'Minnesota 'Board 'Barber AndCosmeto(o8ist Xaminers

Transcription

This document is made available electronically by the Minnesota Legislative Reference Library as part of anongoing digital archiving project. innesota 'Board'Barber and Cosmeto(o8ist xaminersJanuary 6, 2006Legislative Reference Library645 State Office BldgSt. Paul, MN 55155RE:In The Matter of the Proposed Rules ofthe Board of Barber and CosmetologistExaminers Relating to HairbraidingDear Librarian:The Board of Barber and Cosmetologist Examinersintends to adopt rules relating to hairbraiding.We plan to publish a Dual Notice in theJanuary 17, 2006 State Register.The Board has prepared a Statement of Need andReasonableness. As required by Minnesota Statutessections 14.131 and 14.23, the Board is sendingthe Library a copy of the Statement of Need andReasonableness at the time we are mailing ourNotice of Intent to Adopt Rules.If you have any questions, please contact me at651-201-2744.Yours very truly,' )J//. .C 4it7cv&{tALA/ Maureen TibbettsExecutive SecretaryEnclosures:Notice of Intent To Adopt RulesStatement of Need and ReasonablenessProposed Rules2829 University Ave SE, Suite 710, Minneapolis MN 55414(651) 201-2742 FAX (612) 617-2601 www.bceboard.state.mn.usMN Relay Service for Hearing or Speech Impaired: 1-800-627-3529AN AFFIRMATIVE ACTION / EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER

Minnesota Board of Barber and Cosmetologist ExaminersDUAL NOTICE: Notice oflntent to Adopt Rules Without a Public Hearing Unless 25 orMore Persons Request a Hearing, And Notice of Hearing Jf25 or More Requests ForHearing Are ReceivedProposed Amendment to Rules Governing Barbering and Cosmetology andCosmetology Schools, Minnesota Rules, parts 2100.0100, 2105.0010, 2110.0010, 2110.0100,2110.0500, and 2110.0680.Introduction. The Board of Barber and Cosmetologist Examiners intends to adopt ruleswithout a public hearing following the procedures set forth in the rules of the Office ofAdministrative Hearings, Minnesota Rules, parts I 400.2300 to 1400.2310, and theAdministrative Procedure Act, Minnesota Statutes, sections 14.22 to 14.28. If, however, 25 ormore persons submit a written request for a hearing on the rules by 4:30 p.m. on February 16,2006, a public hearing will be held in Conference Room A, Fourth Floor, 2829 University Ave.S.E., Minneapolis, Minnesota 55415, starting at 9:00 a.m. on Tuesday, February 28, 2006 andcontinuing on Wednesday, March 1,2006, if a second hearing day is necessary. To find outwhether the rules will be adopted without a hearing or if the hearing will be held, you shouldcontact the agency contact person after February 16,2006 and before February 28,2006.Agency Contact Person. Comments or questions on the rules and written requests for apublic hearing on the rules must be submitted to the agency contact person. The agency contactperson is: Maureen Tibbetts at the Board of Barber and Cosmetologist Examiners, 2829University Ave. S.E., Suite 710, Minneapolis, MN 55414, phone (651) 201-2744, FAX, (612)617-2601. TTY users may call the Board of Barber and Cosmetologist Examiners at 1-800-6273529.Subject of Rules and Statutory Authority. The proposed rule amendments would: (1)modify the definitions of barbering and cosmetology to exclude hair braiding, hair braidingservices, and hair braiders, as defined in the proposed rule amendments; (2) preempt ordinancesby local units of government that prohibit hair braiding, hair braiding services, or hair braiders,as defined in the proposed rule amendments, or regulate any matter relating to licensing, testing,or training of hair braiding, hair braiding services, or hair braiders; and (3) modify theeducational requirements for cosmetology students to allow for a maximum of one percent of thetotal curriculum time in cosmetology schools to be dedicated to the teaching of unregulatedservices, as defined in the proposed rule amendments. The statutory authority to adopt the rulesis Minnesota Statutes, section 154.22(1), 154.24, and 155A.05. A copy of the proposed rules ispublished in the State Register and attached to this notice as mailed. A free copy of the rules isavailable upon request from the agency contact person listed above.Comments. You have until 4:30 p.m. on Thursday, February 16,2006, to submit writtencomment in support of or in opposition to the proposed rules or any part or subpart of the rules.Your comment must be in writing and received by the agency contact person by the due date.Comment is encouraged. Your comments should identify the portion of the proposed rules

