BEST PRACTICES Transition - Foundation For Community Association Research

Transcription

B E S T P R AC T I C E STransitionfrom Developer ControlTransition is a multistage process that gradually transfersa developer’s control of a community associationto the homeowner members. This report highlights:Roles & Responsibilities of the Developer and HomeownersBuilding the Transition TeamTransition Checklist and AgreementEstablishing a Safety Plan

BEST PR ACTICESTransitionfrom Developer ControlDeveloped in partnership with the Foundation for Community Association Researchand the National Association of Home Builders

TRANSITION FROM DEVELOPER CONTROLACKNOWLEDGMENTSThe Foundation for Community Association Research wishes to thank the National Association ofHome Builders for supporting the development and distribution of this Best Practices Report. In addition, the Foundation is indebted to the task force members who developed and updated this material:Primary AuthorMitchell Frumkin, p.e.,KipconrsJohn Carbone2021-2022 Transition TaskForce Member ContributorsMitch Frumkin, p.e.,rs,ChairDevala Janardan, esq.National Association of HomeBuildersEd Guttenplan, cpaWilkinGuttenplanJoseph CoughlinDavid N. Crump, Jr.,Robert Diamond,esq.esq.Douglas GillilandHoward Goldklang,Lynn Jordan,pcamesq.cpaMickel Graham,Paul Grucza,pcamcmca, ams, pcamJay Nussbaumesq.esq.E. Richard Kennedy,esq.Dave LarkinAlan Lubitzcmca, pcamDrew Mulhare,cmca, lsm, pcamSteven Y. Brumfield,Jerry Orten,Toll BrotherscpaJ. David Ramsey,Margey Meyer,cmca, ams,Kenneth Bloom,Christine LooneyVincent J. Hager, cirmsJacobson, Goldfarb & Scott, Inc.pcamReviewers of EarlierEditionsLynn BoyetCharles GrazianoMarjorie Meyer, cmca,CADRExperts llcRobert Diamond,Reed Smith, llpContributors to EarlierEditionsesq.Elton ParsonsRobert Travis,cirms Copyright 2022. Foundation for Community Association Research6402 Arlington Blvd., Suite 500Falls Church, VA 22042ISBN 978-1-59618-035-2Use PermissionReaders are encouraged to print and reproduce this Best Practices Report for use by community associationmanagers, board members, individual homeowners, and community association-related industry professionalswithout permission of Foundation for Community Association Research provided the following terms are met:This document must be reproduced in its entirety including the use permission statement; this document may notbe added to, modified, amended, or otherwise altered from the original as presented here. Readers and usersagree not to sell copies of this document or otherwise seek compensation for its distribution.Disclaimer: This document is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information regarding the subjectmatter covered. It is provided with the understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering legal,accounting, or other professional services. If legal or expert advice is required, the services of a competent professional should be sought.The Foundation for Community Association Research is dedicated to conducting research and acting as a clearinghouse for information on innovations and best practices in community association creation and management.As part of the Best Practices project, operations related to various functional areas of community associations—community harmony and spirit; community security; energy efficiency; ethics; financial operations; governance,green communities; natural disasters; reserve studies/management; strategic planning; and transition from developer control—have been developed since 2001.2FOUNDATION.CAIONLINE.ORG

TRANSITION FROM DEVELOPER CONTROLW H AT A R E B E S T P R A C T I C E S ?The Foundation for Community Association Research is proud tooffer function-specific Best Practices Reports in the communityassociation industry. The Foundation has developed best practicesin select topic areas using a variety of sources, including, but notlimited to, recommendations from industry experts and variousindustry-related publications.The outcomes of the Best Practices project include: Documented criteria for function-specific best practices.Case studies of community associations that have demonstrated success.The development of a showcase on community excellence.The benefits of benchmarking and best practices include: improving quality; setting high performance targets; helping to overcome the disbelief that stretched goals are possible; strengtheningcost positions; developing innovative approaches to operating and managing practices; acceleratingculture change by making an organization look outward rather than inward; and bringing accountability to the organization because it is an ongoing process for measuring performance and ensuringimprovement relative to the leaders in the field.The Foundation’s entire catalog of Best Practices Reports is available at foundation.caionline.orgas free downloads. Some printed versions are for sale at cost in Community Associations Institute’sbookstore at www.caionline.org/shop.FOUNDATION.CAIONLINE.ORG3

