Expanding Service Provisions For The Homeless

Transcription

IN THE SHADOW OF PLENTY?UNDERSTANDING AND IMPROVING SERVICE PROVISIONFOR THE HOMELESS IN RURAL COUNTIESJeffry A. Will, Director, CCI and Associate Professor of SociologyTracy Milligan, Research Assistant,andTim Cheney, Coordinator Research and Data AnalysisNortheast Florida Center for Community InitiativesDepartment of Sociology, Anthropology, and Criminal JusticeUniversity of North Florida1

IN THE SHADOW OF PLENTY?UNDERSTANDING AND IMPROVING SERVICE PROVISIONFOR THE HOMELESS IN RURAL COUNTIESJeffry A. Will, Director, CCI and Associate Professor of SociologyTracy Milligan, Research Assistant,andTim Cheney, Coordinator Research and Data AnalysisNortheast Florida Center for Community InitiativesDepartment of Sociology, Anthropology, and Criminal JusticeUniversity of North FloridaINTRODUCTION1Most economic indicators suggest that the United States has been riding a wave of greateconomic growth for the past few years. While many citizens would agree that they arebenefitting from the prosperity of the United States, there is an invisible society that has yet toexperience such prosperity. Once again, the economic Arecovery and growth" that has continuedfor over 3 years in Jacksonville has done little to reduce thenumber of homeless persons encountered in the JacksonvilleA.Although SubstantialAnnual Homeless Census and Survey. Indeed, the countprogress has been made incontinues to increase. After more than a decade of researchobtaining funding andand examination, there is still no panacea for addressing thelearning about effectiveneeds of homeless persons. In Duval County alone, theapproaches, much morehomeless population has increased by almost 21% fromremains to be done.@February 1999 to November 1999. There were almost 600more homeless persons counted in November than inMartha Burt, et al, in theFebruary 1999.December 1999 H.U.D.report, AHomelessness:In 1984, researchers began stressing the need to seePrograms and the Peoplehomelessness as multi-faceted, with differing problems,They Serve.needs, desires, and directions for various sub-groups withinthis population. After over two decades of research andadvocacy, understanding the extent of homelessness and themechanisms for overcoming this social problem remainelusive. The number of homeless persons, and the problems they face remain a central concern1 Research for this report was made possible in part by a grant award from the ASA Sydney S. Spivack Program inApplied Social Research and Social Policy.2

of many service providers across the country. Much of the homeless population requiresassistance to survive, ranging from economic to mental health needs. Numerous local agencies,organizations, and governmental units have formed homeless coalitions in order to best provide amultitude of services. There are twenty state funded homeless coalitions throughout the state ofFlorida. According to the 1999 Annual Report on Homeless Conditions in Florida, the numberof homeless persons searching for assistance from community agencies increased 17 percentfrom last year. The Emergency Services and Homeless Coalition(ESHC) of Jacksonville wasestablished in the late 1980's and is now comprised of more than 60 individuals and communitybased organizations. The ESHC of Jacksonville has been diligent in trying to coordinate andprovide the necessary services for the homeless. In 1998, concerned citizens of St. Johns Countyformed and organized the Emergency Services and Homeless Coalition, Incorporated.Between 1991 and 1999, Sociologists from the University of North Florida and TheNortheast Florida Center For Community Initiatives (CCI) worked with the Emergency Servicesand Homeless Coalition of Jacksonville to conduct an annual intensive homeless census, coupledwith the interviewing of hundreds of homeless persons in an attempt to better understand thecondition of homeless persons in Jacksonville and their needs. Conducted in mid-Winter eachyear, the census attempted to do a full count of all homeless persons in Duval County, FL, as partof the needed documentation for Federal Emergency Management Agency, The State of Florida,and United Way funding.The outcome of the homeless census and survey has had a dramatic impact on serviceprovision for many homeless persons in Jacksonville. A multi-service site , the I. M. SulzbacherCenter for the Homeless, was opened in Winter, 1996. The facility is a showcase for the effortsof numerous community activists and organizations who made the development of this center areality. In June, 1996, the facility also dedicated the new Health Care for the Homeless Clinic atthe Sulzbacher Center, making the facility a true full service community effort. During the pasttwo years, an eye clinic and a dental clinic have also been funded through grant proposalsdeveloped out of information gained from the census and survey.Although the Emergency Services and Homeless Coalitions of Jacksonville and St.Johns County have been successful in implementing services for the homeless, there is not asimilar organization for other counties surrounding Duval County. In this report, we present thefindings from an 8month effort to inventory available services for homeless adults and childrenin the rural counties in Northeast Florida (Region IV). These counties include: Baker, Clay,Nassau, and St. Johns. Surveys were distributed to agencies and organizations throughout allfour counties. Over 300 surveys were distributed to agencies, individuals, and other contactsthroughout these counties, with 129 responses. This represents an overall response rate of33.3%. Clay County had the highest response rate (37.0%) with St. Johns (34.0%), Nassau(27.3%), and Baker (21.4%) following respectively.3

