Inter Agency Guidelines For Case Management & Child Protection

Transcription

INTER AGENCY GUIDELINES FORCASE MANAGEMENT &CHILD PROTECTIONTHE ROLE OF CASE MANAGEMENT IN THE PROTECTION OF CHILDREN:A GUIDE FOR POLICY & PROGRAMME MANAGERS AND CASEWORKERSJANUARY 2014

Front page image: Tdh/Mélanie Rouiller

CONTENTSAcknowledgements.4GLOSSARY & WORKING DEFINITIONS.5Acronyms and Abbreviations.7INTRODUCTION TO THE GUIDELINES.8Background to the Development of the Guidelines.8Format of the Guidelines.9SECTION 1 – Principles & Practices.1 0What is Case Management?.1 0Guiding Principles for Case Management.13SECTION 2 – Establishing and Strengthening Case Management Services.2 0Contexts for Developing / Introducing Case Management.2 0Analysing External and Internal Capacities and Constraints.2 4Analyse Internal Agency Capacity.2 8Complementary Activities as Alternatives to Establishing Case Management.3 2Essential Elements of Designing & Implementing a Case Management Services.34SECTION 3 - Case Management Steps.4 4STEP 1 - Identification and Registration.4 6STEP 2 - Assessment.4 8STEP 3 - Case Planning.5 4STEP 4 - Implementing the Case Plan.5 5STEP 5 - Follow Up and Review.5 8STEP 6 - Case Closure.61CASE STUDIES.63Appendices for Reference:.6 6APPENDIX 1: Caseworker competency and skill framework.6 7APPENDIX 2: Roles of Supervisors vs. Caseworkers.7 0APPENDIX 3: Sample of child protection/ child safeguarding policy.7 2APPENDIX 4: Samples of registration forms.7 8APPENDIX 5: Samples of assessment forms.8 7APPENDIX 6: Risk assessment guide.9 3APPENDIX 7: Sample of case planning form.9 7APPENDIX 8: Sample of follow up form.9 8APPENDIX 9: Sample of case conference report.9 9APPENDIX 10: Case closure form.101APPENDIX 11: Case transfer Form.102APPENDIX 12: Sample of data protection protocol.103APPENDIX 13: Sample of informed consent.108Child protection working group Inter agency guidelines 3

FOREWORDAnyone who has ever done case management knows what a complicated andoften difficult task it is.In regular situations this is already the case. In emergency situations - where levelsof injury, physical violence, sexual violence, psychosocial distress, associationwith armed groups and separation are amplified - interventions are even morecomplex. The number of child protection cases is high, problems are multifaceted,social welfare staff is often overstretched and resources are more limited.We know that a time-limited, hourly session with a child will not guarantee his/her protection. Careful assessment and support of (and for) family members andcaregivers as well as liaison with community members, school personnel, courtrelated personnel, and child welfare agencies increases the likelihood that thechild will remain safe and promote healthy relationships with others.These guidelines have been developed at an inter-agency level to complement theagreed standard on Case Management (Minimum Standards for Child Protectionin Humanitarian Action, 2012). They aim to provide a common understanding andstep-by-step guidance on how to do case management. They put the child at thecentre of the intervention, focusing on child friendly procedures and language.I urge agencies working in the field of Child Protection in Emergencies to use andadhere to these guidelines in order to jointly provide the best possible support tothe children that we serve.Katy Barnett,Coordinator Global Child Protection Working Group4Child protection working group Inter agency guidelines

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTSNumerous organisations and individuals were involved in developing these guidelines; theChild Protection Working Group would like to express their thanks to everyone who hascontributed information and ideas.In particular thanks are due to the members of the Child Protection Working Group(CPWG)’s Case Management Taskforce (The International Rescue Committee, Save theChildren, Child Frontiers, Terre des Hommes, UNICEF, Plan International, InternationalMedical Corps and independent consultants).Special thanks also go to the European Community Humanitarian Office (ECHO) andthe Office for US Foreign Disaster Assistance (OFDA) of the United States Agency forInternational Development for making the development of these guidelines possible.Child protection working group Inter agency guidelines 5