TRANSITION FROM DEVELOPER CONTROLCONTENTS1. WHAT IS TRANSITION?.52. TRANSITION BASICS.6Association Governance . 6Governing Documents . 63. THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PROCESS.64. ESTABLISHING A LEGAL FRAMEWORK.75. PROFESSIONAL PARTNERS.8Community Association Manager. 8Engineer/Reserve Specialist . 9Attorney. 9Certified Public Accountant. 96. INSURANCE.10Flood Insurance. 10Other Property Insurance. 10Fidelity Insurance and Directors and Officers Liability. 11Workers’ Compensation. 117. HOMEOWNER COMMITTEES.12Communication and Education Committee. 12Maintenance Committee. 12Insurance Committee. 13Rules Committee. 13Finance Committee. 14Management Committee. 14Transition Committee. 158. OTHER CONSIDERATIONS .15Motivating Involvement. 15The Effect of the Sales Pace. 15Transferring Common Area Maintenance. 16Transferring Financial Control. 16Transferring Budget Responsibility. 17Liability and Litigation. 189. ESTABLISHING A SAFETY PLAN.18Periodic Inspections. 19Reserve Studies and Funding . 20Maintenance. 2010. ADDITIONAL RESOURCES.22Books available from Community Associations Institute. 22Other Books of Interest. 22Best Practices Reports (available at foundation.caionline.org):. 2211. ATTACHMENTS.23Sample Condominium Transition Agreement and Release. 234FOUNDATION.CAIONLINE.ORG

TRANSITION FROM DEVELOPER CONTROLINTRODUCTIONSince the early 1970s, community associations—condominiumassociations, cooperatives, and homeowners associations—in theUnited States have become ubiquitous because they answer theneed for a housing alternative that offers not only a wide rangeof pricing options but also an array of services and activities notgenerally available with a single-family home purchase.When making a major purchase such as a home in a community association, one of the key concerns of all involved has to do with the expectations associated with what will be received. Whether theexpectations are presented as part of the governing documents, as part of the promotional literatureused to sell the units, or by the builder’s representative on the original board, if the actual purchasedoes not match the expectations created, disappointment and disillusionment may occur. This cantranslate into all parties spending a great deal of money and energy to resolve both perceived and realproblems. For this reason, thought must be given to the design and development of any communityassociation so that expectations are both realistic and realized.The purpose of this report is to provide associations (and, to some extent, developers/builders)with guidelines they can use to turn over a community association successfully and smoothly. Theultimate goal of transition from developer control is for the owners to be adequately prepared to takeover association governance and operations effectively.1. WHAT IS TRANSITION?Transition is a multistage process that gradually transfers a developer’s control of a community association to the homeowner members.Transition takes place over months and, sometimes, years. It is not defined by any specific actionor event and is implemented somewhat differently in each community.Transition begins when a developer makes the decision to build a housing development and culminates when ownership, governance, and responsibility lie completely with the homeowners associationmembers.The requirement for a formal transition process is a legal one, established by state law and thecommunity association’s governing documents.After turnover, the developer’s role is primarily related to construction, prior financial operations,and warranty issues. Transition does not end developer exposure to liability, as state law may continueto provide recourse for construction defects and warranties.FOUNDATION.CAIONLINE.ORG5

