Advances In Crowdfunding Research And Practice - OAPEN

Transcription

Edited byRotem ShneorLiang ZhaoBjørn-Tore FlåtenAdvances inCrowdfundingResearch and Practice

Advances in Crowdfunding

Rotem Shneor Liang ZhaoBjørn-Tore FlåtenEditorsAdvancesin CrowdfundingResearch and Practice

EditorsRotem ShneorSchool of Business and LawUniversity of AgderKristiansand, NorwayLiang ZhaoSchool of Business and LawUniversity of AgderKristiansand, NorwayBjørn-Tore FlåtenSchool of Business and LawUniversity of AgderKristiansand, NorwayISBN 978-3-030-46308-3    ISBN 978-3-030-46309-0 (eBook)https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-46309-0 The Editor(s) (if applicable) and The Author(s) 2020. This book is an open access publication.Open Access This book is licensed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits use, sharing,adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriatecredit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence andindicate if changes were made.The images or other third party material in this book are included in the book’s Creative Commonslicence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the book’sCreative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds thepermitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder.The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc. in this publicationdoes not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevantprotective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use.The publisher, the authors and the editors are safe to assume that the advice and information in this bookare believed to be true and accurate at the date of publication. Neither the publisher nor the authors orthe editors give a warranty, expressed or implied, with respect to the material contained herein or for anyerrors or omissions that may have been made. The publisher remains neutral with regard to jurisdictionalclaims in published maps and institutional affiliations.This Palgrave Macmillan imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature Switzerland AG.The registered company address is: Gewerbestrasse 11, 6330 Cham, Switzerland

In loving memory of Prof. Andreas Wyller Falkenberg, an inspirationalfriend, colleague, and mentor.

AcknowledgementsThe authors are grateful for the support of the University of Agder’sLibrary grant for Open Access Publications, as well as the management ofthe University of Agder’s School of Business and Law for their unequivocal and generous support in making this book project a reality.vii

Contents1 Introduction: From Fundamentals to Advances inCrowdfunding Research and Practice   1Rotem Shneor, Liang Zhao, and Bjørn-Tore FlåtenPart I  The Current State of Crowdfunding   192 Crowdfunding Models, Strategies, and Choices BetweenThem  21Rotem Shneor3 The Global Status of the Crowdfunding Industry  43Tania Ziegler, Rotem Shneor, and Bryan Zheng Zhang4 Lending Crowdfunding: Principles and MarketDevelopment  63Tania Ziegler and Rotem Shneorix

xContents5 Equity Crowdfunding: Principles and Investor Behaviour  93Anna Lukkarinen6 Reward-Based Crowdfunding Research and Practice 119Liang Zhao and Sunghan Ryu7 Donation Crowdfunding: Principles and Donor Behaviour 145Liang Zhao and Rotem Shneor8 Ethical Considerations in Crowdfunding 161Rotem Shneor and Stina Torjesen9 Legal Institutions, Social Capital, and FinancialCrowdfunding: A Multilevel Perspective 183Wanxiang Cai, Friedemann Polzin, and Erik StamPart II  Crowdfunding in Historical Context  20710 History of Crowdfunding in the Context ofEver-Changing Modern Financial Markets 209Aki Kallio and Lasse Vuola11 The FinTech Industry: Crowdfunding in Context 241Paul GriffithsPart III  Crowdfunding in Geographic Context  27112 Crowdfunding in China: Turmoil of Global Leadership 273Liang Zhao and Yuanqing Li

