NATIONAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON INSTITUTIONAL

Transcription

U.S. Department of EducationOffice of Postsecondary EducationNATIONAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON INSTITUTIONAL QUALITY AND INTEGRITY(NACIQI)June 22, 23, and 24, 20168:30am-5:30pmDouble Tree by Hilton HotelWashington BallroomWashington DC-Crystal City300 Army Navy DriveArlington, VA 22202NOTE: Dates and times listed for agenda items are subject to change.Wednesday, June 22 Day 18:30am WelcomeTed Mitchell, Ph.D., Under Secretary8:45am Welcome and IntroductionsSusan D. Phillips, Ph.D., NACIQI ChairpersonConsent Agenda and ProceduresSusan D. Phillips, Ph.D., NACIQI Chairperson Call for third-party oral comments Call for removal of any items from the consent agenda Move and second consent agenda Call for vote on the consent agenda Note: Renewals of recognition (under 34 CFR 602) are not on the consent agenda forthis meeting.Consent Agenda Compliance Report State Approval Agency for Public PostsecondaryVocational EducationPuerto Rico State Agency for the Approval of Public Postsecondary Vocational, TechnicalInstitutions and ProgramsReview Procedures for Renewal Applications (with pilot project questions)Susan D. Phillips, Ph.D., NACIQI Chairperson Primary readers introduce agency application Department staff provides briefing1

Primary readers’ questions of the agency (standard questions as well as the first threesets of questions under the pilot project)Other questions by NACIQI followed by response and comment from agencyThird-party commentsAgency responds to third-party commentsDepartment staff responds to agency and third-party commentsDiscussion and voteFinal set of pilot project questions9:15am Renewal of Recognition American Psychological Association (APA), Commission onAccreditationNACIQI Primary Readers:Jill Derby, Ph.D.Anne D. Neal, J.D.Department Staff:Chuck MulaAgency Representatives:Kathleen J. Bieschke, Ph.D. APA Commission on AccreditationChairperson, APAJacqueline Remondet Wall, Ph.D. Director, Office of ProgramConsultation and Accreditation, APAThird Party Oral Commenters:1) René Puliatti Executive Director, California Psychology Internship Council2) Pirouz Ganji Registered Psychological Assistant, PsyD. Candidate: California Institute ofIntegral Studies, APA Division 39 student member3) Elena Gomez Clinical Psychologist, The Hume Center4) Juliet Rohde-Brown, Ph.D. Core Faculty and Director of Clinical Training, PacificaGraduate Institute Clinical Program, Academic Senate Secretary5) Bayla G. Travis, Psy.D. Clinical Psychologist - Chronic Pain Specialist, IntegrativeWellness Center6) Amanda T. Stewart California Licensed Clinical Psychologist (CA PSY27174)7) Jaclyn D. Deilgat, Ph.D. Licensed Clinical Psychologist (PSY27879); Executive Director,Collective Connections Counseling & Consultation Services8) Oksana Yakushko, PhD Core Faculty, Chair, Clinical Psychology Program, PacificaGraduate Institute, Pacifica.edu9) Andrea Kaplan, Ph.D. Professor, Clinical Psychology, American School of ProfessionalPsychology10) Farzana Khan, MA11) Suzanne Stambaugh, Psy.D. Licensed Psychologist (TX 3-6459) Adjunct Faculty: AustinCommunity College Supervising Psychologist, Psychological ARTS Private PracticePsychotherapist12) Kelly Burns, J.D., Psy.D. Staff Psychologist & Clinical and Assessment Supervisor,Richmond Area Multi-Services2