TRANSITION FROM DEVELOPER CONTROL2. TRANSITION BASICSAssociation GovernanceA primary component of the transition process is the transfer of governance responsibility from thedeveloper to the homeowners. Initially, the developer appoints the board members; these are typicallyhis or her employees. At turnover, the owners elect volunteer residents to represent them on the board.In some states, statutes or regulatory mandates, as well as each association’s governing documents,determine exactly how the transition process will occur and set specific benchmarks that must be reached.Board transition is a gradual process that allows homeowner members to receive training and gainexperience prior to turnover. A progressive transfer of control helps reduce conflict and avoid legalaction while the developer retains a substantial interest in the project.Governing DocumentsCommunity association governance is based on documents prepared and registered by legal counsel onbehalf of the developer. The association is createdby recording policies, procedures, and restrictions ininstruments typically called trust deeds; declarations;covenants, conditions and restrictions (CC&Rs); orcharters.BEST PRACTICE: The developercompiles all association governingdocuments, policies, and proceduresin a manual for the new board, theassociation, and the managementcompany. This document providesdetails on established policies andprocedures and how to enforcearchitectural policies and community rules and regulations.Other documents that the developer preparedmust also be transferred to the homeowner-controlledboard. This documentation includes the articles ofincorporation, association bylaws, and communityrules and regulations. It may also include deeds, surveys, utility plans, service contracts, inventories,inspection reports, operations manual, and a preliminary reserve study.3. THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PROCESSWhen starting a new community, the developer acquires a tract of land, prepares plans, and seeksapproval to build a community of defined size and facilities on the site. The developer determines whatshared facilities, common areas, and basic services will be necessary to make the community functionaland attractive to buyers. Working with engineers, architects, planners, and county or municipal agencies, the developer obtains necessary approvals, zoning reviews, building permits, and utility servicecontracts to create the community and make it operational.While the planning, permitting, and financing activity is underway, the developer also mustdetermine how the community will be operated and managed. The governing entity, the communityassociation, is legally chartered and registered, usually as a nonprofit corporation, with the developeridentified as the responsible party and primary agent for the association.Most developers build model homes and present a schematic model of how the community willlook when it is fully built and occupied. Potential buyers receive information packets explaining thatownership comes with defined responsibilities for association governance and management, which thebuyer must understand and accept.6FOUNDATION.CAIONLINE.ORG

TRANSITION FROM DEVELOPER CONTROLDuring the initial build-out phase, the developer appoints people to serve on the associationboard, and they are responsible for initial governance, financial operations, creating and enforcingcommunity rules, and providing basic services. Association activity at this stage includes payingtaxes, enforcing community rules, and arranging for snow removal, landscaping, trash removal, poolmaintenance, and other essential services. The developer may choose to involve homeowners in someaspects of association activity early on, but this is not required or typical. The developer’s employeesusually serve on the board before turnover.As the build-out process moves forward, theassociation may become legal owner of certain sharedphysical assets, known as common elements, and thedeveloper may invite several homeowners to join theassociation board to begin learning about governanceand community management.BEST PRACTICE: Early in the transition process, the developer adds aminority of homeowners to the boardor creates a homeowner advisoryboard to ensure that homeowners areprepared to assume leadership of thecommunity after turnover.In most states, the developer must relinquishcontrol of the association when community buildout or home sales reach a certain level, usually around 75 percent completion or at a certain time ifthe development will be under construction for a long time. At this point, the homeowners becomeincreasingly responsible for community governance, management, and operations. This phase of thetransition process is when most community associations make decisions about engaging professionalmanagement. Some associations start with “self-management” where volunteers who serve on theboard take responsibility for basic community operations. Most boards quickly discover the need forprofessional management services as the transition process becomes active.4. ESTABLISHING A LEGAL FRAMEWORKA legal framework is a broad system of rules that governs and regulates decision making, agreements,and laws that are recognized and enforceable. For community associations that legal framework isestablished in state statutes and the association’s governing documents. Therefore, establishing thelegal framework for transition is one of the most important parts of the transition process.The legal framework for transition, especially for condominiums, typically is established in broadterms in state statutes, which set minimum standards for the process. Nevertheless, developers havesubstantial latitude in determining the legal framework for transition when drafting a community association’s governing documents.BEST PRACTICE: Developers thoroughly understand the requirements established in statestatutes to draft the association’s legal documents appropriately.BEST PRACTICE: Developers make a conscious effort to balance their interests with theowners’ interests during the planning process. Developers provide protection for the owners and flexibility for themselves.FOUNDATION.CAIONLINE.ORG7