Contentsxi13 Crowdfunding Prospects in New Emerging Markets: TheCases of India and Bangladesh 297Krishnamurthy Suresh, Stine Øyna, and Ziaul Haque Munim14 Crowdfunding in Africa: Opportunities and Challenges 319Emmanuel James Chao, Priscilla Serwaah, Prince Baah-Peprah,and Rotem Shneor15 Israeli Crowdfunding: A Reflection of Its EntrepreneurialCulture 341Kalanit Efrat, Shaked Gilboa, and Daniel Berliner16 Crowdfunding in Europe: Between Fragmentation andHarmonization 373Karsten Wenzlaff, Ana Odorović, Tania Ziegler, andRotem ShneorPart IV  Crowdfunding in Sectoral Context  39117 Crowdfunding Sustainability 393Natalia Maehle, Pia Piroschka Otte, and Natalia Drozdova18 Crowdfunding in the Cultural Industries 423Anders Rykkja, Natalia Maehle, Ziaul Haque Munim, andRotem Shneor19 Civic Crowdfunding: Four Perspectives on the Definitionof Civic Crowdfunding 441Karsten Wenzlaff

xiiContentsPart V  The Future of Crowdfunding  47320 Crowdfunding Education: Objectives, Content, Pedagogy,and Assessment 475Rotem Shneor and Bjørn-Tore Flåten21 The Future of Crowdfunding Research and Practice 499Rotem Shneor, Bjørn-Tore Flåten, and Liang ZhaoIndex  521

Notes on ContributorsPrince Baah-Peprah is a doctoral research fellow at the University ofAgder’s (UiA) School of Business and Law and a member of theCrowdfunding Research Centre at UiA. He holds a master’s degree inInternational Management from UiA. His research interests lie in marketing strategies in crowdfunding while examining regional and contextual heterogeneities. He currently focuses on how the involvement ofexperts in the development stage of crowdfunding campaigns reducesrisk and enhance project success. Based on his background in management, accounting and finance, he has previously researched entrepreneurial financing and private equity investment in emerging markets.Daniel Berliner is a doctoral research fellow at the CrowdfundingResearch Centre at the University of Agder, Norway. His research interests include investor decisions, crowdfunding and alternative financing,especially in the context of high-technology new ventures. His PhDresearch focuses on entrepreneurship and alternative financing models.Previous to his PhD studies, he acquired extensive experience workingwith various high-technology Israeli ventures in the field of branding andstrategy.Wanxiang Cai is a doctoral research fellow at Utrecht University Schoolof Economics (U.S.E.). He holds an MSc in Business Administrationxiii

xivNotes on Contributorsfrom Chongqing University (CQU), School of Economics and BusinessAdministration. In his research Wanxiang analyses to what extent andhow social capital and formal institutions affect individual crowdfundingcampaigns, transaction volumes on platforms and the development ofthe financial crowdfunding market. Wanxiang is also affiliated with theEuropean Centre for Alternative Finance. His work has been presented atleading conferences in the field of entrepreneurial finance.Emmanuel James Chao is currently a senior lecturer and a head ofresource and incubation centre at Mzumbe University-Tanzania. Further,he is the founder and chair of the annual International Conference ofBusiness and Management in Emerging Markets (ICBMEM) and anassociate researcher at the Centre for Crowdfunding Research at theUniversity of Agder. He holds a PhD in International Management andMSc in International Business from the University of Agder in Norway.He has published in a wide variety of international outlets such asInternational Business Research, Journal of Global Marketing, Journal ofBusiness to Business Relations, Journal of Knowledge Management andPractice among others.Natalia Drozdova is a doctoral research fellow at NHH, NorwegianSchool of Economics, where she earlier graduated with a master’s degreein International Business. Natalia’s research interests include crowdfunding, sharing economy, collaborative consumption and online movements.Kalanit Efrat is Senior Lecturer of International Business, Marketingand Entrepreneurship at the Ruppin Academic Centre, Israel. Herresearch interests include international small and medium enterprises(SMEs), collaborative strategies, information and knowledge-based capabilities and crowdfunding. Her articles were published in the Journal ofWorld Business, Technovation, International Marketing Review, InternationalBusiness Review and Journal of Business Research among others.Bjørn-Tore Flåten is an associate professor at the University of AgderSchool of Business and Law. He holds a PhD in International Managementfrom UiA and an MSc from the Norwegian School of Economics. Hisresearch interests revolve around strategic management of knowledgework and entrepreneurship, with focus on knowledge sharing and