GLOSSARY & WORKINGDEFINITIONSAlternative Care:Alternative care is the care provided for children by caregiverswho are not their biological parents. This care may take theform of informal or formal care. Alternative care may be kinshipcare; foster care; other forms of family-based or family-like careplacements; residential care; supervised independent livingarrangements for children.1Case Management:The process of helping individual children and families throughdirect social-work type support, and information management.Caseworker:The key worker in a case who maintains responsibility for thechild’s care from identification to case closureChild Protection:The prevention of and response to abuse, neglect, exploitation,and violence against childrenChild Protection System:The set of laws, policies, regulations and services needed acrossall social sectors – especially social welfare, education, health,security and justice – to support prevention and protectiveresponses inclusive of family strengthening”.2Non-discrimination:The principle that distinctions should not be made betweenpeople or communities on any grounds of status, includingage, gender, race, colour, ethnicity, national or social origin,sexual orientation, HIV status, language, religion, disability,health status, political or other opinion.Protective factors:Conditions or attributes in individuals, families, communities, orthe larger society that, when present, mitigate or eliminate riskin families and communities that, when present, increase thehealth and well-being of children and families.31. Alternative Care in Emergency toolkit. Extended care guidance. Inter Agency Working Group on Unaccompanied andSeparated Children2. UNICEF Global Strategy, 2008.3. Preventing Child Maltreatment and Promoting Well-Being: A Network for Action, Resource Guide. 20136 Child protection working group Inter agency guidelines

Psychosocial Support:Care and support which influences both the individual andthe social environment in which people live and ranges fromcare and support offered by caregivers, family members,friends, neighbours, teachers, health workers, and communitymembers on a daily basis but also extends to care and supportoffered by specialised.4Referral:The process of formally requesting services for a child ortheir family from another agency (e.g. cash assistance,health care, etc.) through an established procedure and/orform; caseworkers maintain overall responsibility for the caseregardless of referrals.Resilience:The ability of children and their families to deal with, and recoverfrom, adversity and crisis, influenced by individual characteristicsand external factors like: diversity of livelihoods, copingmechanisms, life skills such as problem-solving, the ability toseek support, motivation, optimism, faith, perseverance andresourcefulness.Risk:The likelihood that a hazard will happen, its magnitude and itsconsequences; the probability of external and internal threats(e.g. armed attacks, natural disasters, gender-based violence)occurring in combination with individual vulnerabilities (e.g.poverty, disability, membership of a marginalized group)5Risk Assessment:Methodology to determine the nature and extent of risk bytaking into account potential hazards and existing conditionsof vulnerability that together could harm children and theirfamilies. Risk assessments should take into account communitycapacity to resist or recover from the hazard’s impact.6Vulnerability:Physical, social, economic and environmental factors thatincrease the susceptibility of a community or individuals todifficulties and hazards and that put them at risk as a result ofloss, damage, insecurity, suffering and deathOrganisations / Agency used interchangeablyIn different settings people may use different terms such as “client” or “case” to referto the individual at the centre of a case plan. As this guidance relates specifically to themanagement of child protection concerns, the term “child” is generally used.4. Action for the Right of the child. ARC resource pack. 20095. Minimum Standards for Child Protection in Humanitarian Action, Child Protection Working Group, 20126. Ibid.Child protection working group Inter agency guidelines 7

ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONSCM:Case ManagementCP:Child protectionCPMS:Child Protection Minimum StandardsCPWG:Child Protection Working GroupECHO:European Community Humanitarian Aid OfficeHIV:Human Immunodeficiency VirusIA CP IMS:Inter Agency Child Protection Information Management SystemIRC:International Rescue CommitteeMDG:Multidisciplinary Group MeetingNGO:Non-Governmental OrganizationOFDA:Office of the US Foreign Disaster AssistanceTdh:Terre des HommesUASC:Unaccompanied and Separated ChildrenUNCRC:United Nations Convention of the Rights of the ChildUNHCR:United Nations Commissioner for RefugeesUNICEF:United Nations Children’s Fund8 Child protection working group Inter agency guidelines

