2012 Lead Management Optimization Study - Marketo

Transcription

2012 Lead Management Optimization – Key Trends Analysis2012 Lead ManagementOptimization StudyKey Trends AnalysisCompliments of:

2012 Lead Management Optimization – Key Trends AnalysisCopyright 2012 CSO InsightsAll Rights Reserved.Terms and ConditionsPrinted in the United States of America. Except as permitted under the United States Copyright Act of 1976,no part of this publication may be produced or distributed in any form or by any means, or stored in adatabase or retrieval system, without the prior written permission of the publisher. For additional information,contact CSO Insights, 4524 Northfield Court, Boulder, CO 80301, Phone: (303) 530-6930, e-mail:jim.dickie@csoinsights.com.The reader understands that the information and data used in preparation of this report were as accurate aspossible at the time of preparation by the publisher. The publisher assumes no responsibility to update theinformation or publication. The publisher assumes that the readers will use the information contained in thispublication for the purpose of informing themselves on the matters that form the subject of this publication. Itis sold with the understanding that neither the authors nor those individuals interviewed are engaged inrendering legal, accounting, or other professional service. If legal or other expert advice is required, theservices of a competent professional should be sought. The publisher assumes no responsibility for any useto which the purchaser puts this information.All views expressed in this report are those of the individuals interviewed and do not necessarily reflectthose of the companies or organizations they may be affiliated with, CSO Insights, Insight TechnologyGroup, or Sales Mastery. All trademarks are trademarks of their respective companies.

2012 Lead Management Optimization – Key Trends AnalysisTable of Contents2012 Lead Generation Optimization Study Introduction . 12012 Lead Generation Optimization Study Sales and Marketing Alignment . 2Top Strategic Marketing Objectives for 2012 . 52012 Marketing Budget Compared to 2011. 7Top Rated Lead Generation Programs . 9Customer and Prospect Data Accuracy Ratings . 11Ability to Deliver Highly Targeted/Relevant Messaging . 13Utilization of Lead Generation Management System . 15Lead Scoring Methods . 17Percentage of Leads Turned Over to Sales . 19Disposition of Non-sales Ready Leads. 21Metrics for Tracking Lead Generation ROI . 23Lead Management Optimization: Going Forward . 25

2012 Lead Management Optimization – Key Trends Analysis2012 Lead Management Optimization Study IntroductionFor the past eight years, CSO Insights has conducted our annual Lead ManagementOptimization (LMO) study focused on understanding how, and how effectively, marketing issupporting sales in their efforts to hit their revenue targets. As part of the 100 metrics wecollect each year, we acquire a detailed understanding of the challenges facing marketingteams, why those problems exist, and what some companies are doing to leverage people,process, technology, and knowledge to address those issues.We had over 400 firms participate in the 2012 Lead Management Optimization study.Professional services firms were the largest industry segment represented, followed bytechnology, manufacturing, advertising/media/PR/publishing, telecommunications, financialservices, distribution, and health care.In terms of geographic mix, 67.5% of the firms were based in the United States, and 32.5%were international companies.An analysis of the data by industry or company size is available to advisory services clients bycontacting their CSO Insights analyst. Anyone wishing to obtain these analyses or is interestedin benchmark information for their firm should email Laura Andrus. CSO Insights1No portion of this report may be reproduced or distributed in any form orby any means without the prior written permission of the authors.

