Operations And Maintenance Plan For Lead-Based Paint

Transcription

Operations and Maintenance Planfor Lead-Based PaintFormer Pioneer Press Building345 Cedar StreetSt. Paul, MinnesotaPrepared forDougherty Mortgage LLCAndPioneer Apartments, LLLPWarning: This document may not be reproduced or excerptedfrom in substantial part without the expressed writtenpermission of Braun Intertec Corporation.Braun Intertec Corporation11001 Hampshire Avenue SouthBloomington, MN 55438Project B1702158.03May 19, 2017

Table of ContentsDescriptionPageOperations and Maintenance Plan . 1for Lead-Based Paint . 1A.Introduction. 2A.1.Purpose. 2A.2.Background. 2B.Objectives and Elements of the O&M Program . 2C.Notifications . 2C.1.Elements of notification . 3C.2.Methods OF Notification . 3C.3.Required information . 3C.4.Short Term Worker Acknowledgment . 4D.Labels and Signs. 4E.Training . 4E.1.Training for O&M Coordinator . 4E.2.Training for Maintenance Employees . 5E.3.Training for Abatement Contractors . 5E.4.Medical Surveillance and Employee Protection Program . 5F.Maintenance and Renovation Permit System . 6F.1.O&M Coordinator Permit Issuance Procedure . 6F.2.Special Work practices for renovation and remodeling. 6G.Periodic Surveillance - Reinspection . 7H.Emergency Response Procedures . 7I.Certification . 7List of AppendicesAppendix A: Lead-Based Paint Guidance for HUD Field StaffAppendix B: Lead-Based Paint Summary TableAppendix C: Example Notification Letter and FormAppendix D: Example Worker Acknowledgment FormAppendix E: Example Documentation of Training FormAppendix F: Renovate Right BrochureAppendix G: Example Maintenance and Work Permit System FormAppendix H: Example Periodic Surveillance FormFormer Pioneer Press Building – Lead Based Paint O&M Plan (May 19, 2017)

A.IntroductionA.1. PurposeBraun Intertec Corporation was retained by Dougherty Mortgage LLC, to develop a Lead-Based PaintOperation and Maintenance (O&M) Program Manual for the property located at 345 Cedar Street in St. Paul,Minnesota (the Property). The purpose of the O&M Program Manual is to outline procedures to effectivelymaintain and manage lead-based paint (LBP) in place until it must be removed due to a scheduledrenovation or demolition, or its condition warrants removal. Included in Appendix A is the Lead-Based PaintGuidance for Owners and HUD Field Staff, prepared by U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development(HUD), which provides additional information for property owners about LBP compliance.A.2. BackgroundThe Property is occupied by an eight-story office structure with a full basement, penthouse, and elevatorequipment room on the roof. It was constructed in 1955 and encompasses approximately 162,000 totalsquare feet. The building is constructed of brick, concrete and steel. The typical interior finishes includedsheetrock/joint compound, plaster, floor tile, carpeting, lay-in ceiling panels, ceiling tiles, and vinyl sheetflooring. There is an elevator shaft located in the west central area of the building and connects thebasement to the eighth floor. There are mechanical/duct rooms on the northeast and southeast cornersof each floor, and main vertical pipe chases centered on the north perimeter wall, south perimeter wall,and central area just north of the elevator shafts. The exterior of the structure has concrete and brickwalls with a rubber membrane roof system. There is a single-story maintenance garage(fleet maintenance building) to the west of the office building that has concrete block interior walls,brick and mortar exterior walls and a rubber membrane roof system.Braun Intertec completed a Pre-Renovation Hazardous Building Materials Inspection and Lead-BasedPaint Inspection Report dated April 13, 2017 (2017 Inspection). Based on the 2017 Inspection,the identified LBP-coated components included interior components: plaster, ceramic and concretewalls; plaster columns; plaster, and wood ceilings; concrete floors and stair risers; metal valves; woodwindow casing; metal pipes. LBP was identified on the following components located on the exterior ofthe buildings: metal garage door lintel, jambs, and guards; metal access door and door lintel; metaldecorative gate; and parking lot striping on asphalt. A summary table of the identified LBP components isincluded in Appendix B.