13) Bryant L. Welch, J.D., Ph.D. and Associates14) Henriette van Eck, PhD, LLC15) Megan O’Banion, Psy.D. (PSY 23744) Director of Clinical Training and AssociateProfessor, Clinical Psychology Program (APA-accredited), ASPP at Argosy University, SanFrancisco Bay Area16) Allan Scholom, Ph.D. Clinical Psychologist / Psychoanalyst, Chicago Center forPsychoanalysis17) Jennifer Frazier, MS, Doctoral Candidate Palo Alto University18) Sheena Demery, Psy.D Early Career Psychologist19) Ginger Rennie, Psy.D. Early Career Psychologist20) Tara Pir, PhD, CEO/President Institute for Multicultural Counseling and EducationServices, Inc. (IMCES)21) Shawn Rubin, PsyD Licensed Clinical Psychologist, Former Administrator of GraduateDegree Programs in Humanistic Psychology, Formerly Michigan School of ProfessionalPsychology & Saybrook University22) Scarlett Luger-Klein, MA Clinical Psychology Student at California Institute of IntegralStudies, PsyD Department23) Nadia Thalji, MA Doctoral Candidate in Clinical Psychology at Pacifica GraduateInstitute Student Committee Member of The California Psychology Internship Council(CAPIC)24) Melodie R. Schaefer, Psy.D. Licensed Psychologist, State of California12:00pm BREAK12:15pm Renewal of Recognition Accreditation Commission for Acupuncture and OrientalMedicine (ACAOM)NACIQI Primary Readers:Arthur Rothkopf, J.D.Federico Zaragoza, Ph.D.Department Staff:Rachael Shultz, Ed.D.Agency Representatives:Mark S. McKenzie, PhD MsOM LAc Executive Director,ACAOMJohn Paul Liang, PhD LAc Chair, ACAOMKarl Gauby, PhD, JD, Director of Regulatory Affairs, ACAOM1:00pm LUNCH3

2:00pm Renewal of Recognition American Bar Association (ABA), Council of the Section ofLegal Education and Admissions to the BarNACIQI Primary Readers:Roberta L. Derlin, Ph.D.Arthur E. Keiser, Ph.D.Department Staff:Nicole Harris, Ed.D.Agency Representatives:Barry Currier Managing Director, ABAStephanie Giggetts Accreditation Counsel, ABAWilliam Adams Deputy Managing Director, ABARebecca White Berch Justice of the Supreme Court of Arizonaand Chair of the Council of the Section of Legal Education andAdmissions to the Bar Supreme Court of ArizonaThird Party Oral Commenters:1) Montgomery Blair Sibley3:00pm BREAK3:15pm Renewal of Recognition Accrediting Bureau of Health Education Schools (ABHES)NACIQI Primary Readers:Simon BoehmeAnne D. Neal, J.D.Department Staff:Valerie LeforAgency Representatives:Ms. Florence S. Tate Executive Director, ABHESJohn A. Yena, MBA Chairman of the Board, ABHESAmy Rowe Director of Institutional Review and Development,ABHES4:00pm BREAK4:15pm Renewal of Recognition Commission on Accrediting of the Association ofTheological Schools (ATS)NACIQI Primary Readers:Hank Brown, J.D.Federico Zaragoza, Ph.D.Department Staff:Chuck Mula4

Agency Representatives:Daniel O. Aleshire, PhD Executive Director, ATSAlton B. Pollard, III, PhD Chair of ATS Board of Commissionersand Dean at Howard University School of Divinity, ATSThomas M. Tanner, PhD Director, Accreditation and InstitutionalEvaluation, ATS5:30pm Closing RemarksThursday, June 23 Day 28:30am Welcome and IntroductionsSusan D. Phillips, Ph.D., NACIQI ChairpersonReview Procedures for Renewal Applications (with pilot project questions)Susan D. Phillips, Ph.D, NACIQI Chairperson Primary readers introduce agency application Department staff provides briefing Primary readers’ questions of the agency (standard questions as well as the first threesets of questions under the pilot project) Other questions by NACIQI followed by response and comment from agency Third-party comments Agency responds to third-party comments Department staff responds to agency and third-party comments Discussion and vote Final set of pilot project questions8:45am Renewal of Recognition Accrediting Council for Independent Colleges and Schools(ACICS)NACIQI Primary Readers:Ralph Wolff, J.D.Frank H. Wu, J.D.Department Staff:Steve PorcelliAgency Representatives:Mr. Anthony Steven Bieda Executive In Charge, ACICSThird Party Oral Commenters:1) Robert Shireman Senior Fellow, The Century Foundation2) Christopher J. Madaio, Esq. Maryland Office of the Attorney General, ConsumerProtection Division3) Ben Miller Senior Director for Postsecondary Education, Center for American Progress4) Steve Gunderson President and CEO, Association of Private Sector Colleges andUniversities5