addressed, the reason for the comment, and any change proposed. You are encouraged topropose any change desired. Any comments that you would like to make on the legality of theproposed rules must also be made during this comment period.Request for a Hearing. In addition to submitting comments, you may also request that ahearing be held on the rules. Your request for a public hearing must be in writing and must bereceived by the agency contact person by 4:30 p.m. on Thursday, February] 6, 2006. Yourwritten request for a public hearing must include your name and address. You must identify theportion of the proposed rules to which you object or state that you oppose the entire set of rules.Any request that does not comply with these requirements is not valid and cannot be counted bythe agency when determining whether a public hearing must be held. You are also encouragedto state the reason for the request and any changes you want made to the proposed rules.Withdrawal of Requests. If 25 or more persons submit a valid written request for ahearing, a public hearing will be held unless a sufficient number withdraw their requests inwriting. If enough requests for hearing are withdrawn to reduce the number below 25, theagency must give written notice of this to all persons who requested a hearing, explain theactions the agency took to effect the withdrawal, and ask for written comments on this action. Ifa public hearing is required, the agency will follow the procedures in Minnesota Statutes,sections] 4.] 3] to ]4.20.Alternative Format/Accommodation. Upon request, this Notice can be made availablein an alternative format, such as large print, Braille, or cassette tape. To make such a request orif you need an accommodation to make this hearing accessible, please contact the agency contactperson at the address or telephone number listed above.Modifications. The proposed rules may be modified, either as a result of publiccomment or as a result of the rule hearing process. Modifications must be supported by data andviews submitted to the agency or presented at the hearing and the adopted rules may not besubstantially different than these proposed rules, unless the procedure under Minnesota Rules,part 1400.2110, has been followed. If the proposed rules affect you in any way, you areencouraged to participate in the rulemaking process.CanceHation of Hearing. The hearing scheduled for February 28,2006 and March I,2006, will be canceled if the agency does not receive requests from 25 or more persons that ahearing be held on the rules. If you requested a public hearing, the agency will notify you beforethe scheduled hearing whether or not the hearing will be held. You may also call the agencycontact person at (65]) 201-2744 after February] 6,2006 to find out whether the hearing will beheld.Notice of Hearing. If 25 or more persons submit valid written requests for a publichearing on the rules, a hearing will be held following the procedures in Minnesota Statutes,sections 14.] 31 to ]4.20. The hearing will be held on the date and at the time and place listedabove. The hearing will continue until all interested persons have been heard. AdministrativeLaw Judge Beverly Jones Heydinger is assigned to conduct the hearing. Judge Heydinger can be

reached at the Office of Administrative Hearings, ] 00 Washington Square, Suite] 700,Minneapolis, Minnesota 5540]-2138, telephone (612) 341-7606, and FAX 612-349-2665.Hearing Procedure. If a hearing is held, you and all interested or affected persons,including representatives of associations or other interested groups, will have an opportunity toparticipate. You may present your views either orally at the hearing or in writing at any timebefore the close of the hearing record. All evidence presented should relate to the proposedrules. You may also submit written material to the Administrative Law Judge to be recorded inthe hearing record for five working days after the public hearing ends. This five-day commentperiod may be extended for a longer period not to exceed 20 calendar days if ordered by theAdministrative Law Judge at the hearing. Following the comment period, there is afive-working-day rebuttal period during which the agency and any interested person mayrespond in writing to any new information submitted. No additional evidence may be submittedduring the five-day rebuttal period. All comments and responses submitted to the AdministrativeLaw Judge must be received at the Office of Administrative Hearings no later than 4:30 p.m. onthe due date. All comments or responses received will be available for review at the Office ofAdministrative Hearings. This rule hearing procedure is governed by Minnesota Rules,parts] 400.2000 to ]400.2240, and Minnesota Statutes, sections] 4.131 to 14.20. Questionsabout procedure may be directed to the Administrative Law Judge.The agency requests that any person submitting written views or data to theAdministrative Law Judge prior to the hearing or during the comment or rebuttal period alsosubmit a copy of the written views or data to the agency contact person at the address statedabove.Statement of Need and Reasonableness. A statement of need and reasonableness is. now available from the agency contact person. This statement contains a summary of thejustification for the proposed rules, including a description of who will be affected by theproposed rules and an estimate of the probable cost of the proposed rules. The statement mayalso be reviewed and copies obtained at the cost of reproduction from the agency.Lobbyist Registration. Minnesota Statutes, chapter 10A, requires each lobbyist toregister with the State Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board. Questions regarding thisrequirement may be directed to the Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board at:Suite] 90, Centennial Building, 658 Cedar Street, St. Paul, Minnesota 55155, telephone651-296-5148 or 1-800-657-3889.Adoption Procedure if No Hearing. If no hearing is required, the agency may adopt therules after the end of the comment period. The rules and supp011ing documents will then besubmitted to the Office of Administrative Hearings for review for legality. You may ask to benotified of the date the rules are submitted to the office. If you want to be so notified, or want toreceive a copy of the adopted rules, or want to register with the agency to receive notice of futurerule proceedings, submit your request to the agency contact person listed above.Adoption Procedure After a Hearing. If a hearing is held, after the close of the hearingrecord, the Administrative Law Judge will issue a report on the proposed rules. You may ask to