2012 Lead Management Optimization – Key Trends Analysis2012 Lead Generation Optimization Sales and Marketing AlignmentMarketing has many different types of responsibilities, but for this study the one we are mostinterested in is how effectively they support sales in generating the right quality and quantity ofleads to fill the pipeline with legitimate sales opportunities. Our view has been that marketing isnot responsible for generating all the leads that sales reps need, as clearly some prospectingefforts need to be territory specific, but marketing should be creating a meaningful number ofquality leads.One of the first things we do when we gather the data from our annual Lead ManagementOptimization study is to compare certain responses we receive from marketing teams with theanswers we receive from our annual Sales Performance Optimization (SPO) study. Let us sharewith you a few metrics that show the level of alignment between these two functional groups.The first question we ask both sales and marketing professionals taking their respective studiesis: What percentage of all leads that sales pursue is generated by marketing? The percentagefigure from sales, as reported in 2012 Sales Performance Optimization study, was 27.1%, whilethe number reported by marketing in the 2012 Lead Management Optimization study wasnoticeably higher, at 36.9%. In analyzing the data from both studies, we found one factor thatmay explain the difference of opinions, and that is not all leads turned over to sales are activelyfollowed up, as shown in Figure 1.Percentage of Leads Turned Over to SalesActively Followed UpDo Not Know5.2% 25%9.4%25% - 50%10.8% 90%39.0%51% - 75%19.2%75% - 90%16.4%Figure 1Only 55% of the firms surveyed have a lead follow up rate of 75% or more.To help companies determine the true contribution of marketing’s lead generation efforts, theywill have to be able to track the disposition of all the leads that are turned over to sales. CSO Insights2No portion of this report may be reproduced or distributed in any form orby any means without the prior written permission of the authors.

2012 Lead Management Optimization – Key Trends AnalysisWe also looked at the ratings that marketing gave themselves in regards to how they thoughtsales graded their performance in three different areas. The first was the effectiveness of thecompany website to successfully engage prospects and customers. As shown below in Figure2, half of all the companies surveyed felt their web presence needed improvement. This was inline with the 53% figure reported from sales.Figure 2Marketing sees lots of room for improvement in meeting sales’ expectations.With regards to the assessment of the quantity and quality of leads, marketing was somewhatharder on themselves than sales. Above, we see 67% of marketing teams stated they needed toimprove lead quantity and 52% believed the same about lead quality. Sales’ ratings, whencompared with marketing’s, were 60% and 51%, respectively.In general, we believe that marketing and sales are fairly well aligned with “what” to do.However, the challenge, as presented in the Key Trends Analysis of this report, is around leadgeneration teams getting more effective at “how” to do deliver effective lead generationprograms. The study clearly shows that the number of options marketing can utilize to reachprospects and customers makes the task of selecting the right approaches and then effectivelyexecuting them much more complex than ever before.We trust the information presented in this analysis will help you more effectively optimize yourorganization’s lead generation efforts. While we believe the issues raised have broadapplicability, we encourage you to use this information only as the basis for brainstorming andgoal planning sessions for identifying and prioritizing your organization’s lead generationobjectives. Everyone can benefit from understanding the strategies and tactics other companiesare using, but in the end you must implement solutions that fit your specific business needs. CSO Insights3No portion of this report may be reproduced or distributed in any form orby any means without the prior written permission of the authors.

2012 Lead Management Optimization – Key Trends AnalysisAfter having had a chance to digest this analysis, research clients are encouraged to set up abriefing with their CSO Insights analyst to discuss the specific ways you can more effectivelyleverage people, process, technology, and knowledge to optimize your lead efforts.Anyone having questions or comments on the data presented in this report can be directed to:Jim DickieManaging PartnerCSO Insights(303) 521-4410jim.dickie@csoinsights.comBarry TrailerManaging PartnerCSO Insights(916) 712 9621barry.trailer@csoinsights.comFor a complete list of the survey questions, e-mail kim.cameron@csoinsights.com. CSO Insights4No portion of this report may be reproduced or distributed in any form orby any means without the prior written permission of the authors.

2012 Lead– KeyTrends2012ManagementLead ManagementOptimizationOptimization – KeyTrendsAnalysisAnalysisWhat are your organization’s top three strategic marketing objectives for 2012?Top Three Strategic Marketing Objectives for 201286.5%Increasing New Customer Acquisition47.1%Increasing Brand Awareness39.1%Optimizing Cross-selling and Up-sellingOptimizing New Product Introduction25.7%Improving Customer Loyalty24.2%Develop/Optimize Social Media Strategy20.2%Increasing Customer Renewals20.2%18.0%Enhancing the Customer Experience13.8%Migrating to a Customer-centric Strategy4.3%Other (please specify)0%20%40%60%80%100%Key FindingsCommentary Marketing’sobjectives alignwell with sales.After reflecting on the low lead generation ratings that sales gavemarketing, we were interested in how the goals of sales andmarketing aligned. Above is what marketing identified as their keyobjectives. Below is what sales focused on this year. (Reference:CSO Insights’ 2012 Sales Performance Optimization Study.) Disconnectseen betweenknowing whatmarketing wantsto do and theirability toexecute. Renewedinterest seen inbuilding brandawareness. CSO Insights5No portion of this report may be reproduced or distributed in any form orby any means without the prior written permission of the authors.

