AS-3298-17/EX Violation Of Confidentiality Of CSU San .

Transcription

ACADEMIC SENATEOFTHE CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITYAS-3298-17/EXMay 18-19, 2017VIOLATION OF CONFIDENTIALITY OF CSU SAN BERNARDINO (CSUSB)PRESIDENTIAL SEARCH PROCESS AND CENSURE OF TRUSTEE EMERITUS LOUMONVILLE AND MR. PAUL GRANILLORESOLVED: That the Academic Senate of the California State University (ASCSU) expressgrave concern about the violation of confidentiality of the CSUSB presidentialsearch process by Trustee Emeritus and former Chair of the CSU Board ofTrustees Lou Monville, and community member Paul Granillo in a May 8, 2017op-ed about the CSUSB Academic Senate and its vote of no confidence inPresident Tomás Morales; and be it furtherRESOLVED: That the ASCSU endorse ASCSU Chair Christine Miller’s May 9, 2017 letter tothe CSUSB Faculty Senate expressing concern about the violation ofconfidentiality and the characterization of academic senates in the Granillo andMonville op-ed; and be it furtherRESOLVED: That the ASCSU censure Trustee Emeritus Monville and Mr. Granillo forviolating the confidentiality of the presidential search process by publiclydisclosing confidential committee deliberations and the identity of a finalist; andbe it furtherRESOLVED: That the ASCSU revoke AS-3255-16/FGA, its Commendation in Honor of TrusteeEmeritus Lou Monville; and be it furtherRESOLVED: That the ASCSU call upon the Board of Trustees to rescind the honorarydoctorate scheduled to be conferred upon Trustee Emeritus Monville; and be itfurtherRESOLVED: That the ASCSU also call upon the Board of Trustees to refrain from appointingeither Trustee Emeritus Monville or Mr. Granillo to future CSU searchcommittees; and be it furtherRESOLVED: That the ASCSU distribute this resolution to Trustee Emeritus Lou Monville, Mr.Paul Granillo, Board of Trustees, CSU Chancellor, CSU campus Senate Chairs,CSU San Bernardino Academic Senate, San Bernardino Sun, and the PressEnterpriseRATIONALE: On Tuesday, May 9, 2017 the CSU San Bernardino FacultySenate passed a “Resolution of No Confidence in the President of California StateUniversity, San Bernardino.” On May 8, Trustee Emeritus and former Chair ofthe Board of Trustees Lou Monville and Paul Granillo, a community member,published an op-ed piece against the resolution entitled “Academic Senates Need

Academic Senate CSUPage 2 of 2AS-3298-17/EXMay 18-19, 2017More Transparency” ates-need-more-transparency-guest-commentary). Monville and Granillo areboth graduates of CSUSB and both were members of the presidential searchcommittee that resulted in the hiring of CSUSB President Morales. In that piece,Monville and Granillo break the confidentiality of the presidential search processby publicly disclosing confidential committee deliberations and the identity of afinalist. The breach of confidentiality is an egregious violation of the veryprinciples the Chancellor and Board of Trustees have used to justify confidentialor closed presidential searches, and calls into question the continued use of thatmechanism to produce the best qualified candidates for a campus presidency.Moreover, the tone of the op-ed shows a complete lack of respect for academicsenates and a misunderstanding of the principles of collegial shared governance.Sources Resolution of No Confidence in the President of California State University,San Bernardino http://senate.csusb.edu/Resolutions/(FSD1617)VNC signed.pdf Paul Granillo and Lou Monville, Academic Senates Need More Transparency:Guest Commentary, San Bernardino Sun, May 8, -senates-need-moretransparency-guest-commentary Letter from Academic Senate CSU Chair Chris Miller to “My SenateColleagues at CSU San Bernardino,” May 9, 2017 (attached) “Alumni and Community Leader Lou Monville to receive honorary doctorate,”News Release, CSUSB Office of Strategic Communication, February 7, 2017 ate/Approved – May 18-19, 2017