Notes on Contributorsxvinternet- enabled collaboration within and beyond the boundaries of thefirm. Flåten has contributed with book chapters to research-focusededited books, as well as published in journals such as Information andOrganization, Journal of e-Business and the Norwegian Journal of Geography.Currently, Flåten is serving as the head of Department of Managementand as the Vice Dean of the School of Business and Law. Flåten is alsoheading the university’s Centre for Entrepreneurship. Through the centre, Flåten has also launched UiA Innovation, whose objective is commercialization of research from faculty and students.Shaked Gilboa is a Senior Lecturer of Customer Experience,Organizational Development and Human Resource Management at theRuppin Academic Centre, Israel. Her research interests include customerexperience among mall shoppers, small businesses’ customers, city residents and crowdfunding’s creators and backers. Her articles were published in the European Journal of Marketing, Journal of Retailing andConsumer Services, Cities and International Business Review among others.Paul Griffiths is the academic director of postgrads in Banking andFintech at the EM Normandie Business School. Prior to becoming a full- time academic, Paul spent many years in leadership positions at globalmanagement consulting firms, serving boards of blue-chip companies,particularly in the financial services sector. He specializes in managementof intangible assets such as intellectual capital and related technologiessuch as artificial intelligence and Fintech. Having lived and worked inmultiple countries, he defines himself as multicultural. Paul brings to hislectures the hands-on experience of having started up from scratch consulting firms in eight countries. His interests in research bridge across thefields of Fintech and knowledge management and the development ofknowledge networks, particularly in banking. He holds a master’s degreein engineering, has been a Humphrey Fellow (Fulbright Commission) atthe University of Minnesota and holds a doctorate in business administration. He is a prolific writer in professional and academic publicationsand a renowned speaker at conferences and seminars.Aki Kallio holds LLM degree from the University of Helsinki and currently serves as the Managing Compliance Officer (Corporates &

xviNotes on ContributorsInstitutions, C&I) at the Danske Bank A/S Finland Branch. Kallio is amember of Extended Group Compliance, C&I Compliance and C&IFinland Management Teams. Previously Kallio worked as a MinisterialAdviser in the Financial Markets Department of the Ministry of Financeof Finland (being responsible, among others, for drafting and enteringinto force the Finnish Crowdfunding Act and acting as a co-head of theFinancial Market Department’s Fintech—expert group). In addition, heacted as a Finnish representative of the European Commission’s informalexpert group—“European Crowdfunding Stakeholder Forum (ECSF)”.He is also a co-author of first published book on crowdfunding and fintech in Finland (in Finnish: Joukkorahoitus, ). Prior to joining the Ministryof Finance of Finland he worked for two leading Finnish law firms and asa corporate counsel.Yuanqing Li is Assistant Professor of Entrepreneurship at DominicanUniversity. She graduated with a Doctor of Philosophy in BusinessAdministration (Entrepreneurship Focus) from the University of TexasRio Grande Valley (UTRGV). Her undergraduate degree in EnglishEducation (Henan Normal University, 2010) and master’s degrees inboth Teaching Chinese to Speakers of Other Languages (Minzu Universityof China, 2012) and Management (MBA UTRGV, 2015) have preparedher to teach and conduct research in diverse interests (including entrepreneurship especially in crowdfunding, cross-cultural communication andorganizational behaviour).Anna Lukkarinen is a postdoctoral researcher at Aalto UniversitySchool of Science in Finland. Her research interests lie in equity crowdfunding, entrepreneurial finance and new ventures. She currently focuseson developing an improved understanding of investor behaviour anddecision making in equity crowdfunding, which she does in close collaboration with crowdfunding practitioners. With work background inmanagement consulting at McKinsey & Company and investment banking at Citigroup, she strongly believes in the mutual benefit potential offostering linkages between academia and the industry.Natalia Maehle is an associate professor at the Western NorwayUniversity of Applied Sciences, Mohn Centre for Innovation and

