Transcription
REPORT ON EXAMINATION AS TO THE CONDITION OFCOVERYS SPECIALTY INSURANCE COMPANYAS OF DECEMBER 31, 2018NAIC COMPANY CODE 15686NAIC GROUP CODE 1154FILEDMAY 15, 2020COMMISSIONERDEPARTMENTOFBANKING & INSURANCE
TABLE OF CONTENTSSALUTATION. 1SCOPE OF THE EXAMINATION . 2COMPANY HISTORY . 3Capital Stock . 3Dividends to Stockholders . 4MANAGEMENT AND CONTROL . 4CONFLICT OF INTEREST PROCEDURES 5CORPORATE RECORDS . 5PARENT, SUBSIDIARIES, AND AFFILIATES . 5Intercompany Agreements. 6FIDELITY BOND AND OTHER INSURANCE COVERAGE . 7TERRITORY AND PLAN OF OPERATION . 7REINSURANCE . 7ACCOUNTS AND RECORDS . 7FINANCIAL STATEMENTS . 9Exhibit A – Financial Statement as of December 31, 2018. 9Exhibit B – Underwriting and Investment Exhibit . 10Exhibit C – Capital and Surplus . 11NOTES TO FINANCIAL STATEMENTS . 12CONCLUSION . 13AFFIDAVIT . 14
SALUTATIONPHIL MURPHYGovernorState of New JerseyDEPARTMENT OF BANKING AND INSURANCEOFFICE OF SOLVENCY REGULATIONPO BOX 325TRENTON, NJ 08625-0325SHEILA OLIVERLt. GovernorMARLENE CARIDECommissionerTEL (609) 292-5350FAX (609) 292-6765January 7, 2020Honorable Marlene CarideCommissioner of Banking and InsuranceState of New Jersey20 West State StreetTrenton, New Jersey 08625Commissioner:A financial examination has been made of the condition and affairs of the:Coverys Specialty Insurance Company67 East Park Place, Suite 703, Morristown, New Jersey 07960NAIC GROUP CODE 1154NAIC COMPANY CODE 15686a property and liability insurance organization authorized to transact business in the State of NewJersey, and hereinafter referred to in this report as "CSIC" or "Company."1
SCOPE OF THE EXAMINATIONThe New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance, hereafter referred to as the“NJDOBI” or “We”, participated in a full scope coordinated multi-state risk focusedexamination which was led by the Massachusetts Division of Insurance. This examinationcovers the period from the commencement of operations on April 1, 2015 through December31, 2018, and is the first examination of Coverys Specialty Insurance Company, hereafterreferred to as “CSIC” or “the Company”. The current examination includes a review of anymaterial transactions and/or events occurring subsequent to the examination date and notedduring the course of the examination. The principal portion of the examination wasconducted at the Company’s main administrative office located in Boston, Massachusetts.The current examination was conducted concurrent with the examinations of its affiliates,Medical Professional Mutual Insurance Company (“MPMIC”), ProSelect InsuranceCompany (“PSIC”) Preferred Professional Insurance Company (“PPIC”), HealthcareUnderwriters Group, Inc. (“HUG”), Preferred Professional RRG (“PPRRG”), and CoverysRRG, Inc. (“CRRG”), (collectively, “The Group”). During the period of December 31, 2015through December 31, 2018, the Company’s assets increased from 56,727,598 to 81,016,125, liabilities increased from 6,048,272 to 27,837,598, and surplus increasedfrom 50,679,326 to 53,178,527.The NJDOBI conducted the examination in accordance with the 2018 edition of the NationalAssociation of Insurance Commissioners (“NAIC”) Financial Condition ExaminersHandbook (the “NAIC Handbook”). The NAIC Handbook requires the NJDOBI to plan andperform the examination in order to evaluate the financial condition and identify prospectiverisks of the Company. To meet these objectives, the NJDOBI obtained information regardingthe Company’s corporate governance environment, identified and assessed inherent risks towhich it is exposed and evaluated the Company’s system of internal controls and proceduresused to mitigate identified risks. The examination also included assessing the principles usedand significant estimates made by management, as well as, evaluating the overall FinancialStatement presentation, management’s compliance with Statutory Accounting Principles andAnnual Statement instructions when applicable to domestic state regulations.According to the NAIC Handbook, “One of the increased benefits of the enhanced risk focused approach is to include consideration of other than financial risks that could impactthe insurer’s future solvency. By utilizing the enhanced approach, the examiner reviewed thefinancial and enterprise risks that existed at the examination “as of” date and will bepositioned to assess financial and enterprise risks that extend or commence during the timethe examination was conducted and prospective risks which are anticipated to arise or extendpast the point of examination completion. Using this approach, examiners will be betterpositioned to make recommendations for appropriate future supervisory plans (i.e., earlierstatutory exams, limited-scope exams, key areas for financial analysts to monitor, etc.) foreach insurer.”All accounts and activities of the Company were considered in accordance with the risk focused examination process.The examination report only addresses regulatoryinformation revealed by the examination process in accordance with the NAIC Handbook.All other financial matters were reviewed and determined not to be material for discussion inthis report.2