INTRODUCTION TO THEGUIDELINESBACKGROUND TO THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE GUIDELINESThe guidelines were developed in recognition of the increased emphasis and interestbeing placed upon case management as a service part of a child protection system. Casemanagement is not new; however its application in humanitarian settings is relatively recent.The intention in developing these guidelines was to provide a general framework of agreedprinciples, considerations, steps and procedures for effective child protection case managementin line with the Minimum Standards for Child Protection in Humanitarian Action (CPMS)7developed in 2012 by the Child Protection Working Group (CPWG). This is to provideinterventions in line with Standard 15 of CPMS, which states:Girls and boys with urgent child protection needs are identified and receive ageand culturally-appropriate information as well as an effective, multi-sectorial andchild-friendly response from relevant providers working in a coordinated andaccountable manner.The primary focus of these guidelines is for use by agencies and practitioners in humanitariansettings. However, these guidelines can also be a useful resource for governments andagencies working in more stable or development situations. Likewise, these guidelines can behelpful additional guidance in refugee situations, but practices would need to take into accountbroader refugee case management including the specific Best Interest Procedure.While we have tried to make these guidelines as user-friendly and simple as possible, we haveassumed that agencies and staff engaging in case management work have some trainingand experience in providing care and support to children with child protection concerns.Training materials on case management have being developed by the CPWG to accompanythese guidelines. In addition, there are a number of other training packages and usefulresources, which are included in the Resources Section at the end of the guidelines.Please note that these guidelines are about CASE MANAGEMENT, not child protectionprogramming generally. Inevitably some mention is made of aspects of child protectionprogramming, as case management can be a component of broader programming.For more information on child protection and child protection programmes generally, in bothhumanitarian and development contexts, please see the Resources Section.As every country and community context is different, these guidelines will need to be adaptedto the particular environment in which you are working.7. Minimum Standards for Child Protection in Humanitarian Action, Child Protection Working Group, 2012Child protection working group Inter agency guidelines 9

FORMAT OF THE GUIDELINESThere are three main sections to these guidelines:SECTION 1 – PRINCIPLES & PRACTICESThis section explores what case management is, in general terms, and the principles thatshould inform and underpin case management practice.SECTION 2 – IMPLEMENTING CASE MANAGEMENT SERVICESThis section considers the main dynamics and factors that should be taken into accountwhen either introducing case management services, or seeking to strengthen them. It isprimarily aimed at policy makers and programme managers – including child protectionadvisors and coordinators.SECTION 3 - CASE MANAGEMENT STEPSThis section examines in greater detail the different steps that form part of the casemanagement process, and the key elements to be considered. It is aimed primarily atfrontline caseworkers and their supervisors – that is to say those who actually have theday-to-day contact with children and families. It will also be of use to managers andadvisors who have responsibility for either establishing or implementing case managementresponses and supervising caseworkers.Throughout the text other key resources that are available have been signposted. Inaddition, the Resource Section at the end of the guidelines contains a comprehensive listof references and other useful materials.10 Child protection working group Inter agency guidelines

PRINCIPLES &PRACTICES

SECTION 1PRINCIPLES & PRACTICESWHAT IS CASE MANAGEMENT?CASE MANAGEMENT is a way of organising and carrying out work to address anindividual child’s (and their family’s) needs in an appropriate, systematic and timelymanner, through direct support and/or referrals, and in accordance with a project orprogramme’s objectives.Case management can be provided in emergency and development settings to addressa range of issues, including child protection concerns. Case management services canbe provided as part of programmes that address the needs of children with particularvulnerabilities or risks (such as separation or commercial sexual exploitation) or may beprovided as part of programmes or services that address a broader range of child welfareand social protection concerns. Having case management procedures in place ensuresquality, consistency, and coordination of services.CASE MANAGEMENT IS NOT:A type of programme or intervention – it is a service for identifying children’s needsand coordinating services to meet those needs.Appropriate to be used in all circumstances (explored further in Section 2)A quick and easy fix solution – it needs well trained staff, supported by appropriatesupervision and is often a medium to long-term work in progressKEY POINTS ABOUT CASE MANAGEMENT:1. Should focus on the needs of an individual child and their family, ensuring that concernsare addressed systematically in consideration of the best interests of the child andbuilding upon the child and family’s natural resilience.2. Should be provided in accordance with the established case management process, witheach case through a series of steps (as shown below) involving children’s meaningfulparticipation and family empowerment throughout.Child protection working group Inter agency guidelines 13

