Transcription
View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.ukbrought to you byCOREprovided by Via Sapientiae: The Institutional Repository at DePaul UniversityDePaul Journal of Art, Technology& Intellectual Property LawVolume 27Issue 1 Fall 2016Article 1Table of ContentsFollow this and additional works at: https://via.library.depaul.edu/jatipPart of the Computer Law Commons, Cultural Heritage Law Commons, Entertainment, Arts, andSports Law Commons, Intellectual Property Law Commons, Internet Law Commons, and the Science andTechnology Law CommonsRecommended CitationTable of Contents, 27 DePaul J. Art, Tech. & Intell. Prop. L. (2019)Available at: his Front Matter is brought to you for free and open access by the College of Law at Via Sapientiae. It has beenaccepted for inclusion in DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property Law by an authorized editor ofVia Sapientiae. For more information, please contact digitalservices@depaul.edu.
et al.: Table of Contents&DEPAUL JOURNAL OF ART, TECHNOLOGYINTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAWVolume XXVIIFall 2016Number ]SEMINAR ARTICLEA Legal Perspective on the Protection of UnderwaterCultural Heritage Resources in the United States:Is the Abandoned Shipwreck Act Lost at Sea,.or is It Worthy of Salvage?Jeffrey Cohn1CASE SUMMARIESPhoenix Entertainment Partners v. Rumsey,829 F.3d 817 (2016) .Jordan MelvinKirtsaeng v. John Wiley & Sons, Inc.,136 S. Ct. 1979 (2016) .41Eric Garcia49Victoria Campbell59Alexandra Navratil73Useful Article or Creative Design:Varsity Brands, Inc. v. Star Athletica, LLC.Kristy Diesner91Authors Guild v. Google, Inc.,804 F.3d 202 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 16, 2015) .CASE NOTESExamining the Seventh Circuit's Repudiation ofthe Transformative Fair Use Analysis:.Kienitz v. Sconnie Nation, LLC.iPublished by Via Sapientiae, 20191
DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property Law, Vol. 27, Iss. 1 [2019], Art. 1DePaulJournal ofArt, Technology & IntellectualPropertyLaw is publishedsemi-annually for 40.00 per year by DePaul College of Law, 25 EastJackson Boulevard, Chicago, Illinois, 60604-2287. Second-class postagepaid at Chicago, Illinois 60604-2287 and additional mailing offices.POSTMASTER: Send change of address notice to DePaul Journal of Art,Technology & Intellectual Property Law, 25 East Jackson Boulevard,Chicago, Illinois, 60604-2287.Cite as 27 DEPAUL J. ART, TECH. & INTELL. PROP. L.Copyright 2016 by DePaul UniversityAll Rights ReservedPrice: 40.00 annual subscription; 20.00 single issue.Subscriptions are accepted only on a per volume basis, are payable in advance and will berenewed automatically unless notification to the contrary is received in writing.Change of address should be mailed to the Journal at least thirty days before the nextissue is to be distributed. Please send the old and new address, including ZIP codes.Rates for advertising quoted upon request.&The Journal invites the submission of unsolicited manuscripts. Please confine theauthor's name and biographical information to a removable title page. Citations shouldconform to the Bluebook: A Uniform System of Citation ( 2 0 th ed. 2015) by The ColumbiaLaw Review, the HarvardLaw Review, the University of Pennsylvania Law Review, andthe Yale Law Journal. Send manuscripts to DePaul Journal of Art, TechnologyIntellectual Property Law, 25 East Jackson Boulevard, Chicago, Illinois 60604.Manuscripts will not be returned unless specifically requested and accompanied withproper return postage.Comments and suggestions regarding the content of this publication are invited.DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property LawDePaul University College of Law25 East Jackson BoulevardChicago, Illinois 60604-2287E-mail:depaul.jatip@gmail.comWeb ntactivities/journals/Pages/default.aspxPrinted in U.S.A.Cover Design byThe 2007-2008 Editorial BoardThe moral right of the 2007-2008 Editorial Board has been l27/iss1/12