5) Seamus Ware Critical Accounts Program Manager, Hewlett Packard Enterprise6) Aaron Shenck Executive Director, The Pennsylvania Association of Private SchoolAdministrators7) Doug Seelbach Mechanical Designer/3d Designer, Six Sigma/The UPS Store8) Allan G. Hancock CLU ChFC Chief Executive Officer and Chairman of the Board, TheHancock Group, Inc., and, Advisory Board Member, DuBois Business College9) Joshua K Renicker Chief Operating Officer, Energy Access, Inc.10) Mark Lunghofer Production Manager, Sensit Technologies LLC.11) Larry King Jr.12) Quirt Marlon Collins13) Jim Bare Registered Medical Assistant / Registered Phlebotomy Technician, JohnsonCity Community Health Clinic14) James Harsh Systems Support Technician, ITT Technical Institute/employee/graduate15) Xavier Ferguson Recruiting Coordinator, Labor Ready16) Kevin M. Gratz Talent Acquisition Specialist, SSM/Dean Clinic17) Bobbie Casteel Consultant Perkins Cybersecurity & Advisory Services18) Terrence Smith Architectural Designer, Aerotek19) Joshua Mann Consultant, Pathway Forensics, LLC20) Stefany Ward Billing and Project Coordinator, Global Linking Solutions21) Lovell Walls Office Systems Special, Konica Minolta22) Joseph Fernandez Member of the National technical Honors society23) Mendi Goble Executive Director, Richmond Chamber of Commerce24) Deanna Henley Burns McDonnell, Electrical Drafting Technician25) S. Paul Mazza, III President, South Hills School of Business & Technology26) Carrie Wofford President, Veterans Education Success27) Sara Nolan Collins Legal Services Director, Veterans Education Success28) Walter Ochinko Policy Director, Veterans Education Success12:00pm LUNCH1:00pm Renewal of Recognition Accrediting Commission of Career Schools and Colleges(ACCSC)NACIQI Primary Readers:Jill Derby, Ph.D.Cameron C. Staples, J.D.Department Staff:Chuck MulaAgency Representatives:Duane B. Kramer Chair of the Commission, ACCSC, UniversalTechnical InstituteMichale S. McComis, Ed.D. Executive Director/CEO, ACCSCChristopher D. Lambert Associate Executive Director, ACCSCKaren Marcinski Director of Member Services, ACCSC6

Third Party Oral Commenters:1) Juliet Mee Director, Professional Massage Training Center, Inc.2) Dalphna Curtis President, PCCenter3) Ki Kiraoso Owner/Director, Abdill Career College, Inc.2:45pm BREAK3:00pm Renewal of Recognition American Osteopathic Association, Commission onOsteopathic College AccreditationNACIQI Primary Readers:Simon J. BoehmeRichard F. O’DonnellDepartment Staff:Nicole Harris, Ed.D.Agency Representatives:Alissa Craft, DO, MBA Vice President, Accreditation, Commissionon Osteopathic College AccreditationJoshua Prober, JD General Counsel & Senior Vice President,American Osteopathic AssociationThomas Cavalieri, DO Commissioner, Commission onOsteopathic College Accreditation3:45pm BREAK4:00pm Renewal of Recognition Council on Occupational Education (COE)NACIQI Primary Readers:Arthur E. Keiser, Ph.D.Cameron C. Staples, J.D.Department Staff:Valerie LeforAgency Representatives:Gary Puckett President and Executive Director, COEAlfonzo Salazar Commission Chair and Administrator, Home Lifeand Community Services, Inc.Mr. Charles Johnson Commission Member and CommissionExecutive Committee Member, Excellence UnlimitedCynthia C. Sheldon Associate Executive Director – AgencyOperations, COEDerin P. Dickerson Partner, Alston and Bird, LLP5:30pm Closing Remarks7