During the course of the examination, consideration was given to work performed by theCompany’s Internal Audit Department and the Company’s external accounting firm. Workreviewed included risk analysis, documentation, test-work and remediation efforts overweaknesses identified. Certain auditor work papers have been incorporated into the workpapers of the examiners and have been utilized in determining the scope and areas ofemphasis in conducting the examination.COMPANY HISTORYProMutual Group, Inc., the immediate parent of Coverys Specialty Insurance Company, isitself wholly owned by MPMIC, the ultimate parent company of the Coverys insuranceholding company group. MPMIC was originally organized as a Joint UnderwritingAssociation (“JUA”) established under the Massachusetts Acts of 1975. The Massachusettslegislature created the JUA to guarantee the continued availability of medical malpracticeprofessional liability insurance within the State.In July 1992, the name of the JUA was changed to the Massachusetts Medical ProfessionalInsurance Association (“MMPIA”), to reflect that the entity was no longer a jointunderwriting association. In January of 1995, the MMPIA was converted to a mutualinsurance company known as the Medical Professional Mutual Insurance Company(“MPMIC”), which assumed all of the assets and liabilities of the Association.On May 2, 1995, MPMIC received its certificate to transact business in Massachusetts as amutual insurance company, and formed a downstream holding company, ProMutual Group,Inc. Coverys Specialty Insurance Company was organized on December 19, 2014 as anexcess and surplus lines insurance company domiciled in the State of New Jersey, and is awholly owned subsidiary of ProMutual Group, Inc., itself a wholly owned subsidiary ofMPMIC. The Company and other affiliated companies of MPMIC are collectively referredto as “Coverys”.CSIC is authorized to write multiple lines of business which are designated as “b” perN.J.S.A. 17:17-1 and N.J.S.A. 17:22-6.69 to entitle it to engage in the kinds of businessspecified on a Surplus Lines only basis.The Company is eligible to write excess and surplus lines in all fifty states and the District ofColumbia and is currently writing business, primarily medical professional liabilityinsurance, in forty-seven states. The Company’s statutory home in the State of New Jersey islocated at 67 East Park Place, Suite 703, Morristown, New Jersey 07960. The RegisteredAgent of the Company is Joseph Murphy, Chief Operating Officer and Secretary, located at67 East Park Place, Suite 703, Morristown, New Jersey 07960.Capital StockThe Capital Stock of the Company at December 31, 2018 was 2,000,000 consisting of200,000 authorized and outstanding shares issued with a 10 par value per share. ProMutualGroup, Inc. owns 100% of the Company’s outstanding stock.3
Dividends to StockholdersThe Company did not issue dividends during the examination period.MANAGEMENT AND CONTROLThe Company’s bylaws state that the number of directors who shall serve on the Board shallbe three, the exact number of which shall be fixed from time to time by resolution of theBoard. At December 31, 2018, there were three board members as follows:DirectorsGregg L. HansonJoseph G. MurphyJose R. ZorolaPrincipal OccupationChairman of the Board, Chief Executive OfficerChief Operating Officer, SecretaryChief Underwriting OfficerMPMIC maintains an audit committee which is responsible for recommending the election ofindependent certified public accountants, reviewing the insurer’s financial condition, thescope and results of the independent audit and any internal audit, nominating candidates fordirector for election by shareholders or policyholders, evaluating the performance of officersdeemed to be principal officers of the insurer and recommending to the board of directors theselection and compensation, including bonuses or other special payments of the principalofficers. As of December 31, 2018, the Audit Committee was comprised of the followingmembers:Robert K. Sheridan, ChairTheodore A. CalianosMichael B. DriscollMichael W. LougeBrenda E. RichardsonMaryanne C. BombaughPaul J. DesjardinsJohn H. GillespieDonna M. NorrisPeter T. RobertsonN.J.S.A. 17:27A-4d.