Attachment 1 to AS-3298-17/EX

Alumnus and community leader Lou Monville to receive honorary doctorate – CSUSB News5/17/17, 3(07 PMAttachment 2 to AS-3298-17/EXQuick LinksTOP STORYMember of CSUSB’s ‘Written by Veterans’ program to discuss his newly published novel inRedlands -written-by-veterans" (http://www.facebook.com/CSUSB)# (http://www.twitter.com/CSUSBNews/) % (http://news.csusb.edu/feed/)Public transportation fertile territory for hate messages, CSUSB professor -professor-says/)New wide-format printer installed at CSUSB Printing Services is faster, less expensive tooperate ter-less-expensive-to-operate/)CSUSB hosts 6th annual Meeting of the Minds student research osts-6th-annual-meeting-of-the-minds-student-CSUSB News y Awareness Fair returns to CSUSB for the second eness-fair-returns-to-csusb-for-the-second-TOP STORIES NEWS CLIPS (HTTP://NEWS.CSUSB.EDU/CATEGORY/NEWSCLIPS/)NEWS RELEASES B professor comments on law enforcement’s sometimes difficult decision onwhether an incident is a hate crime cision-on-whether-an-incident-is-aHome (http://news.csusb.edu/) / Alumni (http://news.csusb.edu/category/alumni/)/ News Releases (http://news.csusb.edu/category/newsreleases/) / Alumnus and communityhate-crime/)leader Lou Monville to receive honorary doctorate6th annual Armed Forces Day celebration to be held at CSUSB May -may-17/)SearchNews media rely on CSUSB criminal justice faculty as resourcesRECENT /)Member of CSUSB’s ‘Written by Veterans’ program toCal State San Bernardino singled out for scholarship programdiscuss his newly published novel in ypublished-novel-in-redlands/)CSUSB Ed.D. candidate Quinton Bemiller discusses his advocacy for the arts in theInland Empire date-quinton-bemillerPublic transportation fertile territory for hate e-inland-empire/)CSUSB professor -professor-Alumnus and community leader Lou Monville to receivehonorary doctorateALUMNI (HTTP://NEWS.CSUSB.EDU/CATEGORY/ALUMNI/), NEWS ES/) February 27, 2017, by Office of Strategic! 0 Comment tion ate/#respond)Like 8TweetShareShare2says/)New wide-format printer installed at CSUSB PrintingServices is faster, less expensive to -is-faster-lessexpensive-to-operate/)CSUSB hosts 6th annual Meeting of the Minds studentresearch symposiumCalifornia State University, San Bernardino will award alumnus Lou Monville, who had served on the CSU Board of sts-6th-for 10 years culminating with two terms as the board chair, an honorary doctorate in humane letters during the research-commencement exercises on June 17.symposium/)Monville, who served as president of the CSUSB Associated Students Inc. as an undergraduate, and graduated with aAbility Awareness Fair returns to CSUSB for the secondbachelor’s degree in communication, will be honored at the university’s College of Arts and Letters graduation exercises.year topPage 1 of 4