Notes on ContributorsxviiRegional Development. She holds a PhD from NHH, Norwegian Schoolof Economics. Maehle’s research interests include digital business models,innovation, consumer behaviour and branding. She is currently leading aNorwegian part of the international research project supported by theHorizon 2020 ERA-net Cofund SUSFOOD2. Maehle also leads severalwork packages in an international research project on crowdfunding. Shehas an excellent track record of publications in the highly ranked international peer-reviewed journals.Ziaul Haque Munim is Associate Professor of Maritime Logistics at theUniversity of South-Eastern Norway. His research interests include maritime economics and logistics, supply chain management and international business. He holds a PhD in International Management from theUniversity of Agder and an MSc in Supply Chain Management from theVienna University of Economics and Business. His publications haveappeared in leading journals such as the Journal of Business Research, AsiaPacific Journal of Management, Resources, Conservation & Recycling andothers. He received the Best Paper Award at the IAME 2016 conferenceand the Young Researcher Best Paper Award at the IAME 2018 conference.Ana Odorović is a PhD research fellow in the Graduate School in Lawand Economics at the University of Hamburg in Germany. Her thesisdeals with the question of overcoming asymmetric information in thecrowdfunding market from a law and economics perspective. She is alsoa research affiliate at the Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance. In2018, she was a visiting researcher at the University of Oxford. She holdsan LLM degree in business law from the Panthéon-Assas University (Paris2) and a master’s degree in economics from the University of Belgrade,where she also teaches economics at the Law school.Pia Piroschka Otte is a senior researcher at Ruralis, Institute for Ruraland Regional Research. In addition, she works as a researcher at NTNUSustainability within the climate change cluster. Pia has an interdisciplinary background with a PhD in Political Science and a master’s degree inDevelopment Studies from NTNU. Her work focuses on social scienceresearch addressing energy transitions, climate change and rural/urbandevelopment. She is currently leading an international research project

xviiiNotes on Contributorsthat tests the feasibility of offsetting CO2 emissions from transportthrough crowdfunding of climate-friendly technologies on local farms.Stine Øyna is an associate professor at The School of Business and Law,University of Agder, Norway. She holds a PhD in International Businessfrom the same university. Her research interests lie in the intersectionbetween international business and entrepreneurship, with a currentfocus on born globals, internationalizing SMEs and entrepreneurshipeducation. She has publications in journals such as International BusinessReview and International Studies of Management and Organization. Shereceived the Lazaridis Institute SMEs & International EntrepreneurshipBest Paper Prize at the EIBA 2018 conference.Friedemann Polzin is an assistant professor at Utrecht UniversitySchool of Economics (U.S.E.), Sustainable Finance Lab (SFL) andEuropean Centre for Alternative Finance (ECAF). He holds a PhD fromEBS Business School and an MSc in Business Administration from theUniversity of Jena. Friedemann investigates the financing of innovationand entrepreneurship as well as corresponding sources such as banking,venture capital or crowdfunding. Another part of his research looks at thepolicy environment required for a transition towards a green economy.His work has been published in major innovation, entrepreneurship andsustainability journals.Anders Rykkja is a doctoral research fellow at the Inland NorwayUniversity of Applied Sciences. He holds an MA in Music BusinessManagement from the University of Westminster. Anders currentlyworks on his doctoral thesis, which is on the emergence, adoption andusage of cultural crowdfunding as a supplemental financing mechanismin the cultural and creative industries. Over the last few years as a teammember of Knowledge Works, the Norwegian knowledge centre for thecultural and creative industries, he has published reports on a variety oftopics, including music industry export, festivals and cultural policyintervention schemes.Sunghan Ryu is an assistant professor in USC-SJTU Institute ofCultural and Creative Industry at Shanghai Jiao Tong University. Heholds a PhD in IT management from the College of Business, KAIST. His