TRANSITION FROM DEVELOPER CONTROLBEST PRACTICES FOR ADDRESSING TRANSITION IN GOVERNING DOCUMENTS Governing documents address the developer’s right to control architecture, design,development, and sales, rather than controlling the board. Governing documents enable rather than impede the association’s business andfinancial management. No provision should be considered boilerplate; even the moststandard provisions should be drafted to aid in a successful transition. Governing documents specify procedures that encourage owner and residentinvolvement. Governing documents establish a transition team that includes not only developerappointed directors, but homeowners as well. Governing documents include provisions for alternative dispute resolution. Governing documents establish reasonable schedules for turnover that follow statelaw or lending agency guidelines and provide for a phased, increased number ofowners on the board.5. PROFESSIONAL PARTNERSOptimally, the developer hires a team of professionals who are knowledgeable in all aspects of community association operations to guide homeowners through the transition process. By creating a professionalteam, the developer encourages the best designed andoperated community association possible and reducesthe potential for litigation after turnover.BEST PRACTICE: Once the comSpecialists are available to help owner boards anddevelopers navigate the transition to owner control.These professionals include managers, attorneys, engineers, and accountants who can provide constructiveassistance in achieving a successful transition.Community Association ManagerIn many cases, the first manager retained to representthe community is hired by the developer. Hiring themanager initially retained by the developer has itsadvantages and disadvantages.The developer’s manager is familiar with the property, however, that affiliation may cause the perception ofa conflict of interest. Furthermore, the developer’s manager may not specialize in community association management. Knowledge of, and particularly certification in,community association management outweighs whateverfamiliarity a manager may have with a specific property.8munity has been turned over tothe homeowners, the board’s firstaction is to hire a professionalcommunity association manager who will help identify and hireother professional partners. Thenew manager has professional credentials or designations such asCertified Manager of CommunityAssociations (CMCA), AssociationManagement Specialist (AMS),Large-Scale Manager (LSM),and Professional CommunityAssociation Manager (PCAM).Homeowner majority boards consider hiring the developer’s manager only if that person has thesequalifications.FOUNDATION.CAIONLINE.ORG

TRANSITION FROM DEVELOPER CONTROLEngineer/Reserve SpecialistAn engineer’s role during transition is to prepare a transition study and a reserve study.The reserve study is a budgeting tool with recommendations for projecting when and how much to allocate forfuture repairs and replacement of common assets.The transition study will determine whether thecommon elements have been constructed in generalconformance with the design documents and that nodefects exist and whether the preliminary reserve study isadequate.BEST PRACTICE: The association engineer conducts a formaltransition study that includesan analysis of all common elements and a reserve study forfuture budgeting.BEST PRACTICE: The association’s engineer recognizes thedefinition of adequate, which isthat sufficient funds are available when replacements arerequired.AttorneyAttorneys, more than any other professionals, determinea community’s success or failure. Because they draft the governing documents, they provide thefoundation upon which homeowners will build an association.BEST PRACTICE: Developers retain attorneys who specialize in community association lawto draft association governing documents.BEST PRACTICE: The association board retains an association attorney as soon as the transition process begins. In most states, it is a violation of legal ethics for the attorney whorepresented the developer or builder to represent the association also during the transitionprocess.BEST PRACTICE: The developer is represented by one attorney and the association byanother.BEST PRACTICE: Rather than unilaterally selecting an association attorney without homeowner board member input, the developer compiles a list of attorneys for homeownerboard members to consider, interview, and select.Certified Public AccountantCommunity associations have unique financial circumstances that make it imperative that the board hire anaccountant who is familiar with community associationfinances and has experience working with them.FOUNDATION.CAIONLINE.ORGBEST PRACTICE: The transitionboard retains its own accountant torepresent the association. This personspecializes in and has experience withproviding financial, auditing, and taxservices for community associations.9

TRANSITION FROM DEVELOPER CONTROL6. INSURANCEInsurance provides protection for losses throughout the transition process, so those involved do not sufferfinancial losses or pass on a loss to someone else. Responsibility for insurance coverage transitions fromdeveloper to homeowners based on several factors.Flood InsuranceUnder the National Flood Insurance Program, the Standard Flood Insurance Policy has three forms: thegeneral property form, the dwelling form, and the residential condominium building association policyform. A building’s ownership type and occupancy will determine which form should be used and howmuch the policy premium will be. Only eligible properties located in participating communities qualifyfor NFIP coverage.BEST PRACTICE: Developers remain knowledgeable of National Flood Insurance Programrequirements and insure the association accordingly.BEST PRACTICE: Developers educate homeowner board members about flood insurancecoverages and prepare them to take over insurance responsibilities.BEST PRACTICE: The association board reviews policy limits annually or when improvementshave been made to ensure the association meets all requirements for the NFIP coverage.Other Property InsuranceThe broad term property insurance includes, but is not limited to, special form buildings and contents,equipment and machinery, earthquake, building law/ordinance, and sewer and drain backup.Developers must provide property insurance on all completed common area buildings, structures,and contents until a master policy can be written in the association’s name.Best Practice: The developer maintains property insurance on residential buildings untilthe first title is conveyed to an owner in a building under construction. At that time, thebuilding will be added to the association’s policy.Best Practice: Association boards ensure that all coverages meet the minimum standardsset by statutory law and the association’s governing documents.Best Practice: Until all residential building is completed, the developer carries a builders’ riskor installation floater, which would also cover common area buildings until their completion.10FOUNDATION.CAIONLINE.ORG