et al.: Table of Contents&DEPAUL JOURNAL OF ART, TECHNOLOGYINTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAWNumber IFall 2016Volume XXVIIBOARD OF EDITORSMADELAINE THOMASEditor in ChiefNATASHA MANGALTOM CALASCIBETTASUKHPAL KOONERCase Notes AndComments EditorLegislative UpdatesEditorLead Articles & BusinessEditorDEBA ALAMLUMA ZAYADLAUREN BURSEYCase Summaries EditorTechnical Productions& Symposium DirectorSeminar & Below-TheLine EditorWRITING STAFFKRISTY DIESNERSUBARNA BHATTACHARYAMORGAN DRAKEALEXANDRA NAVRATILSTEPHEN CHOIJORDAN MELVINJOSH SHANCERERIC GARCIAFACULTY ADVISORPROFESSOR MARGIT LIVINGSTONMember, National Conference of Law ReviewsiiiPublished by Via Sapientiae, 20193
DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property Law, Vol. 27, Iss. 1 [2019], Art. 1DEPAUL UNIVERSITYGENERAL ADMINISTRATIONRev. Dennis H. Holtschneider, C.M., Ed.D.PresidentMarten L. denBoer, Ph.D. ProvostJeffrey Bethke.Executive Vice PresidentRev. Edward R. Udovic, C.M., Ph.D. Secretary of the UniversityVice Presidentfor Teaching & LearningResourcesSeniorExecutivefor University MissionJay Braatz .Vice Presidentfor Planningand PresidentialAdministrationGene Zdziarski, Phd. .Vice Presidentfor Student AffairsErin Minn. Senior Vice Presidentfor AdvancementSherri Sidler.ControllerRobert Janis. Vice PresidentforFacility OperationsDavid H. Kalsbeek, Ph.D.Sen. V. P. for Enrollment Management & MarketingBob McCormick. Vice PresidentforInformation ServicesElizabeth F. Ortiz, Ed.D.Vice PresidentforInstitutionalDiversity and EquityJos6 D. Padilla, J.D.Vice President and General CounselLinda Blakley.Vice PresidentofPublic Relations and CommunicationsStephanie Smith.Vice Presidentfor Human ResourcesCOLLEGE OF LAW ADMINISTRATIONJennifer Rosato Perea.frEr.Allison Brownell Tirres.Barbara B. BresslerSumi Cho . PeMargit LivingstonAllen Moye.DeanProfessorofvLawAssociate Deanfor Academic AffairsAssociate Professor ofuLaw. Associate Deanfor ExperientialEducationAssociate ProfessorofLaw.Associate Dean.for Non-D ProgramsProfessorofLaw.Associate Deanfor Faculty DevelopmentProfessorofLaw. Associate Dean for Information Technology and Library ServicesDirector, Rinn Law LibraryAssociate ProfessorofLawMichael S. Burns.William Chamberlain .Associate Deanfor Student Affairs. Assistant Dean for Law CareerServicesDeborah Howard.Assistant Deanfor InstitutionalPlanning, Strategy and ResearchErika Roditis .Kortney Moore. Director of Business Administration and Operations.Director of ip/vol27/iss1/14
et al.: Table of ContentsCOLLEGE OF LAW FACULTYBenjamin E. Alba .Director,Academic Support, Student Advising & Bar PassageB.S., DePaul University J.D., Loyola University of ChicagoSioban Albiol.ClinicalInstructorB.A., University of Texas at Austin I J.D., Loyola University of ChicagoSusan A. Bandes.CentennialDistinguishedResearch Professor ofLawB.A., State University of New York (Buffalo) IJ.D., University of MichiganDistinguishedResearch Professor of LawM. Cherif Bassiouni.PresidentEmeritus, InternationalHuman Rights Law InstituteJ.D., Indiana University I LL.M., John Marshall Law SchoolS.J.D., George Washington University LL.B., University of CairoMonu Bedi.AssistantA.B., Dartmouth University I J.D., Harvard UniversityProfessorofLawM.Phil., University of Cambridge. Associate Deanfor ExperientialEducationAssociate Professor ofLawDirectorEmeritus, Centerfor Intellectual Propertyand Information TechnologyB.S., University of Minnesota J.D., DePaul UniversityClinical Instructor.Patrick F. CassidyBarbara B. Bressler .B.A., University of Illinois IJ.D., Chicago-Kent College of LawEm ily Cauble .Assistant Professor ofLawB.B.A., University of Notre Dame IJ.D., University