Notes on Contributorsxixresearch interests include IT innovations in cultural and creative domainsand effective information systems applications in the entrepreneurialcontext. His current research interests revolve around crowdfunding andother alternative finance practices. His works appeared in academic journals including Journal of Strategic Information Systems, Electronic Marketsand Electronic Commerce Research & Applications and were presented atprestigious conferences such as ICIS and HICSS.Priscilla Serwaah is a doctoral research fellow at the School of Businessand Law, University of Agder. She previously worked as a teaching assistant at the Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology(KNUST), Ghana. During her master’s at the University of Agder, sheworked as a consultant for Mechatronics Innovation Laboratory (MIL),located in Grimstad. Her research focuses on entrepreneurial/alternativefinance and gender dynamics in crowdfunding.Rotem Shneor is an associate professor at the University of Agder’sSchool of Business and Law and serves as the academic director of theuniversity’s Centre of Entrepreneurship, as well as the founder and headof the university’s Crowdfunding Research Centre. He holds a PhD inInternational Management from UiA and a master’s degree from theNorwegian School of Economics (NHH). He established the NordicCrowdfunding Alliance of platforms, co-founded and currently serves onthe board of the Norwegian Crowdfunding Association. In addition, heis serving as an affiliate researcher at the Cambridge University Centre forAlternative Finance and is a co-author to its annual reports. His researchcovers crowdfunding success, behaviour and motivations, internet marketing and cognitive aspects of entrepreneurship. He has a record of fifteen years in teaching, researching and supporting entrepreneurship. Hehas published in academic journals (including JBR, ERD, IJOEM, CCM,BJM, JPBM, EEP, and JPM), trade magazines, as well as contributedseveral chapters to research-focused edited books and textbooks.Erik Stam is Professor of Strategy, Organization & Entrepreneurship atUtrecht University School of Economics (U.S.E.). He holds a PhD andMSc from Utrecht University. His research lies in the intersection of economics, geography and government policy and is one of the world’s lead-

xxNotes on Contributorsing scholars in entrepreneurship. Erik has co-authored more than 50academic articles, edited and contributed to numerous books. He is affiliated with several universities around the global and he also regularly consults governments and entrepreneurship organizations.Krishnamurthy Suresh is an academic associate at the Indian Instituteof Management (IIM), Bangalore, India. He is also a research associate atthe Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance (CCAF), University ofCambridge Judge Business School. He has authored three alternativefinance industry reports with CCAF. His research interests lie in the areasof small and medium enterprise (SME) financing, crowdfunding, newand alternative financing models for start-ups and SMEs, as well as regulatory frameworks. He is currently pursuing his PhD from India and wasa visiting fellow (Pavate) at the University of Cambridge Judge BusinessSchool (CJBS).Stina Torjesen is an associate professor at the University of Agder’sSchool of Business and Law, where she teaches courses in Business Ethics.Stina holds an MPhil and DPhil in International Relations from theUniversity of Oxford. She served previously as a senior research fellow atthe Norwegian Institute of International Affairs and worked for theUnited Nations in Kazakhstan. She has also worked as a project managerin the sustainability consultancy SIGLA. Her publications include contributions to edited books volumes and articles in academic journals (e.g.IJSD, CSD, CAS, etc.).Lasse Vuola holds LLM from the University of Lapland and California,Berkeley, and MSc from the University of Jyväskylä. He is serving asCEO and co-founder of the Finnish loan-based crowdfunding platformFundu Ltd, which employs approximately 20 people in Finland. He isalso a co-author of the first published book on crowdfunding and fintechin Finland (in Finnish: Joukkorahoitus). Vuola has also worked as a lawyerfor many years in Finland’s largest business law firm, most recentlyemployed by a law firm Castrén & Snellman Oy. In addition, he hasinvested in several start-up companies and implemented many cooperation projects with start-up and growth companies, providing him withcomprehensive understanding of practical corporate financebottlenecks.