Although there are no annual, systematic, homeless counts for these counties, thehomeless population of each county can beestimated using the Barry UniversityEXHIBIT 1Method.2 This method estimates thatBarry Method County Estimationsapproximately 0.31 percent of all persons arehomeless. Exhibit 1 produces the homeless Baker County68estimates for each county based on theClay County433population estimates from April 1,1999.Nassau County178These estimates were obtained from theSt. Johns County353University of Florida Bureau of Economic(based on population estimates 4/1/99and Business Research (BEBR). It isimportant to note, these figures are onlyrough estimates of homeless populations. Inthe past, homeless reports for Duval County have counted many more homeless persons than theBarry Method estimated.In this report we will discuss the variety of services available to the homeless in theseareas and the extent to which these services are provided. Services that assist homeless childrenand the typology of homeless children are also discussed. Information from this report willassist these communities in evaluating the services that are currently provided and determiningwhat needs remain to be addressed.COUNTY HISTORIES AND INFORMATION BAKER COUNTYBaker County of Florida is a small rural community that lies twenty-five miles west ofJacksonville. It consists of 585 square miles of land. Today the county is made up of the townsof Macclenny, Sanderson, Glen St. Mary, Olustee, and Taylor. Baker County was established in1861 and named after the Honorable James McNait Baker, a former judge of the Fourth Judicial*District of the State of Florida. The economy of Baker County has relied heavily upon theOsceloa National Forest. The residents of Baker County primarily rely on agricultural productsas a source of income.The population of Baker County has increased from 15,289 in 1980 to 21,879 in April1999. The population density is 37.40 people per square mile. The cost of living is one of thelowest in the State of Florida. Baker County is ranked 59 out of 67 counties, with a cost ofliving 7.94% below the state average. The median and average cost of renting a dwelling unit is2As this report was being prepared, the Decennial Census effort was underway, whichincluded attempts to count the homeless in these counties. Data on the Census will not beavailable until 2001.4

approximately 375 and 362. Graduation rates for 1996-1997 were 82.26%, compared to thestate average of 73.18%. CLAY COUNTYClay County is a mixture of suburban and rural communities, located just south ofJacksonville. Clay County covers over 601 square miles of land. The county has fourincorporated municipalities - Green Cove Springs, Orange Park, Keystone Heights, and PenneyFarms and one unincorporated area, Middleburg. It is said that Middleburg, originally known asAWhitesville@ is the oldest settlement in the state. In 1858, Clay County was formed from aportion of Duval County and named for Henry Clay of Kentucky, then, a top political figure inthe nation.Clay County s population has more than doubled over the past two decades from 67,052in 1980 to 139,658 as of April 1999. The population density is approximately 232.38 people persquare mile. The current unemployment rate in Clay County is below 4%, which is one of thelowest in the state of Florida. Clay County ranks as having the 20th highest cost of living inFlorida. The cost of living in Clay county is 3.18% below the state average. In 1997, themedian household income was 39,824. School Match ranked Clay County Schools in the top14% of the nation for providing Awhat parents want@ for their children. The major industry forClay County is in concrete, asphalt, lumber, minerals, and dairy. NASSAU COUNTYNassau County is both a rural county, and a resort area. It is located just north ofJacksonville. The county consists of 671 square miles. It was formed in 1824 and named afterthe German Duchy of Nassau. Today the incorporated areas within its borders are: Hilliard,Callahan, and Fernandina Beach.Nassau County had a population of 57,381 as of April 1999. The population density is85.52 residents per square mile. Nassau County ranks as the 37th county in the cost of livingchart. Its cost of living is 6.31% below the state average. Nassau County relies primarily uponpaper products and tourism for income. ST. JOHNS COUNTYSt. Johns County is a combination of urban, suburban, and rural communities and islocated south of Jacksonville. The county covers an area of 609 square miles. St. Johns Countyconsists of three incorporated municipalities: St. Augustine, St. Augustine Beach, and Hastings.The county was one out of the two first formed counties in Florida by General Andrew Jacksonin 1821. At the time, it comprised of all land east of the Suwaney River. The county was namedfor the St. Johns River, which Spanish explorers called ASan Juan Baptista@.The population in St. Johns County has also more than doubled over the past two decades5