Lead-Based Paint O&M Program ManualProject B1702158.03May 19, 2017Page 2B.Objectives and Elements of the O&M ProgramThe objective of the O&M Program is to minimize the potential for lead exposure to anyone at the Property.The specific elements of the O&M Program are as follows: Notification practices and proceduresTraining for the O&M Coordinator and key maintenance personnelMaintenance and Renovation permit systemSpecial work practices for maintenance activitiesSpecial work practices for renovationsEmergency response proceduresPeriodic surveillance programRecordkeepingFor purposes of implementing this O&M Program, only qualified personnel will perform LBP abatementrelated work activities. Adequate training will be provided to key maintenance personnel who will beresponsible for monitoring the building condition and be able to effectively identify areas of potentialhazards. In addition, an individual will be assigned the role of O&M Coordinator. This person will beresponsible for, and trained to, implement the O&M Program and assure that guidelines and provisions ofthe program are met. All abatement activities will be conducted in accordance with all applicable federal,state and local regulatory requirements.C.NotificationsNotification is a key element of the O&M Program. Building occupants in units or areas where a renovationand/or repair project is planned that will involve the disturbance of LBP will be notified in advance of work ofthe potential hazards and the precautions that will be taken.Employees and outside vendors who are aware of the presence of LBP are less likely to disturb the materials.Therefore, notification is considered a key element of the O&M Program.

Lead-Based Paint O&M Program ManualProject B1702158.03May 19, 2017Page 3C.1. Elements of notificationThe elements of notification include: Notification of employees and outside vendors.Notification of building occupants, when appropriate or required.The notification serves two purposes:1. It alerts affected parties to potential hazards in the buildings; and2. It provides basic information on avoiding related hazards.C.2. Methods OF NotificationNotification of occupants and other affected individuals may be accomplished in the following ways: Distributing a notice or letter.Holding awareness training for all maintenance personnel.Issuance of a permit system to all outside contractors.C.3. Required informationThe following information should be available to notified individuals: What has been done to protect occupants.Types and locations of LBP hazards at the Property.How individuals can avoid disturbing LBP.How maintenance personnel are dealing with assumed LBP to prevent lead dust.What will be done periodically and over the long-term to protect the health and safety of thebuilding occupants?Name and telephone number of the person responsible for LBP related activities.An example notification letter is included in Appendix C. Documentation of individuals notified should bekept on file. An example notification form used to document each individual notified is also included inAppendix C. This format or a similar format will be utilized as part of this O&M Program.

Lead-Based Paint O&M Program ManualProject B1702158.03May 19, 2017Page 4C.4. Short Term Worker AcknowledgmentDocumentation of notification should be completed to outside vendors (such as a plumber or electrician)who conduct activities which may disturb LBP within the facility. An example format to use for thisdocumentation is included in Appendix D. This format or a similar format will be utilized as part of thisO&M Program.D.Labels and SignsAll outside licensed abatement contractors and/or certified renovators involved with a renovation and/orrepair project that involves the disturbance of LBP within the facility, must post signs at the entrance and theperimeter of the regulated area of the project. All signs and postings of the project must be in accordancewith the OSHA Standards and all other applicable regulations.E.TrainingThe O&M Coordinator shall ensure that initial and on-going training requirements in the O&M Programare met. The O&M Coordinator shall maintain all employee training records for thirty years beyond theemployee’s last date of employment. An example format for documentation of training is included inAppendix E. This format or a similar format will be used as part of this O&M Plan.E.1.Training for O&M CoordinatorThe O&M Coordinator is responsible for overseeing all O&M activities. He/she must be familiar withappropriate procedures for operations and maintenance activities involving lead-based paint andlead hazards.The O&M Coordinator shall complete an initial course of training in lead hazards. The course should addressthe following areas at a minimum: History and uses of lead.Health effects of lead.Legal and liability considerations related to lead.Criteria for hazards assessment of lead hazard screens.Building assessment results.

Lead-Based Paint O&M Program ManualProject B1702158.03May 19, 2017Page 5 E.2.Personal protective equipment for lead-based paint.Regulatory requirements pertinent to lead-based paint.Requirements for record keeping and report preparation concerning lead-based paintoperations and maintenance activities.Training for Maintenance EmployeesAll maintenance employees shall attend an awareness course on lead hazards. At a minimum, trainingshould cover: Information regarding lead and its various uses and forms.Information on the health effects associated with lead and medical surveillancerequirements.Locations of LBP.Guidance for recognition of damage, or deterioration of LBP.Use of work permit system.Emergency situations.Contact person(s) for questions regarding LBP.Additional training is required if maintenance personnel will conduct LBP abatement activities. It must benoted that the awareness training is not sufficient for employees to conduct LBP abatement activities.E.3.Training for Abatement ContractorsAll outside contractors and their workers performing abatement work shall be licensed and certified toperform the specified abatement work by the State of Minnesota.E.4.Medical Surveillance and Employee Protection ProgramIt is assumed that maintenance personnel at the Property will not be involved in LBP abatement activities.Therefore no medical surveillance program is required.