SECTION 1: PRINCIPLES & PRACTICES3. Involve the coordination of services and supports within an interlinked or referral system4. Require systems for ensuring the accountability of case management agencies (withina formal or statutory system where this exists)5. Are provided by one key worker (referred to as a caseworker or case manager) who isresponsible for ensuring that decisions are taken in best interests of the child, the caseis managed in accordance with the established process, and who takes responsibilityfor coordinating the actions of all actors.CASE MANAGEMENT WHERE FEW SERVICES ARE AVAILABLEIt is sometimes thought that case management cannot be provided where thereare limited services for referrals. However, case management services can stillbe effective when only one agency is working with the child and their family. Withappropriate training and supervision, case management staff can address manyprotection issues themselves and work collaboratively with the community and nonprotection services to address potential gaps.CORE STEPS IN THE CASE MANAGEMENT PROCESSThere are a number of core steps in the case management process (which aredescribed in more detail in Section 3) as shown in the diagram8 below:1. Identify and registervulnerable children, includingraising awareness amongaffected communities.2. Assess the needs ofindividual children and families.6. Close case.3. Develop an individual caseplan for each child addressing theneeds identified. Set time-bound,measureable objectives.5. Follow up and review.4. Start the case plan, includingdirect support and referralservices.8. Diagram adapted from the CP MS, Standard 15. Note that in the CPMS case management contains 5 steps as ‘Assessment’and ‘Case planning’ are combined into a single step. In these guidelines, these two aspects of case management are presentedas separate steps.14 Child protection working group Inter agency guidelines

1. IDENTIFICATION & REGISTRATION – A child who is in need of case managementservices can be identified through a variety of pathways. Staff members in child protectionand other sector programmes might identify a child in the course of their regular activities,or an agency or community member might refer the child to receive case managementservices. In some cases, the child or their family might present themselves directly. Everyprogramme involving case management services should outline specific vulnerabilitycriteria to help guide this identification process and raise awareness on these within acommunity.Registration occurs when the child meets the vulnerability or risk criteria and both the childand their family give informed consent/assent to accept services. Registration includesthe initial collection of data on the child (intake).2. ASSESSMENT – The systematic evaluation of the situation of the child. This shouldconsider the vulnerabilities, risks and harm factors, and also the protective influences andstrengths and resilience of a child and their family. In emergencies, this may be a relativelyquick and straightforward process concentrating on basic needs (for example food andshelter). Where there is an immediate risk to the child (for example the child is living withthe perpetrator of abuse or violence), immediate intervention will be prioritized before acomprehensive assessment and case plan is developed.In a second phase, a subsequent in-depth (comprehensive) assessment is conductedto gain a holistic understanding of the child’s situation. The holistic needs of a child arealways considered even if an agency is not able to address every concern directly. In sucha case, the case would be referred to another agency/service provider able to addressspecific concern. (See later sections on referrals).3. CASE PLANNING – A case plan lists the needs identified in the assessment and sets astrategy for addressing them through direct service provision, referrals and/or communitybased programmes. In complex cases, a multi-disciplinary, inter-agency case conferencemay be called to develop a case plan. Specific, measurable, time-bound case objectivesare set at this time and should ideally be reached prior to case closure. Case plans are fluiddocuments that can be revised at any time if a child’s situation or needs change.4. IMPLEMENTING THE CASE PLAN – The actions taken in order to realise the planincluding direct support and services and referral to other agencies/service providers, asappropriate. A caseworker or manager is responsible for coordinating all of these services,documenting progress, and ensuring case objectives are being met.5. FOLLOW UP AND REVIEW –Follow up involves checking that a child and his/her family are receiving appropriateservices and support.Follow-up also involves monitoring the child’s situation and identifying any changes in achild or family’s circumstances. Follow-up takes place throughout the case managementprocess.Review is a reflection on how the implementation of the plan is progressing, whether theobjectives outlined in the case plan are being met, whether the plan remains relevant,and how to make adjustments to the plan if necessary.Child protection working group Inter agency guidelines 15