from 51,303 in 1980 to 113,941 in April 1999. There are approximately 193.1 people per squaremile in St. Johns County. The unemployment rate for St. Johns County is 3.0%, one of thelowest in the state. St. Johns County has the 19th highest cost of living in Florida, which is3.08% lower than the state average. The median household income for the county is 33,960.Though tourism is the major industry in St. Johns County, the economy is also supplemented byaeronautics, aluminum extrusion, auto parts manufacturing, and health food preparation.INVENTORY OF SERVICES AVAILABLE TO THE HOMELESSTargeted populations. Many of the organizations and agencies (55%) from Region IVtarget their services to all persons irrespective of age, gender, needs, and/or problems. Morethan 22% of the respondents indicated they focus only on servicing children and youth. Onlyseven percent target their services only toward adults. The physically frail and/or medicallycomplex are specifically targeted by only one organization. No organization or agency focuseson providing services to only male adults.Outreach services. Table 1 presents the most frequently cited outreach services providedin Region IV. Mental health counseling service is the most common outreach service providedby the responding organizations in the region. In addition to these top five services, emergencyfood, elderly services, and street outreach are also provided. Despite the variety of outreachservices provided, 31.0% ofthe organization in Region IVdo not provide any outreachTable 1 Outreach Services Providedservices to the homeless. Notfor the Homeless in Region IVonly were the outreachservices examined in RegionMental Health Counseling Services31.0%IV, but they were also studied Case Management26.2%in each county. Most of theSubstance Abuse Treatment Referrals19.0%outreach services provided by Primary Health Care Referrals11.9%the respondents from ClayYouth Services9.5%County are mental healthcounseling services and case*Respondents were able to answer more than one outreachmanagement. Over half of the service, therefore, the percentages do not equal 100%.St. Johns County respondingorganizations claimed thatthey do not provide any outreach services at all. Only one respondent provides outreach servicesfor the elderly and only one respondent provides for veterans. Both organizations are in ClayCounty.Emergency shelter/housing. Affordable housing continues to be a seeminglyinsurmountable barrier for the homeless in Duval County. Forty-four percent of the homelesssurveyed in Duval County in November 1999 stated that shelter or affordable housing is the mostimportant service to them (n 234). Therefore, it was important to examine the types of sheltersand housing available, if any, in Region IV. Over three fourths of the organizations do not6