2012 Lead Management Optimization – Key Trends AnalysisWhen comparing the two sets of objectives, there are severalcommonalities, (e.g., focusing on new accounts, cross-selling andup-selling, improving customer loyalty, etc.). So the major issue isnot that the two functional areas are not on the same page, asthey are both very aware that the main objective is increasingrevenues.The issue between the two groups is marketing’s ability to executeon these goals. In this regard there are some major challenges.When we asked marketing to rate their effectiveness, they gavethemselves less than stellar marks as shown in the followingchart:One last item of note is marketing’s renewed interest in increasingbrand awareness. After the stock market tanked in 2008, thenumber of firms focusing on brand building dropped to the mid‘30s. Above, we see it has gained in importance, perhaps drivenby marketing’s new interest in social media.Notes: CSO Insights6No portion of this report may be reproduced or distributed in any form orby any means without the prior written permission of the authors.

2012 LeadManagementOptimization– KeyTrends2012Lead ManagementOptimization – KeyTrendsAnalysisAnalysisHow does your 2012 marketing budget compare to your budget in 2011?2012 Total Marketing Budget Compared to 20115% - 15% less5.7%0% - 5% less13.2% 15% less3.8% 25% more16.4%11% - 25% more16.7%1% - 10% more44.2%Key FindingsCommentary There are fewerfirms holdingback onmarketinginvestments.In 2009 we witnessed a significant pull back/freezing of marketingbudgets. That trend is now reversing itself as only 22.9% of thefirms surveyed said their 2012 budget was the same as or lessthan 2011. The chart below shows the areas that are gettingmore, the same as, or less of the funds available to invest. Web-basedmarketing isreceiving moreof the budget. Without budgetsto do “more,”lead generationteams mustfocus on“better.” CSO Insights7No portion of this report may be reproduced or distributed in any form orby any means without the prior written permission of the authors.

2012 Lead Management Optimization – Key Trends AnalysisInvestments in the company’s website are of major interest tomany firms participating in this study as supported by theirplanned increases for site design, content creation, and searchengine optimization. Social media continues to be an area inwhich companies are willing to invest additional funds; although,as seen on the next page, the effectiveness of these programsrate less than other lead generation initiatives.When looking at the changes in overall marketing budgets for2012, what struck many members on our advisory board was thefact that only one-third of the firms will have substantially moremoney to spend on marketing this year. Because of this, ouradvisory board’s view is that while marketing teams may not havethe resources to do substantially “more,” marketing teams shouldfocus on doing what they can do “better.”Notes: CSO Insights8No portion of this report may be reproduced or distributed in any form orby any means without the prior written permission of the authors.

2012 LeadManagementOptimization– KeyTrends2012Lead ManagementOptimization – KeyTrendsAnalysisAnalysisWhat three programs are producing the best quality/quantity of leads for your firm?Top Three Rated Lead Generation Programs59.2%Email Marketing47.2%Live Events/Tradeshows26.9%Web Site EO/Paid Search/Google Adwords21.0%Direct Mail18.8%Social Media17.2%Newsletters15.5%Blogs, Podcasts, MobileMarketing12.0%Other (please specify)7.1%Newspaper/Print Ads2.9%TV/Radio0%10%20%30%40%50%60%Key FindingsCommentary Even in the faceof fatigue, emailmarketingremains the toplead generator.How many of you start your day by opening your emailapplications and hit delete, delete, delete, delete without everopening any emails? With this being said, the chart above showsthat email is still rated as the most effective source of leadscompared to other lead generation options. Increase seenin thepercentage offirms leveraginglive events/tradeshows.But dark clouds are on the horizon. Various sources report anestimated 119 emails are sent to business professionals eachday, and 24% of those are thought to be spam―a number thatcontinues to increase. Marketers will have to find new ways to getprospects and customers to opt in to receiving information fromthem via email if this is going to remain an effective a leadgeneration mechanism as it has in the past few years. Social media isnot seen as areal leadgenerator.The number of firms reverting back to utilizing live events, (e.g.,seminars, trade shows, user group meetings, etc.) is once againon the rise. While web events are common, more firms see theneed to blend high-touch and high-tech and are choosing to havea balance of virtual and face-to-face events to build awareness,interest, and establish deeper relationships with customers andprospects. CSO Insights9No portion of this report may be reproduced or distributed in any form orby any means without the prior written permission of the authors.