Alumnus and community leader Lou Monville to receive honorary doctorate – CSUSB News5/17/17, 3(07 PMAttachment 2 to AS-3298-17/EX“I am humbled, there is no greater honor one can receive than an honorary doctorate from your alma mater,” Monville said.ARCHIVES“So much in our life has been shaped by the remarkable experiences Elizabeth and I had as students at CSUSB; I don’t havethe words to describe how grateful we are for all the opportunities CSUSB gave me and my family.”May 2017 (http://news.csusb.edu/2017/05/)CSUSB President Tomás D. Morales praised Monville for his outstanding volunteer work to the university.April 2017 (http://news.csusb.edu/2017/04/)“We are very proud of Lou for his remarkable service to Cal State San Bernardino and the CSU,” Morales said. “His hardwork and dedication to the community personifies the volunteer spirit that we value and instill in our students and alumni as akey to overall success. I can’t think of a more deserving person to receive an honorary doctorate.”After graduation, Monville continued to serve Cal State San Bernardino by participating the Coyote Athletics Association; theCSUSB Alumni Association board, including serving as president; the Ambassadors for Higher Education; the CSUSBPhilanthropic Foundation Board of Directors; and the CSUSB Advisory Board. He currently serves on the CSUSB President’sAdvancement Council and Communications Studies Department Advisory Board.Monville is the senior vice president of the Raincross Corporate Group, a collection of business entities involved in real estatedevelopment, strategic business advisory services, convention center management, operations and catering, and conventionand sports sales and marketing.Monville has more than 20 years’ public affairs and public relations experience. Formerly he was vice president of OPRMarch 2017 (http://news.csusb.edu/2017/03/)February 2017 (http://news.csusb.edu/2017/02/)January 2017 (http://news.csusb.edu/2017/01/)December 2016 (http://news.csusb.edu/2016/12/)November 2016 (http://news.csusb.edu/2016/11/)October 2016 (http://news.csusb.edu/2016/10/)September 2016 (http://news.csusb.edu/2016/09/)Communications, where he led a team that specialized in land-use entitlement, infrastructure project development, publiceducation and community outreach, governmental affairs, and strategic counsel.August 2016 (http://news.csusb.edu/2016/08/)Previously, Monville served in Gov. Pete Wilson’s administration, directing the activities of the governor’s Inland EmpireJuly 2016 (http://news.csusb.edu/2016/07/)office. In that position, Monville advised the administration on public policy impacts relating to business and economic reform,class-size reduction and infrastructure development. Monville has extensive experience in California politics, includingJune 2016 (http://news.csusb.edu/2016/06/)providing strategic counsel to statewide initiatives, grassroots organizations, and presidential races. He also worked for twomembers of the California State Assembly.May 2016 (http://news.csusb.edu/2016/05/)Before entering the political and policy arena, Monville worked in the sports industry, where he served as the public relationsApril 2016 (http://news.csusb.edu/2016/04/)coordinator for the Riverside Pilots minor league baseball team and conducted marketing and promotions for CoyoteAthletics at Cal State San Bernardino.March 2016 (http://news.csusb.edu/2016/03/)He was named the “2009 Small Business Advocate of the Year” by the California Chamber of Commerce in recognition of hisFebruary 2016 (http://news.csusb.edu/2016/02/)passionate volunteerism for the betterment of local and state communities and economies. In 1999, the Inland EmpireBusiness Journal named him one of the region’s top 40 business leaders under 40 years of age.December 2015 (http://news.csusb.edu/2015/12/)In 2004, Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger appointed Monville, who was just 33 at the time, to the California Community CollegeNovember 2015 (http://news.csusb.edu/2015/11/)Board of Governors. Two years later the governor appointed Monville to the CSU Board of Trustees, in recognition of hisdedication to developing the state’s future workforce.October 2015 (http://news.csusb.edu/2015/10/)When his eight-year term to the board was scheduled to end in 2014, Monville was appointed to another full term on theboard by Gov. Jerry Brown. But in recognition of his growing young family, he ultimately accepted a two-year term of servicefrom the CSU Alumni Council. Monville capped his 10 years of CSU board service by serving as board chair from 2014 to2016.During Monville’s service, the board led the CSU through its most challenging budget crisis precipitated by the GreatRecession. At the same time, it selected a new system chancellor and 27 campus presidents; it approved three new doctoraldegrees and added or modified 1,200 degree programs, graduated nearly 984,000 graduates, saw a graduation rateincrease of 19 percent; all while focusing the system on greater value to the state and students, and achieving greatereducational equity for all groups.In addition to serving on the CSU Board of Trustees, Monville has previously served many community organizations,including the Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce, where he served as chair; and on the boards of the CaliforniaInland Empire Council Boy Scouts of America, and Inland Action, which seeks to improve the Inland Empire’s economy.« Previous ArticleNext Article »(http://news.csusb.edu/2017/02/27/csusb- ation-night-2/)CSUSB athletics news, Feb. 25Coyotes basketball teams host(http://news.csusb.edu/2017/02/27/csusbFaculty Appreciation /2017/02/27/coyotes-alumni (http://news.csusb.edu/tag/alumni/)ASI nville-to-receive-honorary-doctorate/#topPage 2 of 4