be notified of the date when the Administrative Law Judge's report will become available, andcan make this request at the hearing or in writing to the Administrative Law Judge. You mayalso ask to be notified of the date on which the agency adopts the rules and the rules are filedwith the Secretary of State, and can make this request at the hearing or in writing to the agencycontact person stated above.Order. I order that the rulemaking hearing be held at the date, time, and location listedaboveI I,1:J. J.() 05'DateO·s 1/ .-- I iulaY\ " ' "itPrinted Name: S 0tS o-.ScJlce.fe rTitle: h c.1t a h 0-0 t-/.-l- I3cxu Page 4

Minnesota Board of Barber and Cosmetologist ExaminersSTATEMENT OF NEED AND REASONABLENESSProposed Amendment to Rules Governing Barbering and Cosmetology and CosmetologySchools, Minnesota Rules, parts 2100.0100, 2105.0010 (formerly 2642.0010), 2110.0010(formerly 2644.0010),2110.0100 (formerly 2644.0100), 2110.0500 (formerly 2644.0500), and2110.0680 (formerly 2644.0680).INTRODUCTIONThe Board of Barber and Cosmetologist Examiners ("Board") was created by theMinnesota legislature in 2004, supplemented by further legislation in 2005. The jurisdiction ofthe Board of Barber and Cosmetologist Examiners combines the authority and functions of thefonner Board of Barber Examiners, which licensed and regulated the practice of barbers, barbershops, and barber schools, and the authority and functions formerly exercised by the MinnesotaCommissioner of Commerce, who administered and enforced the laws regulating cosmetologists,cosmetology salons, and cosmetology schools.The Board is responsible for administration, licensing, enforcement, regulation, andadoption of rules under Minnesota Statutes chapter 154 (barbers, barber shops, barber schools)and Minnesota Statutes chapter 155A (cosmetologists, salons, and cosmetology schools). Boardmembership terms, compensation of members, removal of members, the filling of membershipvacancies, and fiscal year and reporting requirements for the board are as provided in MinnesotaStatutes sections 214.07 to 214.09. Operation of the board staff, administrative services andoffice space, the review and processing of complaints, the setting of board fees, and other aspectsof board operations are governed by Minnesota Statutes chapter 214. Board staff serves bothprofessions.The proposed rule amendments govern the definitions of barbering and cosmetology andthe cosmetology educational curriculum. The proposed rule amendments would: (1) modify thedefinitions of barbering and cosmetology to exclude hair braiding, hair braiding services, andhair braiders, as defined in the proposed rule amendments; (2) preempt ordinances by local unitsof government that prohibit hair braiding, hair braiding services, or hair braiders, as defined inthe proposed rule amendments, or regulate any matter relating to licensing, testing, or training ofhair braiding, hair braiding services, or hair braiders; and (3) modify the educationalrequirements for cosmetology students to allow for a maximum of one percent of the totalcurriculum time in cosmetology schools to be dedicated to the teaching of unregulated services,as defined in the proposed rule amendments. The Board published a Request for Comments inthe State Register on Monday, October 31, 2005 (30 SR 449).The Board of Barber and Cosmetologist Examiners is specifically required by a June 10,2005 Hennepin County District Court order to initiate this rulemaking to adopt the first twocategories of proposed rule amendments discussed above, which relate to the exemption of hairbraiding, hair braiding services, and hair braiders from the definitions of barbering andcosmetology and from licensing and regulation by the Board, and the preemption of anyordinances of local units of government that prohibit hair braiding, hair braiding services, andhair braiders, or regulate any matter relating to licensing, testing or training of hair braiding, hairPage I

