A Background. Whereas, In 2004, The Attorney General .

Transcription

SEITLEMENT AG REEMENTThis settlement agreement ("Agreeme nt") is entered into between Edward D. Jones &Co., L.P. ("Edward Jones"), a licensed sec urities broker-dealer, on one side and the People ofthe State of California, by and through Atto rney General Edmund G. Brown Jr. or his designatedrepresentative ("Attorney General"), on the ot her side (co llectively the "Part ies").RECITA LSABackground. Whereas, in 2004, the Atto rney General commenced aninvestigation into certain arrangements between various mutual fund co mplexes ("MutualFunds") and a number of securities broker- dealers ("Bro ker-Dealers") whereby Broker-Dealersreceived conside ration from the Mutual Funds in connection with ma rketing the co mple xes'mu tual fund sha res . Depending on the particular Mutu al Funds and Broker-Dealers invo lved,this market ing included, but was not limited to: (i) placem ent on a "preferred list," in a "partnersprogram," o r otherwise being identified as a complex to be accorded a higher degree ofmarketing support than complexes not furni shing such consideration; (ii) obtaining access toBroker-Dealer representatives, incl uding through the Broker-Dealers' intrane t website, in orderto promote the funds; and/or (iii) promotions in communicatio ns with Broker-Dealers' customerssuch as on a Broker-Dealer's internet webs ite or in custome r newsletters ("She lf Sp aceArrangements").B.The Attomev General's Investigat ion of Edward Jones . Whereas, on May 19,2004, the Attorney Ge nera l subpoenaed Edward Jone s regarding the "offer and sale of shares inmutual funds as may pertain to poss ible vio lations of state laws , including wi thout limitationsthe state 's securities law ." The investigation included all of the facts and circumstances set forth

in Paragraph A and with respect to Edward Jones: (1) the receipt of revenue sharing, directedbrokerage, contest and trip reimbursement, and other consideration and business arra ngem entswith certain mutua l fund complexes that Edward Jones labeled as Preferred Fund Fa milies; (2)the incentives to Edward Jones ' brokers (referred to as "Investment Representatives") andowners from the foregoing arrangements; (3) the adequa cy of Edward Jones ' disclosures to theinvesting public of the forego ing arrangement (t'the Investigation").C.The Attorn ey General's Enforcement Action. Wher eas, followin g theInvestigation, on Decembe r 20, 2004, the Attorney General filed suit, pursuant to CaliforniaGovernment Code §§ 12658 and 12660, against Edward Jones alleging violati ons of the antifraudprovisions of the Corporate Securities Law of 1968 ("CSL") during the period from January I ,200 1 through December 31, 2004 titled The Pe ople ofthe State of Califom ia v. Edward D. Jones& Co. in Sacramento County Superior Court (Case No. 04AS05097) ("Action"). Edward Joneshas denied the allegations in the Action.D.Related Actions by Edward Jones. Where as, Edward Jones resolved otherregulatory investigations and private litigation arising out of the same circum stances that were thesubject matter of the Atto rney General's Investigation and Action, including bu t not limited to:(1)In December, 2004, Edward Jones entered into consent orders andagreements with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission, the New York StockExchange, the Natio nal Assoc iation of Securities Dealers (now known as FINRA), and theUnited States Attorne y for the Eastern District of Missouri ("Federal Regulators") that providefor, among other things :(i)Revised ongoing disclosures to custom ers regarding thesubjec t matter of the Investigation and Action;2

(ii)The alteration of the incentives to Edward Jones ' brokersfrom the business arrangem ents subject to the Investigationand Action;(iii)The payment by Edward Jones into a FAIR Fund that wasdistributed to all customers including Edward Jones 'California customers in the amount of 1,854,066 .37; and(iv)The offering ofa free switch to Edward Jones' customers,including California customers, from the Preferred FundFamilies to any mutual fund on Edward Jones ' approvedselling list.(2)Edward Jones entered into class action settlements on behalf of allof its customers purchasing and holding Preferred Mutual Fund shares from 1999 through 2004 intwo consolidated actions, the first captioned Spahn v. Edward D. Jones & Co., L.P. pendingbefore the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri ("Spahn") and thesecond captioned Enriquez v. Edward D. Jones & Co., L.P. pending before the Circuit Court ofthe City of St. Louis, Missouri ("Enriquez") (collectively referred to as the "C lass Action" ),which provide for, among other things :(i)The payment in cash to, among others, fanner EdwardJones ' customers including those in California in theamount of 1,211,85 1.29;3