provide any type of emergency shelter or housing. Only six (15.4%) offer emergency shelters, atleast one organization in each county. St. Johns County and Clay County each had twoorganizations or agencies providing emergency shelter and were also the only counties thatprovided any numbers for available beds. One agency in Clay County provides 42 beds forwomen and their children. Anagency providing emergencyshelter in St. Johns County hasTable 2 Emergency assistance services providedsix beds total: for male andin Region IVfemale children and youth. Theorganization in Baker CountyUtilities23.8%that supplies emergency shelter is Rent21.4%classified as an American RedClothing19.0%Cross Emergency Shelter.Food Bank/Pantry19.0%Food Vouchers16.7%Not only is it essential toprovide emergency shelters, but *Respondents were able to answer more than one emergencypermanent and low-incomeassistance service, therefore, the percentages do not equalhousing are also crucial in aiding 100%.the needy and the homeless. Theonly respondent that providespermanent housing, allowing residents to stay at least two years, is located in Clay County. Thesame organization is the only respondent to offer permanent supportive housing with a limit oftwo or more years and provide support services. St. Johns and Clay County were the onlycounties with an organization that provides low-income housing. There are 32 low-income unitsfor the elderly (62 years and over) provided at the St. Johns County agency. The respondentfrom Clay County providing low-income housing has 106 beds available for families.Using the numbers provided, Clay County has a total of 156 emergency, low-income, andpermanent housing beds. As mentioned earlier, using the Barry Method, there are approximately433 homeless persons in Clay County. Using these figures, there is clearly a shortage inavailable beds for homeless persons. St. Johns County also has an insufficient number of bedswith a total of forty-four beds and an estimate of 353 homeless persons.Emergency assistance services. Much of the homeless population requires not only anaffordable place to call home, but they also need assistance with obtaining food, medical care,and other everyday necessities. Respondents were asked what emergency assistance servicesthey provide. As with the provision of outreach services, almost one third (31.0%) of theorganizations do not provide any type of emergency assistance service. Table 2 lists the fivemost frequently cited emergency assistance services available and the percent of respondents thatoffer them. Assistance with utilities is the most offered emergency assistance service in RegionIV. Although four of the organizations or agencies help with meals, no one offers a soupkitchen, a place for needy persons to gather and have a hot, balanced meal. Two of the threerespondents from Baker County offer at least one type of emergency assistance service.Although seven respondents from Clay County said they do not provide any type of emergency7

assistance service, help with utilities was the most often cited emergency assistance service fromClay County organizations. Clothing is the most frequently provided emergency assistanceservice in St. Johns County.Support Services. The provision of support services in these counties was also examined.Such services may include mental and primary health care, education assistance, assistance withobtaining food, children andyouth services, or legal aide.Table 3 Support service provided for the homeless in RegionTable 3 provides a look at the topIVsupport services provided inCase Management31.0%Region IV. Only fourFood Bank/Pantry28.6%respondents claim not to provideLife Skills Training/Parenting28.6%any type of support service. CaseRent/Mortgage Assistance28.6%management is offered mostUtility Payment23.8%frequently by the organizations inClothing21.4%Region IV. The only supportTransportation Assistance21.4%services not provided by anYouth Services21.4%organization is a soup kitchen orassistance in obtaining a state*Respondents were able to answer more than one support service,I.D. card. The most frequenttherefore, the percentages do not equal 100%.support service in Clay County iscase management. St. JohnsCounty offers life style training,youth services, and clothing morethan any other support service.Meals served. Although none of the organizations claimed to provide a soup kitchen,some do provide meals for their clients during their stay in the program. More than threequarters of those that responded to these questions claimed they did not serve any meals at all in1998 or 1999. Many of those that do serve meals indicated they served over one thousand mealsduring 1998. Only one organization served less than one thousand. They served five meals in1998. From January 1, 1999 to June 30, 1999 five respondents cited that they had served morethan one thousand meals. One served almost five hundred fifty meals and one only served threemeals.Initiation of services. Services can be initiated by the clients being served or targeted,caseworkers, court, or by other means. Many agencies utilize multiple referral methods. Almostthree quarters (73.2%) of the organizations in Region IV have caseworkers that refer theirorganization to clients. We find a different pattern for agencies with regard to court referrals,with only 26.8% of the respondents having respondents enter their program in this manner. Over80 percent of the respondents also initiate their services with self-referrals. More than half of theorganizations use other means to initiate services. Some of these other means are throughreferrals from other agencies, schools, churches, and physicians or hospitals.Barriers to services. Although services may be available, they are not always easily8