of Michigan Law SchoolEmeritus Professor of LawLeonard F. Cavise .FoundingDirector, Centerfor Public Interest LawB.A., Hamilton College IJ.D., Georgetown UniversitySumi K. Cho .Professor ofLawB.A., University of California-Berkeley IJ.D., University of California-BerkeleyPh.D., University of California-BerkeleyA lberto R . C oll.Professorof LawDirector, European andLatin American Legal Studies ProgramDirector,InternationalLaw LL.M ProgramDirector, InternationalHuman Rights Law & PolicyB.A., Princeton University IJ.D., University of VirginiaPh.D., University of VirginiaM ichelle C ue .B.A., University of Illinois IJ.D., University of IllinoisLegal W ritingInstructorJohn F. Decker.EmeritusB.A., University of Iowa I J.D., Creighton UniversityProfessorof LawLL.M., New York University I J.S.D., New York UniversityProfessorof LawKatheryn M . Dutenhaver.AssociateDirector, Centerfor Dispute ResolutionB.A., North Central College J.D., DePaul UniversityM.A., University of ChicagoW endy Netter Epstein.AssistantProfessorofLawB.A., University of Illinois IJ.D., Harvard Law SchoolRebecca FeinbergB.A., Yeshiva UniversityI J.D.,.University of Pennsylvania Law SchoolLecturer in LawM.B.E., University of Pennsylvania Medical School IM.S., Johns Hopkins UniversityDavid L. FranklinAssociate Deanfor Institutional ComplianceAssociate ProfessorofLaw.B.A., Yale College IJ.D., University of ChicagoProfessor ofLaw.Director, Asian Legal Studies ProgramDirector, MasterofLaws in InternationalLaw- InternationalBusiness, Commercial&Trade lawDirector, Master ofLaws in TaxationDirector, Vienna University ofEconomics Exchange ProgramJerold A. FriedlandB.A., New York University M.A., New York UniversityJ.D., Brooklyn Law School LL.M., Georgetown UniversityVPublished by Via Sapientiae, 20195
DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property Law, Vol. 27, Iss. 1 [2019], Art. 1Stefania Fusco.Visiting Assistant ProfessorofLawVisiting Faculty & FellowsJ.S.D. & J.S.M., Stanford Law School ILL.M., Chicago-Kent College of LawM.B.A., University of Illinois at ChicagoDottore in Giurisprudenza (J.D.), Universita degli Studi di TorinoSarah Gelsomino.Patty GerstenblithClinical Instructor.DistinguishedResearch ProfessorofLawDirector, Centerfor Art, Museum & CulturalHeritageLawA.B., Bryn Mawr College IPh.D., Harvard UniversityJ.D., Northwestern UniversityRobert Gevirtz.Andrew Gold .ClinicalInstructorProfessor ofLawB.A., Dartmouth College IJ.D., Duke UniversitySteven R. G reenberger.AssociateProfessorofLawB.A., University of Illinois IJ.D., Yale UniversityM ichael G rynberg .Associate ProfessorofLawB.A., Carleton College IJ.D., University of Virginia Law SchoolSusan C. Haddad.Clinical InstructorM.A., University of Chicago I J.D., John Marshall Law SchoolMaria Harrigan.Clinical InstructorDirector, Family Law ClinicJ.D. Loyola University of ChicagoBrian F. Havel.DistinguishedResearch ProfessorofLawAssociate Deanfor InternationalAffairsDirector, InternationalAviation Law InstituteB.C.L., National University of Ireland I LL.M., National University of IrelandDip. Eur. L., National University of Ireland I B. Mod., University of DublinM.A., University of Dublin I LL.M., Columbia UniversityJ.S.D., Columbia UniversityMax N. Helveston.Assistant ProfessorofLawB.A., University of Michigan IJ.D., Yale UniversityDonald H. J. HermannA.B., Stanford University.Northwestern UniversityProfessor ofLaw and PhilosophyI M.A.,J.D., Columbia University ILL.M, Harvard UniversityPh.D., Northwestern University I M.A.A.H., Art Institute of ChicagoM.L.A., University of ChicagoM ichael Jacobs.DistinguishedResearch ProfessorofLawCo-Director, InternationalAviation Law InstituteB.A., Dartmouth College IJ.D., Yale UniversityM.P.H., Johns Hopkins UniversityBarry s Control CenterB.A., University of Chicago I J.D., Yale UniversityRoberta R. Kwall.Raymond P. Niro ProfessorofIntellectual PropertyLawFoundingDirector, Centerfor Intellectual PropertyLaw & Information TechnologyA.B., Brown University I J.D., University of PennsylvaniaJulie D . Law ton.AssistantProfessorofLawDirector, Housing & Community Development Legal ClinicB.A., Florida A&M University I J.D., Howard UniversityL.L.M., Georgetown UniversityWayne K. Lewis.Emeritus ProfessorofLawB.A., Rutgers University I J.D., Cornell ol27/iss1/16