(ii)The pro viding of in credit vouchers to current EdwardJones ' customers including those in California in theamou nt of 3.236,253 .79; and(iii)Na tionwide inj unctions aga inst the prosecution of anyclaims for or on behalf of any members of the classes formatters released by the Class Action settlements.E.Pumose. Whereas, the Parties des ire to resolve all issue s and disputes betweenthorn related to the Investigation and Action on the terms and conditions set forth below, andEdward Jones, without admitting or denying the allegations in the Action. enters into thisAgree ment and agrees to abide by the terms and co nditions set forth below.TE RM S OF THI S AG REEMENTIn consideration of the mutual term s, covenants and conditions of this Agreement, theParties hereto agree to settle all disputes and claims between them relating to the Invest igationand Actio n on the following terms and conditions (the "Terms"):I.Settlement Payment. Within five (5) business days following theexec ution of this Agreeme nt by the Parties, Edward Jones agree s to pay the Attorne y Generaland the State of California the total sum of SEVEN MILLI ON, FIV E HUNDRED THO USANDDOLLA RS ( 7.500,000.00 ) ("Settlement Payment"), as follows:1.1Fees and Costs. Th e total sum o f TWO MILLION, SEVENHUN DRED THO USAND DOLLARS ( 2.700,000.00) made paya ble to the Attorney General.in recognition of the Attorney Ge neral's fees and costs: (i) incurred and to be incurred inco nnection with the Investigation and the Act ion; (ii) to be incurred in conn ection with the

monitor ing and enforcement of the terms of this Agreement and any litigation related thereto;and (iii) to be incurred in connection with the Attorney General's enforcement of California'ssecurities, co mmodities and unfair competition laws.1.2Civil Pena lties. The total sum of FOU R MILLION, EIGHTHUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS ( 4,800,000.00) made payable to the State of California,as civil penalt ies pursuant to California Government Code § 12660.2.Withdrawal of Spahn Motion Within five (5) business days following theexecution of this Agreement by the Parties, Edward Jones shall withdraw its Motion to Show Causecurrently pending before the Spahn Court.3.Dismissal of-Action. Within two (2) business days of both the receipt ofthe Settlement Payment and the withdrawal of the Spahn Motion, the Attorney General shall filea stipulated dismissal with prejudice of the Action with each side to bear its own attorneys ' feesand costs other than the fees and costs Edw ard Jone s has agreed to pay in Paragraph 1 of thisAgreement.4.Releases by Edwa rd Jones. In cons ideration for the ob ligations and mutualreleases set forth in this Agreement , Edw ard Jones, EDJ Holding Co., Inc., The Jones FinancialCompanies, L.L.P. and their respe ctive partne rs, limited partners, subordinated limited part ners,trustees, managing partners, executive committee, management committee , agents, insurers,attorneys, parent corporations, subsidiaries, affiliated and related entit ies, assigns, and otherrepresentatives of any kin d or nature, and their predecessors and successors in interest(vlceleasors"), hereby release, remise and forever discharge the Attorney Ge neral and his agen ts,insurers, attorneys, affiliated and related entities, assigns, and other representatives of any kindor nature, and their predecessors and succ essors in interest, from any and all claims (includingattorneys' fees andlor costs), actions, rights, demands, damages, costs, liabilities of any kind or5

nature, whether known or unknown, sounding in tort. contract or any statutory regulatory orother theory of liability which Releasors now have or have ever had or may hereafter haveagainst the Attorney General, arising out of. in connection with or related to the subj ect matter ofthe Investigation, and allegations contained and which could have been raised in the Act ionand/or Edward Jones' alleged misrepresentations or omissions arising out o f our relat ing toEdward Jones Preferred Fund program, revenue sharing or directed brokerage. Re1easorsacknowledge that they are aware of. and specifically waive. the provisions of California CivilCode § 1542. Releasors acknowledge that they fully and voluntarily waive. release andrelinquish any and all of the rights and benefits which they may have under said Section 1542 orunder the laws of any other state or jurisdiction to the same or similar effect, as pertains to thereleases contained in this Agreement. In connection with such waiver and relinquishme nt,Rcleasors acknowledge that they are aware that they may discover facts in addition to ordifferent from those which they currently know or believe to be true with respect to the subjectmatters of this Agreement. but that it is their intention hereby, to fully, finally and forever settleand release all matters which now exist, may exist, or previously existed between the Parties,whether or not now known or unknown, suspected or unsuspected with respect to theInvestigation and Action. In furtherance of such intent, the release given herein shall be and shallremain in effect as a full and complete release, notwithstanding the discovery or existence of anysuch additional or different facts.Excluded from this release are the Attorney General' s obligations under thisAgreement.5.Releases bv the Attornev General. In consideration for the obligations andmutual releases set forth in this Agreement, the Attorney General in his o fficial capacity and onbehalf of the People of California and his agents, insurers. attorneys, affiliated and related6