Alumnus and community leader Lou Monville to receive honorary doctorate – CSUSB News5/17/17, 3(07 PMAttachment 2 to AS-3298-17/EXAssociated Students Inc. /)Board of Trustees fornia State University sity/)Citizens Business Bank Arena arena/)College of Arts and Letters ters/)commencement tion studies community (http://news.csusb.edu/tag/community/)CSU (http://news.csusb.edu/tag/csu/)graduation (http://news.csusb.edu/tag/graduation/)honorary doctorate (http://news.csusb.edu/tag/honorary-doctorate/)Lou Monville (http://news.csusb.edu/tag/lou-monville/)Tomás D. Morales es (http://news.csusb.edu/tag/trustees/)LEAVE A COMMENTYour comment (required):Name (required):Email (required):WebsitePost opSearchPage 3 of 4

Alumnus and community leader Lou Monville to receive honorary doctorate – CSUSB News5/17/17, 3(07 PMAttachment 2 to AS-3298-17/EXOffice of Strategic Communication ion)5500 University ParkwaySan Bernardino, CA 92407-2393(909) 537-5007 news@csusb.edu (mailto:news@csusb.edu)Disability Resources he California State University System (http://www.calstate.edu/)Privacy and Security Notice urity-notice)Disclosure of Consumer Information octorate/#topPage 4 of 4

Academic senates need more transparency: Guest le?avis LG&date 20170.Attachment 3 to AS-3298-17/EXSan Bernardino County Sun (http://www.sbsun.com)Academic senates need more transparency: Guest commentaryBy Paul Granillo and Lou MonvilleMonday, May 8, 2017We urge passage of Assembly Bill 847, authored byAssemblyman Raul Bocanegra, D-San Fernando, that wouldrequire academic senates at campuses of California StateUniversity and California Community Colleges to publish thenames of their members and their demographic makeup on apublic website, as most other publicly funded entities arerequired to do. The bill would request the same of theindependent University of California campuses.For too long some academic senates and their executivecommittees, who are vested with great authority, have been ableto hide in the shadows — using authority and intimidation to impose their will, creating a campus climatewhere innovation and best practices are actively pushed aside in favor of the status quo, protecting powerand influence for the few.In our opinion perhaps the worst example of this behavior is the current Academic Senate ExecutiveCommittee at our alma mater, Cal State San Bernardino.Six years ago, we served on the presidential search committee, along with two current CSUSB AcademicSenate Executive Committee members, that chose President Tomas Morales. They made it clear then thatPresident Morales was not “their” candidate and have used the shadowy world of the Academic senate towork against him before he ever came to campus and ever since. What is even more troubling is theAcademic Senate “candidate” for campus president at the time was the former CSUSB provost, who alsonow serves on the Academic Senate Executive Committee.The recent call for a vote of no confidence in President Morales is nothing more than tilting at windmills.Don Quixote himself would hang his head in shame.It is our opinion the CSUSB Academic Senate Executive Committee has waged an open war on civilityand innovation on campus. Any effort to increase faculty accountability, enhance student success or tomodernize and improve campus operations is met with relentless opposition. Faculty who speak in favorof counter ideas are quietly pulled aside and told their tenure or promotion is at risk if they don’t fall inline, and yes, the Academic Senate does largely control the promotion and tenure of their own. Evenworse, student government leaders, who serve on the Academic Senate, report they are routinely bulliedand harassed at Academic Senate meetings. Is this the example we want for the next generation ofleaders?1 of 25/17/17 2:43 PM

Academic senates need more transparency: Guest le?avis LG&date 20170.Such examples demonstrate why passage of AB847 is needed. Freedom of thought and expressionwithout intimidation should be the hallmark of higher education, but until academic senates are open andtransparent, this is a mark we will continue to miss.Academic senates play a vital function and when run honorably and openly are beacons for studentprogress and success. They need to

ACADEMIC SENATE OF THE CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY AS-3298-17/EX May 18-19, 2017 VIOLATION OF CONFIDENTIALITY OF CSU SAN BERNARDINO (CSUSB) PRESIDENTIAL SEARCH PROCESS AND CENSURE OF TRUSTEE EMERITUS LOU MONVILLE AND MR.PAUL GRANILLO RESOLVED: That the Academic Senate of the California State University (ASCSU) express grave concern about the vio