014-00395PartiesOrganik Kimya San. ve Tic.A.S. v. Rohm and HaasSyntroleum Corp v. NesteOilToshiba Corp v. LGElectronicGreene's Energy Group v.Oil States EnergyFacebook v. EveryMDRiverbed Tech v. Silver PeakSystemNetFlix, Inc. v. OpenTVFord Motor Com. v. TMCFuel InjectionOrganik Kimya San. ve Tic.A.S. v. Rohm and HaasEuro-Pro Operating v.Acorne EnterprisesEuro-Pro Operating v.Acorne EnterprisesAmneal Pharmaceuticals v.Endo PharmaceuticalsMicro Motion, Inc. v.Invensys systemsMicro Motion, Inc. v.Invensys systemsTerminationTypeFWDMotion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)N/A, MootStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, 12/19/20131/26/20156/22/2015SettledFWDN/AN/A, MootN/AN/A62520041/14/20146/26/2015FWDN/A, 147/9/2015FWDNS83292161/16/20147/22/2015FWDN/A, 281/31/20146/25/2015FWDNS14
PartiesOxford Nanopore v. UAB &University of WashingtonGoogle v. MicrografxEdmund Optics v. SemrockEdmund Optics v. SemrockU.S. Dept. of HomelandSecurity v. Larry GoldenSamsung Electronics v.Black Hills MediaTerminationTypeFWDMotion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)N/A, CancellationonlyNN/A, MootN/A, MootNStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, 8/2015N/AN/AN/AN/ANSNo.180Trial 86IPR2014-00721Samsung Electronics v.Black Hills 410/9/2015FWDN/A, R2014-01246Torrent Pharm v. NovartisAGChurchill Drilling v.Schoeller-BleckmannBroad Ocean Motor v.Nidec Motor CorporationHTC Corp v. AdvancedAudio DevicesHTC Corp v. AdvancedAudio DevicesGeox SpA v. OutdryTechnologiesAAC Technologies Pte. v.MEMSMARTSemiconductorRequest forAdverseJudgmentRequest dN/AN/A15SN/AN/AS
No.194195Trial 14-01533PartiesTech 21 UK v. ZaggGlobal Tel*Link Corp v.Securus TechGlobal Tel*Link Corp v.Securus TechVMware v. CloudingAVX Corp. v. GreatbatchToshiba Corp. v. OpticalDevicesToshiba Corp. v. OpticalDevicesToshiba Corp. v. OpticalDevicesFord Motor v. Empire IPAmazon.com v.Personalized MediaCommunicationsAmazon.com v.Personalized MediaCommunicationsAmazon.com v.Personalized MediaCommunicationsAmazon.com v.Personalized MediaCommunicationsTerminationTypeFWDFWDMotion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)NNStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, 78057499/22/20143/8/2016FWDNS16
No.207Trial IPR2015-00465PartiesAmazon.com v.Personalized MediaCommunicationsEdmit Industries, Inc. v.SMARTDOOR HOLDINGS,INC.MasterImage 3D, Inc. v.REALD INC.AVX Corporation v.Manufacturers and TradersTrustSony MobileCommunications (USA) v.Sanmina CorporationApple, Inc. v. SanminaCorporationApple, Inc. v. SanminaCorporationShinn Fu Company ofAmerica, Inc. v. The TireHanger CorporationEpic Lift Systems, LLC v.Integrated ProductionServicesZhongshan Broad OceanMotor , Ltd. v. Nidec MotorCorporationTerminationTypeFWDMotion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)NStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, 016FWDNS17
No.217Trial IPR2015-00908227IPR2015-00998PartiesAlcohol MonitoringSystems, Inc. v. Soberlink,Inc.Mako Surgical Corporationv. Blue Belt Technologies,Inc.CaptionCall, LLC v. Ultratec,Inc.CaptionCall, LLC v. Ultratec,Inc.Array BioPharma Inc. v.Takeda PharmaceuticalCompany LimitedBlue Belt Technologies, Inc.v. All-Of-Innovation GMBHBaby Trend, Inc. v.Wonderland NurseryGoods, LTDBaby Trend, Inc. v.Wonderland NurseryGoods, LTDLuv N Care, Ltd. v.Munchkin, Inc.AVX Corporation v.Greatbatch LTDAmeriforge Group, Inc. v.Worldwide OilfieldMachine, Inc.TerminationTypeFWDMotion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)NStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, 59/19/2016FWDNS18