entities, assigns, and other representatives of any kind or nature , and their predecessors andsuccessors in interest ("Releasors"), hereby fully release, remise and forever discha rge EdwardJones, EDJ Holding Co., Inc., The Jones Financial Companies, L.L.P., and the ir respect iveprese nt and former partners, limited partners, subordinated limited partners, trustees, managingpartners, executive comm ittee, management commi ttee, employees, investmen t representatives ,financial advisors, officers, agents, insurers, attorneys, parent organizations, subsidiaries,affiliated and related entities, assigns and other representat ives of any kind or nature, and theirpredecessors and successors in interest, from any and all claims (including attorneys fees and/orcosts), actions, rights, demands, damages, costs, liabilities of any kind or nature, sounding intort, contract or any statutory, regulatory or othe r the ory ofliability wh ich Releasors now haveor have ever had or may hereafter have against them, arising out of, in connection with or relatedto the subject matter of the Investigation, the allega tions contained and which could have beenraised, in the Action and/or Edward Jones' alleged misrepresentations or om issions arising outof or re lating to Edward Jones Preferred Fund program, revenue sharing or directed brokerage.Releasors acknowledge that they are aware of, and specifically waive, the provis ion s ofCalifornia Civil Code § 1542. Releasers acknowledge that they fully and vo luntarily waive ,release and relinquish any and all of the rights and benefits which they may have under saidSect ion 1542 or under the laws of any other state or jurisdiction to the same or similar effect, asperta ins to the releases contained in this Agreeme nt. In connect ion with such waiver andrelinquis hment , Releasors ackno wledge that they are aware that they may discover facts inadd ition to or di fferent from those which they currently know or believe to be true with respectto the subject matters of this Agreement, but that it is their intention hereby, to fully, finally andforever settle and release aU matters which now exist, may exist, or previously existed betweenthe Parties, whether or not now known or unknown, suspected or unsuspec ted with respect to the7

Investigation and Action. In furtherance of such intent, the release given herein shall be and shallremain in effect as a full and complete release, notwithstanding the discovery or existence of anysuch addit ional or different facts.Excluded from this release are Edward Jones' obligations under this Agreement.6.Miscellaneous.6.1No Admissio n or Finding of Liability. Nothing contained in thisAgreement shall be deemed as an admission by any Party of any liability, fau lt or wrongdoing.The Part ies agree that this Agreement shall not be admissible in any hearing, action orproceeding except to enforce this Agreeme nt's tenns.6.2Advice of Counsel. Each of the Parties has obtained advice oflegal counsel prior to and for the execution of this Agreement and understa nds fully the contentsof this Agreement. Each of the Parties warrants and represents that the party executing thisAgreeme nt on its behalf is duly authorized and empowered to execute this Ag reement.6.3Parties Bear Own Costs and Attorneys' Fees. Except as otherwiseprovided in Section I of this Agreement, each party hereto shall bear its own attorneys' fees andcosts incurred in connection with the Action.6.4Entire Agre ement. This document constitutes the entire agreementbetween the Parties to this Agreement regarding the matters described . All oral agreements,representations and prior agreements between the Parties to this Agreement regarding any suchmatters are merged herein, and this Agreeme nt supersedes all such prior repres entations andagreements. There are no representations, agreements, arrangements or understandings , oral orwritten, between the Parties relating to the subject matter of this Agreement that are not fullyexpressed in this Agreement. The Parties agree that no extrinsic evidence may be introduced tovary the tenus hereof in any judicial proceedi ng involving this Agreement.8