TRANSITION FROM DEVELOPER CONTROLOnce an association master policy can be written, the association should cover the completedcommon area buildings, structures, and contents. Coverage for the completed residential buildings’value should be added to the association’s master policy when the first unit in that building is conveyed to an owner.Coverage is usually written on a single-entity basis, which means the units will be insured to replaceor repair them to the same kind and quality originally offered or built by the developer. Alterations,additions, improvements, betterments, and upgrades made by owners would not be insured by theassociation.BEST PRACTICE: Developers keep owners informed about individual insurance policiesthey might need for their units and which personal items in the unit are not covered by theassociation policy.BEST PRACTICE: Owners purchase property insurance through a homeowner’s policy (HO6) orequivalent that includes personal contents, improvements, betterments, alterations, additions,upgrades, property loss assessment, and enough to cover the association’s master policydeductible.Fidelity Insurance and Directors and Officers LiabilityFidelity insurance protects an association from employeetheft, and directors and officers liability insurance (D&O)protects against lawsuits for breach of fiduciary duty. Whenan association becomes a legal entity, it should purchaseboth fidelity insurance and D&O liability coverage. Fidelityinsurance may be subject to Federal National MortgageAssociation guidelines that require a limit equal to threemonths operating budget plus the entire reserve account.Workers’ CompensationWorkers’ compensation insurance protects the association ifan employee suffers a work-related injury or illness. Even ifthe association does not have its own employees, it needsworkers’ compensation coverage since it could becomeresponsible to someone it does not consider an employee.BEST PRACTICE: The developer hasworkers’ compensation coverage for allemployees involved in the GBEST PRACTICE: Fidelity anddirectors and officers liabilitycoverages are in force from thetime the association board istotally developer-controlleduntil it is totally ownercontrolled.BEST PRACTICE: Insurancecoverages meet the minimumstandards set by law andthe association governingdocuments.BEST PRACTICE: The association obtainsseparate and distinct workers’ compensation coverage when it becomes a legalentity.11

TRANSITION FROM DEVELOPER CONTROL7. HOMEOWNER COMMITTEESHomeowner committees provide the developer with valuable information about homeowners, anopportunity to cultivate homeowner board members, and a cadre of volunteers to help with numeroustasks. Also, homeowner committees allow new residents to become familiar with association living andto have a voice in their community.Homeowner committees are advisory, especially in theearly stages of development, when the developer makesthe final decisions. Subsequently, committees will remainadvisory and report to the board regardless of who controls it.In the early sales period, homeowner committees primarily address the community’s social needs. They helpnew owners become familiar with association living andmake them feel welcome. Committee activity in moresubstantive areas may occur at this stage, but it will beminimal.BEST PRACTICE: By the timehalf the homes are sold, theassociation has several majority homeowner committees thatreport to the board; and, beforeturnover is completed, all committees are functioning.BEST PRACTICE: Each committee has a statement of responsibilities and clear goals.The more common homeowner committees include:C

Toll Brothers Contributors to Earlier Editions John Carbone Joseph Coughlin David N. Crump, Jr., esq. Robert Diamond, esq. Douglas Gilliland Howard Goldklang, cpa Charles Graziano Lynn Jordan, esq. E. Richard Kennedy, esq. Dave Larkin Alan Lubitz Margey Meyer, cmca, pcam Drew Mulhare, cmca, lsm, pcam Jerry Orten, esq. Elton Parsons Robert .