accessible. If the clients cannot utilize the services available, they might as well not exist.Respondents were asked to rank possible barriers to their services. One such barrier rated wastransportation. A majority of the organizations (58.3%) ranked transportation as a severe barrier,while only slightly over 5 percent believed it is not a barrier. At least fifty percent of therespondents from each individual county saw transportation as a severe barrier.The capacity limit of an organization can also hinder or prevent the provision of services.The limited capacity of the organization or agency was cited as a moderate barrier by 51.5% ofthe respondents and 15.2% of them ranked it as not a barrier. Most of the respondents from eachcounty believed limited capacity to be a mild or moderate obstacle, with the exception of NassauCounty. Nassau County only had two responses to this particular question; one believed it to bea moderate barrier and the other saw it as a severe barrier.The availability of child care can also be a problem for some that are searching forservices. Over fifty-five percent of the respondents cited child care as a moderate barrier to theirprograms, while just over 15 percent indicated it is not a barrier for their clients. At least half ofthe organizations from each Clay, Nassau, and St. Johns County cited chid care as a moderateobstacle. Two of the three Baker County respondents ranked child care as not a barrier.Many homeless persons do not have access to a telephone, which can be an obstaclewhen trying to obtain particular services. Over forty-three percent of the respondents sawtelephone access as a mild barrier for their clients. Only 10 percent cited it as a severe problemand more than twenty-three percent believed that it is not a problem. At least fifty percent of therespondents from Clay, Nassau, and St. Johns County viewed access to a telephone as a mildbarrier.Disabled persons also encounter barriers to service that many others do not. Althoughthere are laws that help protect disabled persons from being denied accessability into publicfacilities and businesses, some of our respondents cited that access for disabled persons is abarrier. Almost 47 percent stated it is a mild barrier, while slightly over six percent saw it as asevere barrier. Over thirty-seven percent claimed that access for the disabled is not a barrier totheir program. At least half of the respondents from Clay and St. Johns Counties saw access forthe disabled as a mild barrier. Almost every respondent from Baker and Nassau County did notsee accessability as a barrier.The hours of operation of an agency can provide another obstacle for prospective clients.None of the respondents cited the hours of operation as a severe barrier, but over a forth ofthem thought it to be a moderate barrier. Over a third believed it is not an obstacle to theirservices. Most of the respondents in Baker and St. Johns County viewed the hours of operationas a mild barrier. A majority of the organizations from Clay County did not see their hours ofoperation as a barrier. One respondent from Nassau County did not see a barrier, while the otherorganization saw it as a moderate obstacle.Some agencies require clients to have a state I.D. card in order to receive services. With9

no permanent address, this can be difficult for homeless individuals to obtain. No organizationclaimed the lack of a state I.D. card as a severe barrier. In fact, more than 53 percent believed itnot to be a barrier at all. Slightly over thirty-five saw it as a mild barrier. Most of therespondents from St. Johns County view state I.D. cards as a mild barrier, while most of the ClayCounty respondents do not see it as an obstacle. Only one respondent from Nassau Countyanswered this question and did not see it as a barrier. Only two respondents from Baker Countyresponded to this particular question; one did not see state I.D. cards as a barrier and one saw itas a moderate obstacle.In addition to the barriers listed on the survey, two respondents believed that there areother barriers to their programs. Interestingly, both listed funding as the other barrier and theyboth indicated that it is a severe barrier to the services they provide.Unmet needs of homeless adults. Although there may be many organizations andagencies providing a multitude of services for needy and homeless adults in Region IV, theremay still be many other needs that go unmet in these communities. Respondents were asked tolist their perception of the five most important unmet needs for homeless adults. Notsurprisingly, shelter or housing was listed by just over 80 percent of the respondents.Transportation was also a frequently listed unmet need (45.2%). Among shelter andtransportation, food or soup kitchen, medical care or insurance, and counseling or mental healthservices were also listed as unmet needs for homeless adults. Dental care, school, rentalassistance, phone/address, referrals, and emergency assistance were also listed. Shelter andtransportation are the most cited unmet needs for homeless adults by Clay, Nassau, and St. JohnsCounties individually. Baker County respondents cited shelter and counseling the most. It isimportant to note that these unmet needs are the respondents perception of unmet needs. Whenasked how aware their organization or agency is of the services provided in their county, almostsixty percent claimed that their agency s awareness is very or somewhat limited. Only 16percent believed their organization has a good awareness of the services provided for thehomeless in their county.SERVICE COORDINATION AND REFERRALSService coordination. One critical aspect of delivering services to clients is thecoordination of the services. People needing the services may not know where they are offeredand therefore, organizations and agencies can act as contacts for their clients. Slightly overeighty percent of the respondents coordinate services with other agencies. When an agency doesnot provide a particular service, they can refer their clients to other agencies to receive therequired service. More than 57 percent refer clients to agencies locally as well as out of theircounty, and thirty percent of the respondents refer clients only to local agencies. Of those thatrefer to agencies outside of their area, 27.9% refer an average of ten percent of their clients toDuval County organizations or agencies. Almost 10 percent of the organizations refer one infour clients to Duval County agencies. One respondent refers about fifty percent of their clientsfor necessary services to Duval County. This was an organization in Clay County and it refersthe highest percentage of clients to Duval County.10