6.5Protective Order. Notwithstand ing the pro visions o f paragraph6.4, the Parties agree that the Stipulation and Order for the Production and Exchange ofInformation Designated Confidential in effect in the Action shall remain in full force and effect.6.6Governing Law. The rights and obligations of the Parties and theinterpretation and performance of this Agreement shall be governed by the law ofCalifomia.6.7Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in any number ofcounterparts with the same effect as if the Parties had all signed the same docum ent. Allcounterparts shall be construed together and shall constitute one agreemen t. The Parties stipulatethat counterparts. facsimile. or duplicate originals of this Agreement or any portion thereof shallbe admissible in any j udicial proceeding to the same extent that the original would be admissiblefor all purposes including but not limited to meeting the requirements of Califomia Code of CivilProcedure § 664.6.6.8Succession. Subject to the provi sions otherwise contained in thisAgreement, this Agreement shall inure to the benefit of and be bind ing on the successors andassign s o f the respective Parties.6.9Amendment. The provisions of this Agreement may be modified atany time by agreement of the Parties. Any such agreement hereafte r made shall be ineffective tomodify this Agreement in any respect unless in writing and signed by the Pa rties.6.10Severability. If any prov ision of this Agreement or the applicationthcreof'to any entity or circumstance, for any reason and to any extent, is adj udicated to beinvalid or unenforceable, neither the remainder of this Agreement nor the application of suchprovision to any other entity or circumstance shall be affected thereby, but rather shall beenforced to the greatest extent permitted by law.,

tr -Ui:::' -i:::'UU/jI Ut Ui:::' : :J/j r n, AX NU,6.11Ambi guities a:1d Uncertainties. A:J!.y ambiguities or uncertainties tilthis Agreement shall be equally and fairly interpreted and construed without reference to theidentity of the party or parties preparing this Agreement or any document referred to in thisAgreement, on the understanding that theParties participated equally in the negotiationandpreparation of tbis Agreement and thedocuments referred to in this Agreement, orhavehad theopportunity to do so.IN WITNESS WHEREOF. the Parties hereto have executed thisAgreement on the date set forth below.Date:' - f-- EDMUND G, BROWN IR.CALlFORNLA. ATI'ORNEY GENERALBy.h/\"-1P Ma!kJ'BreclJ",Senior Assistant Attorney Generalllilc: - -- -,--,-EDWARDD, JONES & CO" L.P.APPROVED AS TO FQJW,KEESAL, YOUNG & WGANBy:,GREENSFE LDER, HEMKER & GAL E. P,C.By:10P. U2

6. 11Ambi guities and Un certain ties . Any am biguities or uncertainties inthis Agreement shall be equally and fairly interpreted and construed withou t refe rence to theidentity of the party or parties preparing this Agreement or any doc ument referre d to in thisAgreement, on the und erstanding that the Parties parti cipa ted equ ally in the ne got iatio n andpreparation of this Agreement and the documents referred to in this Agree men t, or have had theopportunity to do so.IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties here to have ex ecu ted thisAgreement on the date set forth below.Date:: EDMUND G. BRO WN JR.CALIFORNIA ATTORNEY GENERALMark J. BrecklerSeni or Assis tant Attorney GeneralDate: - ---EDWARD D. JONES & CO ., L.P.--By::APPROVED AS TO FO RM:By : LbfJ/.J.LL.! !I-GREENSFELDER, HEMKER & GALE,By:r .c,10

Ambi guities and Uncerteinties. Any ambiguities or uncertainties in6.11this A greement shall be equally and fairly interpreted and construed without reference to theidentity of fbe party or parties preparing this Agreement or any document referred to in thisAgreement, on the understanding that the Parties participated equally in the negotiation andpreparation of this Agreement and the documents referred to in this Agreement, or have had theopportunity to do so.IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties hereto have executed thisAgreement on the date set forth below.0 . 1"EOMUND G. BROWN l R.CALIFORNIA ATIORNEY GENERALMark J. BrecklerSenior Assistant Attomey GeneralDate:EDWARD O. JONES 8; CO, L.P.By:, --APPROVED AS TO FORM :KEESAL, YOUNG 8; LOGANBy:- - -- - - GREENSFELDER, HEMKER & GALE, P.C.BY: to-- - - -

2004, the Attorney General subpoenaed Edward Jones regarding the "offer and sale ofshares in mutual funds as may pertain to possible violations ofstate laws, including without limitations the state 's securities law." The investigati