No.228Trial IPR2015-01221PartiesSamsung Electronics v.Nvidia CorporationSamsung Electronics v.Nvidia CorporationAnatomage, Inc. v. SironaDental Systems GMBHBrunswick Corp. v. CobaltBoats, LLCAmerican Megatrends, Inc.v. Kinglite Holdings, LLCAmerican Megatrends, Inc.v. Kinglite Holdings, LLCInstitut Straumann AG v.Sirona Dental SystemsGMBHSamsung Electronics , Ltd v.NVIDIA CorporationGlobal Tel*Link Corporationv. Securus Technologies,Inc.Global Tel*Link Corporationv. Securus Technologies,Inc.TerminationTypeSettledMotion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)N/AStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, 8/3/201663190064/15/201510/19/2016FWDN/A, 890685/19/201512/7/2016FWDN/A, WithdrawnN/AThe Board denied the motion to amend. The Federal Circuit vacated and remanded the denial of the motion to amend. The motion to amend ispending on remand.193
No.238Trial IPR2015-01920PartiesGlobal Tel*Link Corporationv. Securus Technologies,Inc.Global Tel*Link Corporationv. Securus Technologies,Inc.Pharmacosmos A/S v.Luipold Pharmaceuticals,Inc.Pharmacosmos A/S v.Luipold Pharmaceuticals,Inc.Creative ConsumerConcepts, Inc. v. Kid StuffMarketing, Inc.Coalition for AffordableDrugs VIII, LLC v. Trusteesof The University ofPennsylvaniaCoalition for AffordableDrugs VIII, LLC v. Trusteesof the University ofPennsylvaniaMcAfee, Inc. v. CAP, Ltd.CaptionCall, L.L.C. v.Ultratec, Inc.Repro-Med Systems, Inc.d/b/a RMS MedicalStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, rminationDate12/14/2016TerminationTypeFWDMotion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)Y, WDNS87835487/6/201510/7/2016FWDN/A, MootN/A86181358/28/20153/6/2017FWDN/A, MootN/A79322688/28/20153/6/2017FWDN/A, 3/8/2017FWDNS89614769/17/20151/12/2017FWDNS20
No.Trial rtiesProducts v. EMEDTechnologies CorporationActivision Blizzard, Inc. v.Acceleration BayActivision Blizzard, Inc. v.Acceleration BayActivision Blizzard, Inc. v.Acceleration BayActivision Blizzard, Inc. v.Acceleration BayActivision Blizzard, Inc. v.Acceleration BayActivision Blizzard, Inc. v.Acceleration BayAmerigen PharmaceuticalsLimited v. Shire LLCZimmer Biomet Holdings,Inc. v. Four Mile Bay, LLCMRSI SYSTEMS, LLC v.Palomar Technologies, Inc.Aceto AgriculturalChemicals Corp. v. GowanVolkswagen Group ofAmerica, Inc. v. West ViewResearch, LLCVolkswagen Group ofAmerica, Inc. v. West ViewResearch, LLCTerminationTypeStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, 3/2017FWDN/A, MootN/A67149669/24/20153/23/2017FWDY, Grant-in-partS68296349/28/20153/29/2017FWDN/A, MootN/A67013449/25/20153/23/2017FWDN/A, MootN/A67013449/25/20153/23/2017FWDY, Grant-in-partS68296349/28/20153/29/2017FWDY, 58210/2/20153/10/2017FWDN/A, 10/23/20154/28/2017FWDN/A, MootN/A829077811/17/20152/11/2017N/A, WithdrawnN/A829614611/17/20152/10/2017Request forAdverseJudgmentRequest forAdverseJudgmentN/A, WithdrawnN/A21TerminationDateMotion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)
ionDate4/5/2017Motion to AmendSubstituting ClaimsGranted or Grantedin-part (Y, N, N/A)N/AStatutory orSolelyProceduralDenial (S, P,N/A)N/ANSRequest forAdverseJudgmentFWDN/AN/ANSN/AN/AN/A, MootN/AN/A, CancellationonlyNN/AN/ASTerminationTypeRequest forAdverseJudgmentFWDNo.260Trial NumberIPR2016-00211PartiesMcAfee, Inc. v. CAP, PR2016-00214Google Inc. v. VedantiSystems LimitedMcAfee, Inc. v. CAP, 2911/25/20155/23/2017264IPR2016-00341McWane, Inc. v. TomWaughElekta Inc. v. VarianMedical Systems, A, CancellationonlyN/A, Moot270IPR2016-00502Twilio Inc. v. TelesignCorporationElekta Inc. v. VarianMedical Systems, Inc.Eli Lilly and Company v. TheTrustees of The Universityof PennsylvaniaElekta Inc. v. VarianMedical Systems, Inc.3SHAPE MEDICAL A/S v.Sirona Dental SystemsGMBHValeo North America, Inc. v.Schaeffler Technologies AG& Co. KGRequest , Grant-in-part22SN/A
No.271Trial IPR2016-00868281IPR2016-00906PartiesGeneral Electric Companyv. Rolls Royce PLCElekta Inc. v. VarianMedical Systems, Inc.Texas Association ofREALTORS v. POI SearchSolutions, LLCMylan Laboratories Limitedv. Aventis Pharma S.A.Apple Inc. v. PersonalizedMedia Communications,LLCApple In
27 CBM2015-00010 Informatica Corporation v. Protegrity Corp. 8402281 10/14/2014 5/9/2016 FWD N S 28 CBM2015-00040 Google, Inc. v. Contentguard Holdings, Inc. 7774280 12/9/2014 6/21/2016 FWD Y N/A 29 CBM2015-00061 Chicago Mercantile v. Fifth Market 7024387 1/14/2015 3/10/2016 Request for Adverse Judgment N/A N/A