et al.: Table of ContentsDeanfor Faculty DevelopmentProfessorof LawMargit Livingston.AssociateDirector, Centerfor Animal LawDirector, Centerfor Intellectual PropertyLaw & Information TechnologyB.A., Augsburg College I M.A., University of MinnesotaJ.D., University of Minnesota ILL.M., University of IllinoisA ngelica Lopez.B.W.S. & B.S. Missouri State University IM.S.W., University of KansasClinicalInstructorJ.D., Northwestern UniversityScott F. M ain .ClinicalInstructorA.B., University of Chicago J.D., Loyola University of ChicagoWriting InstructorJody M arcucci.LegalB.A., University of Wisconsin IJ.D., DePaul UniversityProfessorof LawG regory M ark.B.A., Butler University I M.A., Harvard UniversityJ.D., University of ChicagoCary Martin ShelbyAssistant Professorof Law.B.S., University of Illinois IJ.D., Northwestern UniversityD irector, Civil Rights ClinicJoey L. M ogul .B.S., Oberlin College I J.D., City University of New York School of LawM ark Moller.AssistantProfessorofLawB.A., Duke University I J.D., University of ChicagoL.L.M., University of Cambridge.Daniel I. MoralesAssistant Professor ofLawB.A., Williams College IJ.D., Yale Law SchoolAssociate Deanfor Information Technology and Library ServicesAssociate ProfessorofLawDirector, Rinn Law LibraryAllen Moye .B.A., Howard University IJ.D., University of RichmondM.L.S., Catholic UniversityJohn Q. MulliganFedEx/UnitedAirlines Resident Research Fellow.B.A., University of Wisconsin-MadisonI J.D., College of William& MaryM arlene Nicholson.EmeritusProfessorof LawB.A., University of California, Los Angeles I J.D., University of California, Los AngelesWritingInstructorA llison I. O rtlieb.LegalB.A., University of Chicago IJ.D., University of ChicagoBruce L. OttleyProfessor ofLaw.Director, DePaul University/University College Dublin Cooperative ProgramCo-Director,InternationalAviation Law InstituteB.A., University of Missouri-Kansas City I M.A., University of IowaJ.D., University of Iowa LL.M., Columbia UniversityAssociate Directorof Legal Analysis, Research & CommunicationMartha Pagliari .B.A., University of Notre Dame IJ.D., DePaul University.Jody RaphaelVisitingProfessorofLawSenior Research FellowSchiller DuCanto & Fleck Family Law CenterA.B., Bryn Mawr College IJ.D., University of ChicagoProfessorof LawSteven Resnicoff.Co-Director, Centerfor Jewish Law andJudaic StudiesB.A., Princeton University J.D., Yale UniversityRabbinic, Beth Medrash GovohaJohn C. Roberts.B.S., Northwestern University I LL.B., Yale UniversityZoe Robinson .Dean EmeritusProfessorofLawAssistant ProfessorofLawB.Mus., Griffith University IB.A., Australian National UniversityLL.B., Australian National University I J.D., University of ChicagoDavid Rodriguez.Director, Third year in PracticeVisiting ProfessorofLawB.S., University of Illinois IJ.D., University of MichiganViiPublished by Via Sapientiae, 20197
DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property Law, Vol. 27, Iss. 1 [2019], Art. 1Jennifer R osato P erea .DeanProfessor of LawB.S., Cornell University J.D., University of PennsylvaniaHoward M . Rubin .Associate Deanfor Lawyering SkillsAssociate ProfessorofLawDirector, FieldPlacement ProgramB.S., University of Illinois I J.D., DePaul UniversityJane Rutherford.Professor ofLawA.B., University of Chicago IJ.D., University of MichiganJoshua D . Sarnoff .Professorof LawB.S., Massachusetts Institute of Technology J.D., Stanford UniversityJeffrey M . Shaman.St.Vincent de PaulProfessorofLawFaculty Director, Centerfor Public Interest LawB.A., Pennsylvania State University I J.D., University of Southern CaliforniaLL.M., Georgetown UniversityStephen A. Siegel.DistinguishedResearch ProfessorofLawB.A., Columbia University I J.D., Harvard UniversityLL.M., Harvard UniversityTerry Smith.Distinguished Research ProfessorofLawB.A., Brown University IJ.D., New York UniversityRaia Stoicheva.Clinical InstructorSusan Thrower.AssociateProfessorofLawDirector, Legal Analysis, Research and CommunicationB.A., University of Virginia IJ.D., Wake Forest UniversityAllison Brownell Tirres.AssociateDeanfor Academic AffairsAssociate ProfessorofLawB.A., Princeton University I M.A., Harvard UniversityJ.D., Harvard University I Ph.D., Harvard UniversityV incent V itullo.Emeritus ProfessorofLawA.B., Loyola University of Chicago IJ.D., Loyola University of ChicagoLL.M., Yale UniversityAnthony G. Volini.Senior Legal Writing InstructorB.S., Benedictine University I J.D., Loyola University of ChicagoM ark C. W eber.St.Vincent de Paul ProfessorofLawB.A., Columbia University IJ.D., Yale UniversityJudge Warren D. Wolfson.DistinguishedVisiting ProfessorofLawB.S. University of Illinois at Chicago ILL.B., University of ol27/iss1/18
et al.: Table of ContentsRINN LAW LIBRARY STAFFAssociate Deanfor Information Technology & LibraryServicesAssociate ProfessorB.A., Howard University I J.D., Universty of RichmondAllen Moye .M.L.S., Catholic UniversityMichael Schiffer.AssociateB.A., University of Chicago IJ.D., University of MichiganM.L.S., Rosary CollegeDirectorfor ComputerServicesStacks Manager/CirculationAssistantJames Brownridge.InterlibraryLoan, CirculationAssistant.Kim GaineyServices, Reference LibrarianMark Giangrande.FacultyB.S., Northwestern University IJ.D., IIT Chicago-Kent College of LawM.L.S., University of TexasHead ofAccess Services.Heather HummonsAssistantReservers Coordinator/CirculationKristy Lueshen.Librarian, Legal Research SpecialistM aria W illm er .B.A., University of Michigan IA.M.L.S., University of MichiganAcquisitions ManagerLenore Boehm .Associate Directorfor Technical Services & Processing.Denise GlynnB.S., Northern Illinois University I M.L.S., Rosary CollegeGovernment Documents & Information LibrarianJack Gorman .AssistantD avid Labno.CatalogingA ssistantE lizabeth Shivers.SerialscquisitionsAssistantD aniel Ursini.AixPublished by Via Sapientiae, 20199
DePaul Journal of Art, Technology & Intellectual Property Law, Vol. 27, Iss. 1 [2019], Art. 1ADJUNCT FACULTYJeff BeckerRobert LoebShawn BerssonAngelica LopezSteve BrandstedtTerrence MacCarthyMary M. BroshananAnne MacMillanVince BrowneScott MainNatalie CarlomangoTimothy M. McCarthyCarrie ChapmanVY'Shaey MitchellJames ClarkJoey MogulJoseph ComerRalph MorrisKaren ContiBrian NachEmily CzerniejewskiJack O'MalleyDavid D'AmatoChristina PannosKelli DudleyTodd PughColin DunnShankar RamamurthyKatheryn DutenhaverMartin RobinsMaureen EganKari RollinsDavid GanfieldAna Santos RutschmanSara GarberKatherine SchostokRobert GevirtzSang ShimChristopher GrohmanRaya StoichevaEllen GutiontovTheodore ThomasValerie Gutmann KochClaudia Valenzuela RivasSusan HaddadElisabeth WardKay HanlonTorrick WardMaria HarriganPaul WintersKeith HebeisenDestiny WoodsThomas HennellyRichard HuttJohn HynesPatrick JonesBrent KidwellSarah KingClaire KossmanJohn KirbyLeslie LandisValerie LeopoldSteven LevyLisa LillyDaniel /iss1/110
& Intellectual Property Law Volume 27 Issue 1 Fall 2016 Article 1 Table of Contents Follow this and additional works at: https://via.library.depaul.edu/jatip Part of the Computer Law Commons, Cultural Heritage Law Commons, Entertainment, Arts, and Sports Law Commons, Intellectual Property Law Commons, Internet Law Commons, and the Science and