2012 Lead Management Optimization – Key Trends AnalysisThe buzz factor around social media is still high, but what impactis it having on creating opportunities? Above, we see that socialmedia came in eighth on the list this year, being cited by only18.8% of the firms surveyed as one of their top three leadgenerators. This represents only a minimal improvement sincelast year.An insight into how companies view the value of social mediasurfaced as part of our 2012 Sales Performance OptimizationStudy. The chart below shows that many companies are still tryingto determine what role social media should play.As firms further refine the ways they utilize this customercommunication method and gather metrics of the impact it has onrevenue, they will be in a position to gauge whether it is anoverhyped method of marketing or a strategic way to createinterest that companies must master.Notes: CSO Insights10No portion of this report may be reproduced or distributed in any form orby any means without the prior written permission of the authors.

2012 LeadManagement Optimization – Key Trends Analysis2012 Lead Management Optimization – Key Trends AnalysisMorgan Creek's Quarterly Update Conference CallsWhat percentage of your customer/prospect data is current and correct?Customer and Prospect Data Accuracy Ratings: Using andNot Using Sales Intelligence 10%6%12%13%11%15%13%10% 10%10% 9%7%5%4%0% 25%25% - 50%51% - 75%76% - 90% 90%Customer Data Accuracy w/SICustomer Data Accuracy no SIProspect Data Accuracy w/SIProspect Data Accuracy no SIDo Not KnowKey FindingsCommentary Only modestincreases indata accuracywere seen thispast year.It is hard to generate interest if you don’t know who to target.Because of this, one area where we continue to see the need formajor improvements is marketing’s access to current/accuratedata on both their prospects and existing customers. Firms usingsalesintelligenceservices havebetter accuracythan those thatdo not. Many firms areplanning toinvest more indata quality.The 2012 study data showed that, on average, there wereimprovements in data ratings on a year-over-year basis. However,these ratings are not where they need to be in order for marketingto run effective lead generation campaigns.However, based on input from our advisory board, we conducteda segmentation analysis of the survey findings, and one item gotour attention. We asked in the study if marketing was usingexternal sales intelligence (SI) services. We found that 53.9% saidyes and 46.1% said no.Above are the data accuracy comparison ratings for firms usingand not using sales intelligence services. Sales intelligence canoffer value to marketing teams seeking to improve customer andprospect data quality and quantity. CSO Insights11No portion of this report may be reproduced or distributed in any form orby any means without the prior written permission of the authors.

2012 Lead Management Optimization – Key Trends AnalysisAs 44.7% of the firms are planning to invest more in datamanagement, making additional investments in sales intelligenceshould be considered.Study participants cited twenty-seven sales intelligence solutionsand the majority of firms using sales intelligence services haverelationships with more than one provider. This presents anotherway to validate data by comparing the information your firm hasgathered to other data sources to help identify changes soonerrather than later.Notes: CSO Insights12No portion of this report may be reproduced or distributed in any form orby any means without the prior written permission of the authors.

2012 LeadOptimization– KeyTrendsAnalysis2012 GenerationLead ManagementOptimization – KeyTrendsAnalysisHow would you rate your ability to deliver highly targeted/relevant messaging?Ability to Deliver Targeted/Relevant Messaging4

2012 Lead Management Optimization Study Introduction For the past eight years, CSO Insights has conducted our annual Lead Management Optimization (LMO) study focused on understanding how, and how effectively, marketing is supporting sales in their efforts to