Lead-Based Paint O&M Program ManualProject B1702158.03May 19, 2017Page 6F.Maintenance and Renovation Permit SystemF.1.O&M Coordinator Permit Issuance ProcedureMinimizing inadvertent disruption of LBP during maintenance and/or renovation is the responsibility of theO&M Coordinator. It may be prudent to initiate a permitting system, where all work orders or requests areapproved by the O&M Coordinator either verbally or using written forms. This permit system is an effectiveway of controlling disruption to LBP during maintenance and renovation activities.The permit system should require that all requests for activities that may disturb LBP be submitted forauthorization to proceed. The O&M Coordinator should physically inspect the area to make sure no LBP ispresent in the work area prior to giving authorization to proceed.The O&M Coordinator will assess the situation to determine whether or not the maintenance activity canproceed without disturbing the LBP or if the activity will need to be modified to avoid disturbance or bedeferred until the LBP in the area can be properly removed or abated by a licensed contractor.Contractors/vendors conducting work which will involve disturbance of any of the identified or suspectedLBP components should comply with the new U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Renovation,Repair, and Maintenance Program Rule (40 CFR Part 745) (RRP Rule). This rule requires contractorcertification, tenant notifications, lead-safe work practices, clearance verification and record keeping.A copy of the EPA’s Renovate Right brochure is included in Appendix F and provides information aboutthe EPA RRP Rule.Example formats for written documentation of the permit system are included in Appendix G.F.2.Special Work practices for renovation and remodelingBuilding renovation, remodeling or building system replacement can be a cause for disturbance of LBP.Activities such as moving walls, adding rooms, or replacing ceilings or floors may result in the disturbance ofLBP. All areas shall be evaluated prior to renovation or remodeling to determine if LBP will be disturbed.

Lead-Based Paint O&M Program ManualProject B1702158.03May 19, 2017Page 7G.Periodic Surveillance - ReinspectionPeriodic surveillance is recommended from the date the O&M Program begins. Identified or assumed LBPshould be inspected whenever an apartment is vacated and/or when personnel access an apartment formaintenance purposes in an area with LBP.This periodic inspection should be conducted by the O&M Coordinator or by an individual that has theproper training. The purpose of the periodic surveillance is to ensure that changes in material condition aredocumented. If maintenance personnel note a change, the change will be documented. An example formatfor this documentation is included in Appendix H. The form includes space to document material location,visual inspection, condition change, the type of change and recommendations for response actions.H.Emergency Response ProceduresAn emergency response situation is not likely to occur due to the presence of the identified LBP at theProperty. However, lead dust can occur during maintenance or renovation projects (see Section 6.2).It is recommended that one or more local LBP abatement contractors are identified that are capable ofresponding on short notice.I.CertificationTHIS LEAD-BASED PAINT OPERATIONS AND MAINTENANCE PROGRAM WILL BE IMPLEMENTED UPONEXECUTION BY THE UNDERSIGNED.Dated this day of , 201As Certified By:Entity NameAddress (City, State, Zip)SignaturePrint Name & Title

Appendix ALead-Based Paint Guidance for HUD Field Staff

Lead-Based Paint GuidanceforOwners and HUD Field Staff

Table ContentIntroduction . iiiIInstructions for Owners . .A. Owner Communication with Contractor. 1. Scheduling Inspections. 2. Reporting. 3. Appeal Process . B. Owner Communication with Residents .1. Pre-Inspection .2. Post-Inspection C. Owner Communication with HUD. 1. Pre-Inspection . 2. Post Inspection. D. Owner Compliance Responsibilities. 1. Determining Applicable Compliance. 2. Calculating level of Assistance . .3. Determining Course of Action (Lead Hazard Control Plan). 4. Requesting HUD Assistance in Funding the LHCP . .5. Documentation of Compliance. .11123444555556667IIInstructions for Project Managers (PM).A. PM Monitoring/Responsibilities. . .1. Monitoring Pre-Inspection Activities .2. Monitoring Owner’s Actions.3. Monitoring LBP Inspection Results in REMS. .B. PM Analysis.1. Processing Owner’s Request for Funding.2. Verifying Owner’s Calculation of Level of Assistance .3. Compliance/Clearance Reports.777788889IIIIVVSpecial Instructions for Contract Administrators (CA). 9Frequently Asked Questions . 10Attachments. . 11Appendix AAppendix BAppendix CCompliance with the Lead Safe Housing Regulation is our objective.