braiding services, or hair braiders. See Stipulated Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law andAgreed Order in Anderson et af. v. Minnesota Board ofBarber and Cosmetologist Examiners etal., Court File No. 05-5467, Hennepin County District Court, June 10, 2005 (Honorable IsabelGomez) ("Court Order"). The definitions of "hair braiding," "hair braiding services," "hairbraiders," and "simple braiding devices" and the content of the first and second parts of theproposed rule amendments are mandated by the Court Order. The Court Order requires theBoard to work in good faith towards adoption of the rule amendments by April 20, 2006. Furtherdiscussion of the legal background and necessity for adoption of the proposed rules appears inthe section below entitled "Need and Reasonableness."Until the Court Order, the statutes and rules concerning "cosmetology" and "licensedservices" were interpreted by the Commissioner of Commerce (who formerly administered andenforced the cosmetology laws, as discussed above) to include hair braiding, hair braidingservices, and hair braiders. The curriculum offered by Minnesota cosmetology schools oftenincluded some instruction in hair braiding skills. Since the Commissioner interpreted hairbraiding as falling within the definition of "cosmetology" until the Court Order, theCommissioner counted instruction in hair braiding taught in cosmetology schools towardsfulfillment of some of the required types and hours of instruction for a cosmetology student.Adoption of the first tv/o categories of rule amendments would shift hair braiding from a"licensed service" to an "unregulated service," as hair braiding would no longer fall within thedefinition of "cosmetology" in the Board's statutes and rules. The cosmetology schools andcosmetology association have expressed to the Board a desire to continue instruction in hairbraiding that would provide some measure of academic credit for students. The third category ofproposed rule amendments responds to that need by modifying the educational curriculum forcosmetology students to allow for a maximum of one percent of the total curriculum time to bededicated to the teaching of unregulated services. This category of proposed rule amendments,therefore, also relates to the requirements of the Court Order.The rule definition of "unregulated services" currently lists other skills exempt fromregulation by the Board, including ear piercing, body wrapping, permanent depilitation,tattooing, artificial tanning of the skin, personal services incidental to performance in theatricalor musical productions or media appearances, personal services incident to mortuary practice,and massage services. The Board believes it is reasonable to treat all types of unregulatedservices similarly and allow for the proposed small amount of instructional credit to apply to theteaching of any type of unregulated service as defined in the proposed amendments to the Boardrules.ALTERNATIVE FORMATUpon request, this Statement of Need and Reasonableness can be made available in analternative format, such as large print, Braille, or cassette tape. To make a request, contactMaureen Tibbetts at the Board of Barber and Cosmetologist Examiners, 2829 University Ave.S.E., Suite 710, Minneapolis, MN 55414, telephone: (651) 201-2744; fax: (612) 617-2601. TTYusers may call the Board of Barber and Cosmetologist Examiners at 1-800-627-3529.Page 2

STATUTORY AUTHORITYThe Board of Barber and Cosmetologist Examiners' statutory authority to adopt the ruleamendments is set forth in Minnesota Statutes, sections 154.22(f) (renumbered as section154.001) (2005 Laws, ch. 27, §9); 154.24; and 155A.05 (2005), which provide, in pertinent part:154.22(1) The barber members of the board shall separately overseeadministration, enforcement, and regulation of, and adoption of rules under,sections 154.01 to 154.26. The cosmetologist members of the board shallseparately oversee administration, enforcement, and regulation of, and adoption ofrules under, sections ]55A.Ol to 155A.l6. Staff hired by the board, includinginspectors, shall serve both professions.154.24 Rules.The Board of Barber and Cosmetologist Examiners shall have authority to makereasonable rules for the administration of the provisions of sections 154.01 to154.26 and prescribe sanitary requirements for barber shops and barber schools,subject to the approval of the state commissioner of health. Any member of theboard, or its agents or assistants, shall have authority to enter upon and to inspectany barber shop or barber school at any time during business hours. A copy of therules adopted by the board shall be furnished by it to the owner or manager ofeach barber shop or barber school and such copy shall be posted in a conspicuousplace in

Minnesota Board ofBarberand Cosmetologist Examiners STATEMENT OF NEED AND REASONABLENESS Proposed Amendment to Rules Governing Barbering and Cosmetology and Cosmetology Schools, Minnesota Rules, parts 2100.0100, 2105.0010 (formerly 2642.0010), 2110.0010 (formerly 2644.0010),2110.0100