SECTION 1: PRINCIPLES & PRACTICES6. CASE CLOSURE – The point at which work with the child ends. This can be for avariety of reasons – for example because the situation is resolved, (i.e. the case plan hasbeen completed and the child no longer requires support). In some cases an organisationwould close a case and transfer the child to another organisation – for example if the childmoves to a different location or, in emergency situations, if the organisation is no longerworking in the area, The case will also be closed where the child becomes 18 years old(unless there are good reasons to remain involved, such as additional vulnerabilities) or ifthe child dies.Managers and caseworkers should keep in mind that case management is not a linearprocess. The six steps shown in the diagram above (Core steps in the case managementprocess p 12) are inter-linked and may at some time trigger a return to an earlier stageor process. Managers and caseworkers should constantly be analysing the situation ofchildren and their family and use the case management steps as flexible tools to organisetheir work.GUIDING PRINCIPLES FOR CASE MANAGEMENTAgencies and staff engaged in child protection case management should comply witha core set of principles to guide their behaviour and interaction with children and theirfamilies. This also provides a foundation of care and responsibility for decisions andactions taken. These core principles are similar to those which underpin all good practicewith children. They also reflect the Protection Principles in the SPHERE Handbook9and the key principles and approaches developed in the CPMS10.DO NO HARMThis means ensuring that actions and interventions designed to support the child (and theirfamily) do not expose them to further harm. At each step of the case management process,care must be taken to ensure that no harm comes to children or their families as a resultof caseworker conduct, decisions made, or actions taken on behalf of the child or family.Caution should also be taken to ensure that no harm comes to children or families as a resultof collecting, storing or sharing their information. For example, care should be taken to avoidcreating conflict between individuals, families or communities, and collecting unnecessaryinformation that, if in the wrong hands, could put the child or family at risk of violence. Unlesscare is taken, this may expose a child and his/her family to further harm such as revengeacts or violence.PRIORITISE THE BEST INTERESTS OF THE CHILDThe “best interests of the child” encompass a child’s physical and emotional safety (theirwell-being) as well as their right to positive development. In line with Article 3 of the UnitedNations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC), the best interests of the childshould provide the basis for all decisions and actions taken, and for the way in which serviceproviders interact with children and their families. Caseworkers and their supervisors mustconstantly evaluate the risks and resources of the child and his environment as well aspositive and negative consequences of actions and discuss these with the child and theircaregivers when taking decisions. The least harmful course of action is the preferred one.9. Sphere Minimum Standards10. Minimum Standards for Child Protection in Humanitarian Action, Child Protection Working Group, 201211. Action on the Rights of the Child, http://www.arc-online.org/using/index.html16 Child protection working group Inter agency guidelines

All actions should ensure that the child’s rights to safety and on-going development arenever compromised.11The Best Interests Principle must guide all decisions made during the case managementprocess. Often in child protection there is no one ‘’ideal’’ solution possible, but rathera series of more or less acceptable choices that must be balanced with a child’s bestinterests.NON-DISCRIMINATIONAdhering to the non-discrimination principle means ensuring that children are notdiscriminated against (treated poorly or denied services) because of their individualcharacteristics or a group they belong to (e.g. gender, age, socio-economic background,race, religion, ethnicity, disability, sexual orientation or gender identity).Children in need of protective services should receive assistance from agencies andcaseworkers that are trained and skilled to form respectful, non-discriminatory relationshipswith them, treating them with compassion, empathy and care. Case management staff mustactively work to be non-judgemental and avoid negative/ judgemental language in theirwork. Whether engaged in awareness raising, prevention or response activities agenciesand caseworkers should challenge discrimination, including policies and practices thatreinforce discrimination.ADHERE TO ETHICAL STANDARDSFor agencies and staff working with children, professional ethical standards and practicesshould be developed and applied; these may be professional codes of conduct and childprotection policies. National laws and policies may exist in addition to international normsand standards to protect children that are relevant and have to be respected. Adheringto ethical standards includes following the guidelines presented in this document. Theseguidelines are fundamental to the delivery of professional and quality care and protectionfor children.SEEK INFORMED CONSENT AND/OR INFORMED ASSENTInformed consent is the voluntary agreement of an individual who has the capacity togive consent, and who exercises free and informed choice. In all circumstances, consentshould be sought from children and their families or caregivers prior to providing services.To ensure informed consent, caseworkers must ensure that children and their familiesfully understand: the services and options available (i.e. the case management process),potential risks and benefits to receiving services, information that will be collected andhow it will be used, and confidentiality and its limits. Caseworkers are responsible forcommunicating in a child-friendly manner and should encourage the child and their familyto ask questions that will help them to make a decision regarding their own situation. (Seeannex 14, the sample of guidance note for informed consent).Informed assent is the expressed willingness to participate in services12. It requires thesame child-friendly communication of information outlined above. However, for youngerchildren who are by nature or law too young to give informed consent, but old enough tounderstand and agree to participate in services, the child’s “informed assent” is sought.Even for very young children (those under 5 years old) efforts should be made to explainin language appropriate to their age,

Case Management: The process of helping individual children and families through direct social-work type support, and information management. Caseworker: The key worker in a case who maintains responsibility for the child's care from identification to case closure