Lead-Based Paint ComplianceInstructions for Owners and HUD Field StaffIntroductionThe Lead Safe Housing Rule contained in 24 CFR 35 became effective September 15,2000. This document summarizes the rule’s requirements for various multifamilyhousing programs and properties receiving Section 8 and other rental assistanceconstructed before 1978. The multifamily programs covered by the new rule are:(1) new applications for mortgage insurance (currently in development); (2) HUD-ownedand Mortgagee-In-Possession (MIP) properties; and (3) properties receiving projectbased rental assistance. Properties with units receiving no more than 5,000 of projectbased rental assistance annually have different requirements than properties with unitsreceiving more than 5,000 annually.To ensure the rule’s effective implementation, HUD has developed a transition plan witha three-part strategy. The goals of the transition plan are to: (1) establish transitionperiods during which geographic areas lacking capacity to comply with the rule can buildthat capacity and focus their resources on the housing stock with the greatest need;(2) provide training assistance to jurisdictions that need help building capacity; and(3) supply funding to reduce the costs of complying with the rule.The Office of Healthy Homes and Lead Hazard Control (OHHLHC) is assisting the localmunicipalities in building capacity to comply with items 1 and 2. In working with theindustry, Multifamily Housing is funding a volunteer lead-based paint inspection programto assist Owners in complying with item 3. This program requires the Real EstateAssessment Center (REAC) to contract for the Inspection/Risk Assessment (IRA).Similar to the physical inspection process, REAC will manage the IRA with a contractorselected by the Department. The contractor will conduct the IRA and report the findingsto the Hub/PCs, the Owner, the OHHLHC and Headquarters.REAC contacted all Owners with properties receiving Section 8 and other forms of rentalassistance provided to the tenants (Loan Management Set-Asides, Section 221(d)(3)with Below Market Interest Rates, and Section 236 with Rent Supplement Assistance) toascertain whether or not they were interested in participating in the program. HUDprovided the listing of Owners who expressed interest in the program to the contractorand the contractor contacted each Owner to schedule the IRA. The IRAs startedJune 4, 2001, and HUD will submit the first reports to the Owners, Hub/PCs, theOHHLHC and Headquarters during the first week of August of this year. REAC and theOHHLHC developed the IRA as a protocol to comply with the Environmental ProtectionAgency standards.The Multifamily Housing Project Manager (PM) will perform follow-up and monitoringactivities of the Owners participating in the Lead-Based Paint (LBP) inspection program.Each segment of the inspection process will consist of some PM involvement. Item II,page 8 of these instructions provides the procedures for Hub/PC staff monitoring(Project Managers).iii

IInstructions for OwnersA. Owner Communication with Contractor1. Scheduling InspectionsInitial Notice: The REAC contractor(s) will contact the owner by telephone tonegotiate a date for the LBP inspection and obtain ownership information i.e.,on-site property manager, contact person, property address, and ownershipentity. The negotiated date must be at least 30 calendar days from the dateREAC contacted the owner. The owner is required to provide preliminarynotification of the inspection to residents at least 15 days prior to the inspectiondate. (For further discussion of resident notification instructions see the sectionon Owner Communication with Residents on page 4). During scheduling of theinspection, the contractor will ascertain if the owner has submitted a Transfer ofPhysical Assets (TPA) application. If this has occurred, the contractor mustdetermine the status of the application before scheduling the IRA. If HUDapproves the TPA before the projected date of the IRA, the contractor mustobtain the new Owner’s approval to conduct the IRA. If a TPA approval occursafter the projected date, the contractor may schedule the IRA.If the Owner pays off the loan and/or opts-out of the Section 8 contract and thetenants use Section 8 certificates or vouchers, the contractor will still conduct theIRA.Second Notice: The REAC contractor is required to send a second notice to theOwner by certified mail 15 calendar days before the scheduled IRA date toconfirm the date and any required and/or requested ownership information. Thecontractor will include in this notice a checklist entitled, “Information for theResidents on Lead-Based Paint Inspection/Risk Assessment” for distribution toeach resident at least five days prior to the inspection. (See Appendix A).Similar to the Physical Inspections conducted by the REAC protocol, thecontractor will not inspect all of the units in the project. Based on theconstruction date of the property, the contractor will inspect a pre-determinednumber of units. The contractor will provide the number of units to the Owner 15days prior to the scheduled inspection. Neither the Owner nor the tenants willknow which units will be inspected until the date of the IRA.1