Friday, June 24 Day 38:30am Welcome and IntroductionsSusan D. Phillips, Ph.D., NACIQI ChairpersonReview Procedures for Renewal Applications (with pilot project questions)Susan D. Phillips, Ph.D, NACIQI Chairperson Primary readers introduce agency application Department staff provides briefing Primary readers’ questions of the agency (standard questions as well as the first threesets of questions under the pilot project) Other questions by NACIQI followed by response and comment from agency Third-party comments Agency responds to third-party comments Department staff responds to agency and third-party comments Discussion and vote Final set of pilot project questions8:45am Renewal of Recognition Transnational Association of Christian Colleges andSchools, Accreditation Commission (TRACS)NACIQI Primary Readers:Paul J. LeBlanc, Ph.D.Arthur Rothkopf, J.D.Department Staff:Rachael Shultz, Ed.D.Agency Representatives:Timothy W. Eaton, Ph.D. TRACS President/CEOJames Flanagan, Ph.D. TRACS Accreditation Commission, Chair,Luther Rice College and Seminary, PresidentBenson M. Karanja, Ed.D. TRACS Accreditation Commission, ViceChair, Beulah Heights University, PresidentRon Cannon, D.Min. VP/COO, TRACS9:30am BREAKReview Procedures for Compliance Reports and Reviews under 34 CFR 602.33Susan D. Phillips, Ph.D., NACIQI Chairperson Primary readers introduce agency application Department staff provides briefing Agency representatives provide comments Third-party comments Agency responds to third-party comments Department staff responds to agency and third-party comments Discussion and vote8

9:45am Compliance Report American Veterinary Medical Association, Council on Education(AVMA)NACIQI Primary Readers:Roberta Derlin, Ph.D.Frank H. Wu, J.D.Department Staff:Nicole Harris, Ed.D.Agency Representatives:John Pascoe, BVSc, PhD, Diplomate ACVS Chair, AVMA Councilon EducationJohn Scamahorn, DVM Chair-elect AVMA Council on EducationKaren Martens Brandt, DVM Director, Education & Research,AVMA Council on EducationThird-Party Oral Commenters:1) Robert Marshak, DVM, DACVIM Professor Emeritus of Medicine and Dean Emeritus,University of Pennsylvania School of Veterinary Medicine2) Carl Darby, MA, VETMB Owner Seneca Falls Veterinary Hospital General practitioner inprivate practice, Board member VIN Foundation3) Sheila W. Allen DVM, MS Dean, College of Veterinary Medicine4) William D. Tyrrell, Jr., DVM, DACVIM-Cardiology Speaking as a practice owner andpractitioner5) William J. Kay, DVM6) Paul D. Pion, DVM, DACVIM (Cardiology) President and co-founder, VeterinaryInformation Network7) Jeffery B. Newman, DVM Veterinarian Owner and Practitioner, Caring Hands AnimalHospitals8) Frank E. Walker, DVM9) Arnold L. Goldman DVM, MPH Connecticut Veterinary Medical Foundation c/o CantonAnimal Hospital LLC10) Deborah T. Kochevar, DVM, PhD, DACVCP Dean and Henry and Lois Foster Professor,Cummings School of Veterinary Medicine at Tufts University11) Jerry Owens, DVM12) Seth Koch, VMD, DACVO Hickory Veterinary Hospital13) Eric Bregman, VMD14) Walter Robinson, DVM East North Veterinary Clinic15) Mark Johnson, DVM Owner, Pender Veterinary Center16) John N. Sexton, DVM Medical Director, Mclean Animal Hospital12:00pm LUNCH9

1:00pm Compliance Report Northwest Commission on Colleges and Universities (NWCCU)NACIQI Primary Readers:Paul J. LeBlanc, Ph.D.Cameron C. Staples, J.D.Department Staff:Nicole Harris, Ed.D.Agency Representatives:Sandra E. Elman President, NWCCUPamela Goad Vice President, NWCCUThomas R. Case Retired General, Chancellor, University of AlaskaAnchorage1:45pm BREAK2:00pm Review under 34 CFR 602.33 for Failure to Submit a Renewal Application under 34CFR 602.31(a) National Council for Accreditation of Teacher EducationReview under 34 CFR 602.33 for Failure to Submit a Renewal Application under 34 CFR602.31(a) Teacher Education Accreditation Council, Accreditation CommitteeNACIQI Primary Readers:Kathleen Sullivan Alioto, Ed.D.Richard F. O’DonnellDepartment Staff:Steve PorcelliAgency Representatives:2:45pm BREAK3:00pm NACIQI Policy Discussion5:30pm Adjourn10

1 U.S. Department of Education Office of Postsecondary Education NATIONAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON INSTITUTIONAL QUALITY