(3) requires that no less than one-third of the directors be directors whoare not officers or employees of the corporation or of any entity controlling, controlled by orunder common control with the corporation and who are not beneficial owners of acontrolling interest in the voting securities of the corporation or any such entity. TheCompany is also required to comply with the provisions of N.J.S.A. 17:27A-4d(4) whichstates that, “The board of directors of a domestic insurer shall establish one or morecommittees comprised solely of directors who are not officers or employees of the insurer orof any entity controlling, controlled by, or under common control with, the insurer and whoare not beneficial owners of a controlling interest in the voting securities of the insurer or anysuch entity. N.J.S.A. 17:27A-4d.(5) provides that the provisions of paragraphs (3) and (4) ofsubsection N.J.S.A. 17:27A-4d. shall not apply to a domestic insurer if the person controllingthe insurer is an entity having a board of directors and committees thereof that substantiallymeet the requirements of those paragraphs.MPMIC is the ultimate parent of the Company and MPMIC has a board of directors and anaudit committee that substantially meet the requirements of independence as outlined inN.J.S.A. 17:27A-4d(3) (4).4
The executive officers of the Company as of December 31, 2018, were as follows:OfficerGregg Lee HansonJoseph G. MurphyJose R. ZorolaTodd C. MillsErin B. BagleySimeon J. MezzichEdward T. LyonsTitleChief Executive Officer and ChairmanChief Operating Officer and SecretaryChief Underwriting OfficerChief Financial Officer and TreasurerVice President and Assistant SecretaryPresidentSenior Vice PresidentCONFLICT OF INTEREST PROCEDURESThe Company has established a procedure for disclosure to its Board of any materialinterest or affiliation on the part of its officers, directors and employees that are inconflict with the official duties of such individuals.Each year, the Company requires its directors, officers and employees to sign a conflictof interest questionnaire and to divulge any potential conflicts of interest that could havean impact on the way they conduct the Company’s business. The completed DisclosureStatements are reviewed by the Compliance Manager, in consultation with the LegalDepartment.CORPORATE RECORDSA review was made of the Board minutes and committee minutes for the period ofexamination. This examination determined that the minutes adequately approve and supportthe Company’s transactions and events.PARENT, SUBSIDIARIES, AND AFFILIATESThe Company is a member of an insurance company holding system as defined in N.J.S.A.17:27A-1 et seq. Accordingly, the Company has filed with the State of New Jersey aninsurance holding company registration as is required under N.J.S.A. 17:27A-3.The following abbreviated organizational chart at December 31, 2017, identifies theinsurance companies within the holding company organization:5
Intercompany AgreementsManagement Services AgreementThe Company entered into a Management Services Agreement with its affiliated companyPSIC effective January 1, 2017. Under the terms of the agreement, PSIC provides servicesincluding, but not limited to: underwriting, policy issuance and administration, riskmanagement claims management and financial administration to the Company. In return, theCompany pays PSIC a pro-rata share of Group expenses per the terms of the agreement. Themanagement fee expense paid to PSIC under this agreement was 13,744,743 and 5,416,541in 2018 and 2017, respectively.Reinsurance AgreementCSIC entered into a 100% quota share reinsurance agreement with MPMIC effective January1, 2015, which was revised on April 17, 2015. Under the terms of this agreement, CSICcedes, and MPMIC reinsures, a one hundred percent (100%) quota share of the netunderwriting assets and liabilities of the Company under all insurance business written bythe Company, net of third-party reinsurance, including any reserve development.Tax Allocation AgreementThe Company and its affiliates, along with the ultimate parent, MPMIC, file a consolidatedfederal income tax return. Effective June 30, 2013, MPMIC and certain affiliates enteredinto the original Tax Allocation Agreement, which covers the allocation, settlement, andfinancial statement presentation of current federal income taxes among companies in theconsolidated income tax return of MPMIC and its subsidiaries. The Company entered intothe Tax Allocation Agreement through a Consolidated Agreement effective June 12, 2015.6
