WIXLIB

Introduction13I found myself in Army basic training at Fort Dix, New Jersey.When I finished my basic training, chances were high that I wouldbe shipped off to Vietnam. But instead of receiving orders forVietnam, I was assigned to the White House in Washington DC.To my amazement, I would be living in my own apartment andworking directly for the President of the United States.After obtaining a top-security clearance, I began my new assignment with the White House Communications Agency. Theagency was responsible for providing communications supportto the President and Vice President wherever they traveled orhappened to be. While many of my more technically-skilled colleagues traveled with the President and Vice-President around thecountry and abroad, my less technical supply job usually kept mebound to the DC area. In fact, during my entire two years with theWhite House Communications Agency, there was only one timethat I ever made an outside trip with the President. Forty yearsago, I was part of the White House advance team that preparedthe way for President Richard Nixon’s visit to his friend DeWittWallace of Reader’s Digest magazine.4The world is fond of saying that “there is a reason for everything” and that “what goes around comes around.” I don’t reallyknow what to say about that presidential visit I took to the heartof Reader’s Digest country so many years ago. But I rememberthe New York Hudson Valley hamlet that DeWitt Wallace andReader’s Digest called home like it was yesterday. What irony thatthe only trip I took on behalf of the President of the United Stateswas to the founder and Executive Director of Reader’s Digest. Andhow fitting that the same Readers Digest Association Inc. thatformerly published the writings and teachings of Robert Schuller’smentor Norman Vincent Peale has begun publishing the writingsand teachings of Rick Warren.5Rick Warren describes himself as a “change agent,”6 butthe more he appears to change things the more things seem toremain the same. Reader’s Digest successfully promoted NormanVincent Peale’s books and articles and kept Peale’s ministry in

14A “Wonderful” Deceptionthe world’s limelight for nearly four decades. What worked forPeale then will surely work for Rick Warren now.As I will later describe in this book, Norman Vincent Peale’sstrong New Age sympathies came to my attention after Deceivedon Purpose was published in 2004. Shortly thereafter, I wouldlearn of Peale’s New Age influence on Robert Schuller and itssubsequent impact on the Church Growth movement that includes Rick Warren today.However, before we look at some of the further New Ageimplications of the emerging Purpose Driven movement, let usfirst review some of the original New Age implications describedin Deceived on Purpose.

OneDeceived on PurposeA little leaven leaveneth the whole lump.—Galatians 5:9Iwas working as a hospice social worker on the California coastin the late summer of 2003 when I first read Rick Warren’s bookThe Purpose Driven Life. Having been formerly involved in theNew Age movement, I immediately recognized some serious NewAge implications to Warren’s Purpose Driven movement. Feelingcompelled to warn the church about the spiritual confusion thatcould result from some of his teachings, I resigned my hospice jobto write Deceived on Purpose: The New Age Implications of thePurpose Driven Church. The book was published in August of 2004.In Deceived on Purpose, while I did not describe Rick Warrenor his Purpose Driven Church as “New Age,” I did point outthe many New Age implications regarding his teachings and thedanger those teachings posed for the church.Because Saddleback apologists have misrepresented thesewarnings and because my concerns have grown significantlysince I wrote Deceived on Purpose, I have written this follow-upbook. To lay a proper foundation for A “Wonderful” Deception,I will briefly summarize some of the basic concerns I expressedin Deceived on Purpose. I will recap these in the remainder ofthis first chapter.15

16A “Wonderful” DeceptionTen Basic Concerns1) Rick Warren Cites New Age LeaderI n The Purpose Driven Life, Rick Warren introduces his mainthemes of “hope” and “purpose.” Inexplicably, Warren choosesto introduce “hope” and “purpose” in his book by citing Dr.Bernie Siegel—a veteran New Age leader who claims to have aspirit-guide named George.1 Somehow, readers of The PurposeDriven Life are expected to believe that God inspired Warren tointroduce the themes of hope and purpose by referencing the“wisdom” of Bernie Siegel, an author and leader in the NewAge movement. But the Bible warns that this kind of worldlywisdom is not from God and can confuse and stumble believers,and completely mislead unbelievers:This wisdom descendeth not from above, but isearthly, sensual, devilish. (James 3:15)Let us not therefore judge one another any more: butjudge this rather, that no man put a stumbling block oran occasion to fall in his brother’s way. (Romans 14:13)2) Rick Warren Sends Confusing NewAge Message: “God is in everything”O ut of the fifteen different Bible versions Rick Warren uses inThe Purpose Driven Life, he chooses to cite Ephesians 4:6 from anew translation that erroneously conveys the panentheistic NewAge teaching that God is “in” everything. According to NewAge leaders, this teaching is foundational to the New Age/NewSpirituality.2 Yet of these fifteen Bible versions Warren uses inhis book, he chooses the New Century Version that has potentially misled millions of Purpose Driven readers to believe thiskey New Age doctrine that God is “in” everything. RegardingGod, Warren writes:

Deceived on Purpose17The Bible says, “He rules everything and is everywhereand is in everything”3The New Century Version quoted by Rick Warren verbalizeswhat A Course in Miracles and my other New Age books taught meyears ago—that God is “in” everyone and everything. This completelymisrepresents what the apostle Paul is saying in Ephesians 4:6. InDeceived on Purpose, I explain:In this Scripture Paul is not writing to the world atlarge. The book of Ephesians is Paul’s letter to theChurch of Ephesus and to the faithful followers ofJesus Christ. In Ephesians 1:1 he makes it clear thathe is writing to “the saints which are at Ephesus, andto the faithful in Christ Jesus.”According to properly translated Scripture, God is not “in”everyone and everything, and God’s Holy Spirit only indwells thosewho truly accept Jesus Christ as their Lord and Savior (John 14:1517; Acts 5:32). In Deceived on Purpose, I wrote:Because the Church of Ephesus was composedof believers who had accepted Jesus as their Lordand Savior, God had sent His Holy Spirit to them.Therefore, as a result of their conversion God’sHoly Spirit resided in them all. Thus, Paul is onlyaddressing the believers of Ephesus and the “faithfulin Christ Jesus” when he stated that God is “aboveall, and through all, and in you all” (emphasisadded). He was not saying that God is present inunbelievers. He was not saying that God is “in”everyone and “in” everything. That is what theNew Age teaches.4It is vital to understand the difference in renderings of Ephesians 4:6. Compare the New Century Version that Rick Warrenquotes with the King James Bible:

18A “Wonderful” DeceptionHe rules everything and is everywhere and is ineverything. (NCV)One God and Father of all, who is above all, andthrough all, and in you all. (KJV)3) Rick Warren and The MessageI n The Purpose Driven Life, Rick Warren cites Eugene Peterson’sThe Message more than any other Bible version. The Message isladen with its own set of questionable New Age implications.In the first chapter of The Purpose Driven Life, five of the sixScriptures Warren cites come from The Message. Warren statesthat The Message is a Bible “paraphrase,” yet he frequently writes,“the Bible says” when quoting from The Message.5One of the many examples of the New Age implications ofThe Message is seen in Eugene Peterson’s paraphrasing of theLord’s Prayer. Where most translations read “in earth, as it is inheaven,” Peterson inserts the occult/New Age phrase “as above,so below.” The significance of this mystical occult saying is seenclearly in As Above, So Below, a book published in 1992 by the editors of New Age Journal. Chief editor Ronald S. Miller describeshow the occult/magical saying “as above, so below” conveys the“fundamental truth about the universe”—the teaching that “weare all one” because God is “immanent” or “within” everyoneand everything. Miller writes:Thousands of years ago in ancient Egypt, the greatmaster alchemist Hermes Trismegistus, believed tobe a contemporary of the Hebrew prophet Abraham,proclaimed this fundamental truth about theuniverse: “As above, so below; as below, so above.”This maxim implies that the transcendent Godbeyond the physical universe and the immanent Godwithin ourselves are one. Heaven and Earth, spirit

Deceived on Purpose19and matter, the invisible and the visible worlds forma unity to which we are intimately linked.6Miller continues describing the meaning of “as above, sobelow” by quoting Sufi scholar Reshad Field:“‘As above, so below’ means that the two worlds areinstantaneously seen to be one when we realize ouressential unity with God. . . . The One and the many,time and eternity, are all One.”7 (ellipsis in original)In 2004 when I searched “as above, so below” on the Internet,the first entry listed further defined this “key” New Age term:This phrase comes from the beginning of TheEmerald Tablet and embraces the entire system oftraditional and modern magic which was inscribedupon the tablet in cryptic wording by HermesTrismegistus. The significance of this phrase is that itis believed to hold the key to all mysteries. All systemsof magic are claimed to function by this formula.“‘That which is above is the same as that which isbelow’ . . . The universe is the same as God, God isthe same as man.”8Most of the references, either on websites or in books andmagazines containing the phrase “as above, so below” describethe term as having the same occult/mystical/New Age/esoteric/magical sources. One website states:This ancient phrase, “As above, so below”describes the Oneness of All That Is.9In Deceived on Purpose, I discuss my concerns over Rick Warrenplacing such great emphasis on Eugene Peterson’s The Message. WhenI looked up Ephesians 4:6 in The Message, Peterson’s paraphrase (like