Notes on ContributorsxxiKarsten Wenzlaff is a PhD research fellow and lecturer in Crowdfundingand Alternative Finance in the Chair for Digital Markets at the Universityof Hamburg in Germany. He is the co-author of the Alternative FinanceBenchmarking Report of the Centre for Alternative Finance at theUniversity of Cambridge and a research affiliate in the European Centrefor Alternative Finance at the University of Utrecht. His research focus isalternative finance, corporate crowdfunding and civic crowdfunding,self-regulation of FinTechs and Fintech ecosystems. Karsten has been anexpert to the Committee on the Digital Agenda of the German Parliament.Bryan Zheng Zhang is the co-founder and executive director of theCambridge Centre for Alternative Finance at the Judge Business School,University of Cambridge. His research examines the accumulation andallocation of capital for start-ups and SMEs through alternative circuitsof finance in a geographical and comparative context. Since 2013, Bryanhas led and co-authored some of the most influential industry reports onthe state of alternative finance both at national and international levels.He has advised and collaborated with numerous institutions and organizations including the Financial Conduct Authority, the British BusinessBank, the Department of International Development, the EuropeanCommission, the World Bank, Oxfam and Unilever. He is also a researchfellow in Finance at Cambridge Judge Business School and a senior fellow at the Financial Innovation Lab. Bryan was trained in economicgeography and public policy at Cambridge and Oxford Universities.Liang Zhao is a postdoc research fellow at the University of Agder’sSchool of Business and Law. He is also a research fellow in China’s PublicSector Economy Research Centre (CPSERC) and China-IsraelEntrepreneurship and Innovation Centre (CIEIC) at Jilin University inChina. In addition, he was an affiliate researcher at the CambridgeUniversity Centre for Alternative Finance. Dr. Liang studies innovationand entrepreneurship, with a special emphasis on reward-based crowdfunding. His research interests include the interactive mechanism ofcrowdfunding platforms, backers and entrepreneurs; e-trust and backerbehaviour; crowdfunding community formation and marketing ofcrowdfunding campaigns. His research output includes journal articles,book chapters and industry reports. Besides, He also writes popular arti-

xxiiNotes on Contributorscles for global FinTech web media such as Crowdfund Insider andTechfoliance. He received his PhD from Amsterdam Business School atthe University of Amsterdam in the Netherlands and his cum laude bachelor and master’s degrees from Jilin University in China.Tania Ziegler is the lead in Global Benchmarking at the CambridgeCentre for Alternative Finance (CCAF) and manages the centre’s alternative finance benchmarking programme which spans Europe, the Americas,Asia Pacific and the Middle East and Africa. She has authored more thana dozen industry reports since joining the CCAF. She is an expert in SMEfinance and leads the Centre’s work on SME Access to Finance in LatinAmerica. She holds an MSc from the London School of Economics (LSE)and a BA from Loyola College in Maryland. Tania is a 2010 FulbrightScholar and has spent a period at the International University of Businessand Economics in Beijing, China.