The Company reported 72,260 due to and 34,682 due from Medical Professional MutualInsurance Company at December 31, 2018 and 2017, respectively, related to the federal taxsharing agreement.FIDELITY BOND AND OTHER INSURANCE COVERAGEThe Company maintains fidelity coverage with limits of 10,000,000 and a 100,000deductible. The aggregate limit of liability exceeds the NAIC suggested minimum. Allemployees are covered by the fidelity bond.The Company has further protected its interests and property by policies of insurancecovering other insurable risks.TERRITORY AND PLAN OF OPERATIONThe Company is 100% owned by ProMutual Group, Inc. and is eligible to write excess andsurplus lines in all fifty states, and the District of Columbia. CSIC is currently writingbusiness, principally medical professional liability insurance, in forty-eight states, excludingMontana, North Dakota and Wyoming.As a New Jersey Domestic Surplus Lines insurer, the Company has a network of licensed,independent surplus lines brokers with expertise in medical professional liability insuranceacross the United States to offer Coverys Specialty’s products. In addition, CSIC’s existingbroker relationships are utilized where appropriate and when approved for Excess andSurplus business. At year-end 2018, about 12% of business was produced by MGAs and theremaining amount, approximately 88%, was procured by other independent producers.REINSURANCEReinsurance Agreements with AffiliatesThe Company entered into a 100% quota share reinsurance agreement with MPMIC effectiveJanuary 1, 2015 and revised as of April 17, 2015. As noted above, under the terms of theagreement, CSIC cedes, and MPMIC reinsures, a one hundred percent (100%) quota share ofthe net underwriting assets and liabilities of the Company under all insurance businesswritten by the Company, net of third-party reinsurance, including any reserve development.Reinsurance Agreements with Non-AffiliatesThe Company cedes a relatively small amount of business to U.S. and Non-U.S. authorizedreinsurers, which is primarily comprised of Excess of Loss reinsurance agreements.ACCOUNTS AND RECORDSThe Company’s accounting books and records are maintained at its main administrativeoffice located at One Financial Center, Boston, Massachusetts 02111.7
The Company’s financial statements are manually prepared by the Coverys FinanceDepartment. The trial balances are prepared utilizing data from the PRO Financial generalledger system. Pro Financial is the financial reporting and general ledger system utilized byCSIC to record, analyze and report financial results. On a quarterly basis, key accountingpersonnel reconcile all subsidiary ledgers, subsystem activity and supporting documents tothe general ledger and produce the Company’s trial balances. The trial balances are thenutilized to produce the financial statements.NetCore is the primary policy administration system, and processes policy billings, claims,accounts receivable and payables. NetCore is a fully integrated system, with Policy andClaims data automatically feeding the accounting systems for billing and disbursementpurposes. Premiums are received through a lockbox. If physical checks are received at theCoverys offices, the checks are sent to the finance department directly from the mailroom forrecording and processing.CSIC utilizes an Enterprise Data Warehouse that stores policy, billing and claims informationwhich is loaded daily. The Company uses Tableau, Excel and Power BI to query the data,and SSRS is used to generate reports for operational purposes. For reinsurance, activity isexported from NetCore into an Excel file which is uploaded into FRS, the reinsuranceadministration system.Coverys outsources its i
mutual insurance company, and formed a downstream holding companyProMutual Group, , Inc. Coverys Specialty Insurance Company was organized on December 19, 2014 an as excess and surplus lines insurance company domiciled in the State of New Jersey, and is a wholly owned subsidiary of P