2. ReportingAfter completing the inspections for a property, the contractor will submit theresults electronically to REAC within 10 business days. REAC will review theresults using a checklist developed in conjunction with the OHHLHC. REAC willreview the results to determine if the report is acceptable. After REAC acceptsthe report, it will mail only the summary report of the results to the Owner and theOHHLHC. The Hub/PC will receive an electronic copy. To receive a copy of theentire report, the Owner must send a written request to:Anthony Carey, Deputy Project ManagerATTENTION: Lead-Based Paint1280 Maryland Avenue, SW, Suite 800Washington, DC 20024-2135The inspection report will identify whether there is NO LEAD PAINT or LEADPAINT and/or LEAD PAINT HAZARDS on the property. If there is LEAD PAINT,the report will identify the location, level of hazard, and acceptable or optionalways of mitigating the hazards.(a) Summary Report and Findings: HUD will provide a summary report tothe Owner. (The actual report is over thirty pages and will be available tothe Owner upon request). The Hub/PC, and the OHHLHC will receive acopy of the entire report. The entire report will consist of the i)(ix)(x)(xi)(xii)(xiii)A summary statement that specifies if the property contains leadhazards with an identification of the particular location.Property information and description.A summary of each identified lead hazard and a lead hazardmanagement category (i.e., high, moderate or low).A summary statement of the dust sample results averaged byeach component sampled (i.e., floors, windowsills, windowtroughs), room type, and the average compared to the applicablestandard level to determine if the results are project-wide.A summary statement of the overall condition of each building byaddress and evaluated samples.A summary statement listing the individual tested units and thetotal number of tested units.The total number of separate tests performed for eachhomogeneous component/substrate pair and the total number ofpositive or negative lead results.The lead classification result, positive or negative for eachidentified homogeneous component/substrate pair in theinspected property.High priority locations that received a detailed examination andenvironmental sampling during the risk assessment.A tabular listing of all testing combinations classified as leadbased paint.A tabular listing of all lead-based paint hazards.Actions required of the owner.Owner(s) name or representative present during theinspection/risk assessment.2

(b)Clearance Reports: The Owner of property with identified LeadBased Paint (LBP) and/or Lead Paint Hazards (LPH) must submita Lead Hazard Control Plan (LHCP). A clearance technician thathas been certified by the unit of local government to review andapprove the work will issue a clearance report once the Ownercompletes reduction activities (See Post-Inspection, page 5).Reduction activities include paint stabilization, maintenance,rehabilitation, interim controls or abatement. A clearanceexamination will follow these activities. In addition to therequirements described in the rule, individual states and localitiesmay have additional or more stringent requirements.As with the other notification requirements, the Owner must notifythe residents upon clearance report issuance. The Owner mustpost the clearance report in a visible, accessible site on theproperty or distribute it to each individual unit. The Owner mustprovide access to a file of all IRA reports in the project officeduring normal business hours for at least one year after all relatedLBP activity is complete for review by the tenants and potentialtenants.3. Appeal ProcessIf the Owner disagrees with the IRA, the Owner may appeal. To appeal, theOwner is required to request a re-evaluation of the IRA review within 15 calendardays of receiving the results. The request must be in writing and forwarded to:Director, Real Estate Assessment CenterATTENTION: Lead-Based Paint1280 Maryland Avenue, SW, Suite 800Washington, DC 20024-2135The re-evaluation may include an analysis of the information the inspectorcollected, a complete re-inspection of a sample of the property, or a laboratoryanalysis of the paint chip samples. If the paint chips samples are used as part ofthe re-evaluation, the Owner must repair the damage.If the Owner disagrees with the re-evaluation results, the Owner may contract foranother inspection with a contractor at the Owner’s expense. If the Ownercontracts for another IRA, the Owner may not charge the costs to the project asan expense. Handbook 4350.1 only permits the use of project funds for testing.The Owner should be advised that the inspection must comply with the3

standards provided in the regulations or the Departments’ protocol. The Ownermust submit this inspection to REAC at the above address within 30 businessdays from the Owner’s notification to REAC to contract for another inspection.The contractor must certify that the inspection meets regulations or theDepartment’s protocol.If REAC’s review of the Owner’s inspection concludes that the property is notcontaminated, HUD may reimburse the Owner the expense of contracting for theinspection.B. Owner Communication with ResidentsAlthough the Owner may request an appeal of the IRA report, the Owner mustpost all information regarding the IRA process in a visible, accessible site on theproperty or distribute it to each individual unit.1. Pre-InspectionAs provided in Item I, Scheduling Inspection, the Owner must notify residents atleast 15 days prior to the inspection date. The exact units that the contractor willinspect are unknown until the day of the inspection. The Owner must notify allresiden

operations and maintenance activities. E.2. Training for Maintenance Employees All maintenance employees shall attend an awareness course on lead hazards. At a minimum, training should cover: Information regarding lead and its various uses and forms. Information on the health effects associated with lead and medical surveillance requirements.