20A “Wonderful” Deceptionthe New Century Version) also definitely lends itself to the New Ageinterpretation that God is present “in” everyone. In The Message,Peterson introduces his readers—with no parenthetical warnings orexplanations—to the concept of ‘Oneness’:You have one Master, one faith, one baptism, oneGod and Father of all, who rules over all, worksthrough all, and is present in all. Everything youare and think and do is permeated with Oneness.10The “as above, so below” God “in” everything “Oneness” message of Eugene Peterson’s paraphrase The Message sounds strikinglysimilar to the same “as above, so below” God “in” everything “Oneness” message of the New Age/New Spirituality. Such a teachingis contrary to what the Bible teaches. We are only “one” in ChristJesus when we repent of our sins and accept Him as our Lord andSavior. Galatians 3:26-28 states:For ye are all the children of God by faith in Christ Jesus.For as many of you as have been baptized into Christhave put on Christ. There is neither Jew nor Greek,there is neither bond nor free, there is neither male norfemale: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus. (emphasis added)4) The Purpose Driven Life’s DistortedView of Bible ProphecyIn The Purpose Driven Life, Rick Warren strongly discouragesthe study of prophecy. He states that “in essence” Jesus told hisdisciples: “The details of my return are none of your business.”11Contrary to what Warren writes, in Jesus’ discussion on theMount of Olives, He tells His disciples that an understandingof the details of His return is very important. He provides muchneeded prophetic information so that His followers will not be

Deceived on Purpose21deceived about the details of His return at the end of time. InDeceived on Purpose, I explain:He warns that there will be false teachers and falseteachings that will try to confuse the details of Hisreturn. He provides the prophetic detail because Hedidn’t want His disciples, or any of us, mistakingAntichrist’s arrival for His own return. He initiatesHis lengthy prophetic discourse by saying, “Take heedthat no man deceive you.” He ends His discussion bywarning them to “watch” and “be ready.”12As someone who has come out of New Age teachings, I findit very disturbing that Rick Warren writes that the details of Jesus’return are none of our business. In Deceived on Purpose, I talk aboutthe role that these details had in my own eventual conversion:Understanding the events surrounding His returnwas critical to understanding how badly I had beendeceived by my New Age teachings. I had learnedfrom reading the Bible that there is a false Christon the horizon and that for a number of years I hadunknowingly been one of his followers. Because theBible’s clear authoritative teachings about the realJesus and His true return had been brought to myattention, I was able to see how deceived I was. Byunderstanding that there is a false Christ trying tocounterfeit the true Christ’s return, I was able torenounce the false Christ I had been following andcommit my life to the true Jesus Christ.135) Rick Warren and John Marks TempletonRick Warren unwittingly lent himself to the “purposes” of NewAge sympathizer John Marks Templeton, as shown in Deceivedon Purpose:

22A “Wonderful” DeceptionEven as I write, [New Age leader] Neale DonaldWalsch’s New Age colleague Wayne Dyer isteaching the principles of the New Spiritualityto an unsuspecting American public on a 3-hourPBS television special. His subject? The power ofintention and purpose. While Dyer was cleverlypresenting the New Spirituality by talkingabout the power of “purpose,” Rick Warrenwas judging a “Power of Purpose” essay contestfor the New Age-based Templeton Foundation.John Templeton—with his strong New Age andmetaphysical leanings—believes in a “shareddivinity between God and humanity.”14I pointed out that the late Templeton had been featured onthe cover of Robert Schuller’s Possibilities magazine and was described as “my wonderful role model” by Neale Donald Walsch.6) Robert Schuller’s Influence on Rick WarrenIdiscovered that Rick Warren had been greatly influenced byRobert Schuller and that he frequently used unattributed material from Schuller’s writings. In promoting his 2004 Robert H.Schuller Institute for Successful Church Leadership, Schullerstated that Warren was a graduate of his Institute.15 Furthermore,on an April 4, 2004 Hour of Power television broadcast, Schullerdescribed how Warren had come to his Institute for SuccessfulChurch Leadership “time after time.”16 And Rick Warren’s wife,Kay, was quoted in a 2002 Christianity Today article saying thatSchuller “had a profound influence on Rick.”17In reading Schuller’s past writings, it soon became apparentthat Schuller had indeed greatly influenced Rick Warren’s ministry and that Warren often used Schuller’s material without anyattribution to Schuller.One of the many examples where Warren emulates Schuller’s material can be seen in the following comparison of theirwritings. In his 1982 book Self-Esteem: The New Reformation,

Deceived on Purpose23Robert Schuller writes:Our very survival “as a species depends on hope. Andwithout hope we will lose the fait

A “wonderful” deception : the further new age implications of the emerging purpose driven movement / Warren Smith. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references. ISBN 978-0-9824881-0-2 (softbound : alk. paper) 1. Christianity and other religions--New Age movement. 2. Warren, Richard, 1954- P