List of FiguresFig. 1.1Fig. 1.2Fig. 2.1Fig. 2.2Fig. 2.3Fig. 3.1Fig. 3.2Fig. 3.3Fig. 3.4Fig. 3.5Fig. 4.1Fig. 4.2Win-win dynamics in crowdfunding The crowdfunding campaign process Generic organizational fundraiser model choice framework Extended organizational fundraiser model choice framework Consumer fundraiser model choice framework Global volumes 2013–2017 (USD) Global volumes by top models 2017 (USD) Total 2017 volumes by region (million USD).(Source: Ziegler et al. 2020) Crowdfunding per capita volumes by GDP percapita 2017—Lead markets Regional volumes—Europe, Asia-Pacific, and Latin America& the Caribbean (USD). (Source: Ziegler et al. 2020) Traditional P2P lending model. (Source: Bank for InternationalSettlements and Financial Stability Board (2017). Marketstructure, business models and financial stability implicationsBank for International Settlements. The full publication isavailable on the BIS website free of charge: www.bis.org) Balance sheet lending model. (Source: Bank for InternationalSettlements and Financial Stability Board (2017). Marketstructure, business models and financial stability implicationsBank for International Settlements. The full publication isavailable on the BIS website free of charge: www.bis.org) 3632333345464750556970xxiii

xxivList of FiguresFig. 4.3Fig. 4.4Fig. 4.5Proportion of global volume from key crowdlending models 73Sources of UK SME finance 2012–2018 (in billion GBP) 77Institutional vs. retail investors in crowdlending (globally)in 2018 83Equity crowdfunding volumes (million EUR). (Source:Based on figures reported in Garvey et al. 2017; Zhang et al.2018; Ziegler et al. 2018a, b, c, d, 2019) 94Typical equity crowdfunding process under the all-or-nothing model. (Source: Modified from Lukkarinen et al. 2016) 95The four-dimension framework of reward-basedcrowdfunding 122Interactions between financial crowdfunding and institutionsat macro and micro levels 192Interactions between financial crowdfunding and institutionsat macro, meso, and micro levels 199Timeline—Brief history of crowdfunding 224The effect of the 2007–2008 crisis 251The effect of major technological breakthroughs on FinTechand banks 254Effects of social changes on banks and FinTech 255Evolution of the relationship between banks and FinTechs 263Indian crowdfunding market volumes by model(2013–2017). ( Based on figures from Ziegler et al. [2018]) 301Market volume by country for 2015 (in million). (Source:Based on figure from Ziegler et al. 2018a, b) 357Market volume per capita by country for 2016 (in million). (Source: Based on figures from Ziegler et al. 2018a, b;World Bank Data for Israel 2019) 357Headstart (rewards and donations campaigns) fundingvolumes 2012–2018 (in million). (Source: Based on datareceived from the company) 363Headstart (rewards and donations campaigns) success rates2012–2018. (Source: Based on data received from thecompany) 363Alternative finance volume per capita versus GDP per capita2017. (Source: Ziegler et al. 2019) 377Cross-border flows in European crowdfunding markets2017. (Source: Ziegler et al. 2019) 380Fig. 5.1Fig. 5.2Fig. 6.1Fig. 9.1Fig. 9.2Fig. 10.1Fig. 11.1Fig. 11.2Fig. 11.3Fig. 11.4Fig. 13.1Fig. 15.1Fig. 15.2Fig. 15.3Fig. 15.4Fig. 16.1Fig. 16.2

List of TablesTable 2.1Table 2.2Table 3.1Table 3.2Table 4.1Table 4.2Table 4.3Table 5.1Table 8.1Table 8.2Table 8.3Table 8.4Table 11.1Table 11.2Table 13.1Table 13.2Table 13.3An extended CCAF global crowdfunding typology 24Main crowdfunding model characteristics 29Top thirty national markets by volume in 2017 49Top crowdfunding models by region 56Global alternative lending in USD billion (inclusive ofChina figures) 73Global alternative lending in USD billion (exclusive ofChina figures) 74Crowdlending models 2018 by model and region (in USDbillion) 75Comparison of different forms of early-stage equityfinancing 104Ethical pitfalls for platforms 170Ethical pitf

Agder's (UiA) School of Business and Law and a member of the Crowdfunding Research Centre at UiA. He holds a master's degree in International Management from UiA. . 2012) and Management (MBA UTRGV, 2015) have prepared her to teach and conduct research in diverse interests (including entrepre - neurship especially in crowdfunding, cross .