Organizations refer their clients to other agencies for a number of services. Substanceabuse treatment was the most frequently cited service that agencies make the most referrals foroutside of their county. Services for shelter/housing and medical problems are also referredquite frequently. Other services that are referred the most to out-of-county agencies include:dental, mental health and legal aid. Individually the counties cited different services that arereferred to agencies out of their county. Shelter was listed most frequently by Clay Countyrespondents as the service most referred to agencies outside of their county. Two thirds of theSt. Johns County respondents cited substance abuse treatment as the most referred service toagencies outside of their county. The most locally referred service for a majority of therespondents is food. Public assistance service is also a major referral for many of theorganizations. Shelter, mental health, rent and utility assistance, and domestic violence wereamong those services listed as most frequently referred to another local agency. A comparisonof the individual counties shows that they locally refer different services. One quarter of theClay County respondents refer shelter and food the most to other local agencies. One out of fiveof the respondents from St. Johns County refers clients in need of food, mental health, and rentand utility assistance the most to other local agencies. Organizations from Baker County citedthat public assistance and truancy services are referred to other local organizations the most.Rent and utility services are referred the most to local agencies by a Nassau County organization.Table 4 provides the most frequently cited local and out-of-county referred services fromRegion IV.Table 4 Services referredAnother CountySubstance Abuse TreatmentMedicalShelter/Housing9.3%7.0%7.0%Another Local AgencyFood/Meals11.6%Public Assistance9.3%Mental Health7.0%Rent/Utility Assistance7.0%Shelter/Housing7.0%Organizations that coordinate services. When asked what organizations they coordinateservices with, Salvation Army and Florida Department of Children and Families were namedmost frequently. United Way, religious organizations, schools, and hospitals were also cited asorganizations they coordinate services with. Respondents were also asked from which agenciestheir agency receives referrals. Salvation Army was once again one of the top cited, along withschools and the Sheriffs Office/Courts. Other agencies from which respondents receive referralsare United Way, County Health Department, and religious organizations.THE POPULATION SERVEDRace, age, and sex. Understanding the population being served is very important indeciding what services need to be provided. Because of this, the respondents were asked to give11

a breakdown of the race, age, and sex of their clients. Although 75% of the respondents claimedto systematically collect and store data about their clients, less than ten respondents answeredthese questions. With such a small response we cannot interpret the data. We believe that lackof adequate data to report on activities represents a major challenge facing these services.Reasons adults seek services. To gain more knowledge of the population being served bythe organizations or agencies in Region IV, the respondents were asked why adults request theirservices. A majority of respondents (57.1%)claimed that adults seek their services as aresult of a loss of income. Table 5 exhibits the Table 5 Reasons adults need services inRegion IVmost frequently listed reasons. Mild ormoderate mental illness, poor or unsafe living57.1%conditions, and spiritual needs were cited once Loss of IncomeSubstanceAbuse/Addiction28.6%each as reasons for adults using their services.25.7%By far, Clay County respondents cited the

mile in St. Johns County. The unemployment rate for St. Johns County is 3.0%, one of the lowest in the state. St. Johns County has the 19th highest cost of living in Florida, which is Though tourism is the major industry in St. Johns County, the economy is also supplemented by