Minority Business

Transcription

2019MINORITY BUSINESSPARTICIPATION REPORTAN AGENCY OF THES TAT E O F T E X A SFor The Fiscal Year EndingAugust 31, 2019

March 26, 2020The Honorable Greg AbbottThe Honorable Dan PatrickThe Honorable Dennis BonnenMembers of the 86th LegislatureLadies and Gentlemen:In accordance with the Texas Government Code, §466.107, the Texas Lottery Commission issubmitting its annual Minority Business Participation Report for fiscal year (FY) 2019.During FY 2019, the agency achieved an overall participation of 17.66% in its minority/HistoricallyUnderutilized Business (HUB) contracting activity, which represented a decrease of three percentagepoints from FY 2018’s performance of 20.69%. In addition, the agency continued to surpass its 20%goal for minority retailers.During FY 2020, the Texas Lottery will continue to implement initiatives designed to increase theminority/HUB participation in its business operations.If you have any questions regarding the report, please do not hesitate to contact our ExecutiveDirector, Gary Grief.Sincerely,J. Winston KrauseChairman

TABL E OF CON TE N TSI N T RODUC T ION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1BAC KGROU N D . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2E X EC U T I V E SU M M A RY. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4K EY CON T R AC TOR S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6FISCA L Y E A R 2 019 H IGH L IGH TS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7FISCA L Y E A R 2 019 M I NOR I T Y/H U B E X PEN DI T U R E SU M M A RY . 8FISCA L Y E A R 2 019 ACCOM PL ISH M EN TS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9FISCA L Y E A R 2 02 0 R ECOM M EN DED I M PROV E M EN TS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13A PPEN DIC E S. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .15

TEXAS LOTTERY CO M M I SSI O NMINORITY BUSINESSPARTICIPATION REPORTFISCAL YEAR 2019INT ROD U C T IONThe Texas Lottery Commission (TLC) has prepared itsannual Minority Business Participation Report for FY2019 in accordance with Section 466.107 of the StateLottery Act. This report documents the agency’s levelof minority business participation both in its lotteryand bingo contracting activity, and in the licensingof lottery retailers. It also provides recommendationsfor the improvement of lottery-related minoritybusiness opportunities.As defined by the State Lottery Act, a “minoritybusiness” is a “business entity at least 51% ofwhich is owned by minority group members or,in the case of a corporation, at least 51% of theshares of which are owned by minority groupmembers.” Minority group members includeAfrican Americans, American Indians,Asian Americans, Mexican Americansand other Americans of Hispanic origin.Throughout this report, the terms “minorityowned business” and “minority business”are used interchangeably.The Texas Lottery Commission’s HUB Programadopts by reference the rules administered bythe Office of the Comptroller of Public Accountsregarding historically underutilized businesses,which are set forth in the Texas Administrative Code,Title 34, Part 1, Chapter 20, §§20.281 – 20.298. Inaddition to the minority group members noted above,the Comptroller’s definition also includes businessesowned by women and service-disabled veterans.Although it is not specifically addressed by the StateLottery Act, the TLC also has a strong commitmentto including minorities in its business operations bymaintaining a diverse workforce. Information aboutthis area is included in Appendix D of the report(page 26).M I N O R I T Y B U S I N E S S PA RT I C I PAT I O N R E P O RT F Y 2 0 1 91

B A C K G R OUNDTex as L ot tery Commission VisionTo be the preeminent Lottery and Charitable Bingo agency through innovative leadership.Tex as L ot tery MissionThe Texas Lottery is committed to generating revenue for the state of Texas through the responsiblemanagement and sale of entertaining lottery products. The Texas Lottery will incorporate the higheststandard of security, integrity and responsible gaming principles, set and achieve challenging goals,provide quality customer service and utilize a TEAM approach.Charitable Bingo MissionProvide authorized organizations the opportunity to raise funds for their charitable purposesby conducting bingo. Determine that all charitable bingo funds are used for a lawful purpose.Promote and maintain the integrity of the charitable bingo industry throughout Texas.Core ValuesThe Texas Lottery Commission combines private business management principles with public servicestandards of conduct in all its operations. The following values guide us in our work: Integrity and Responsibility Innovation Fiscal Accountability Customer Responsiveness Teamwork ExcellenceMinorit y/ HUB CommitmentThe Texas Lottery Commission is committed to assisting and including minority-owned businessesand Historically Underutilized Businesses (HUBs) in its procurement opportunities. In accordancewith the provisions of the State Lottery Act and the state’s HUB rules, the agency and its contractorsmake a good faith effort to contract and subcontract with minority-owned businesses for the purchaseof goods and services for the operation of the agency.Minorit y/ HUB Pro gr amThe TLC’s Minority/HUB Program functions as part of the agency’s Administration Division.The agency’s HUB Coordinator is responsible for advising and assisting the TLC in complyingwith the requirements of the State Lottery Act and the state’s HUB rules. The agency’s Minority/HUB Program operates in three key areas to promote the inclusion and utilization of minority-ownedbusinesses and HUBs: outreach activities, contract compliance and reporting.2T E X A S L O T T E RY C O M M I S S I O N

Outreach ActivitiesOutreach activities make up one of the most important components of the TLC’s Minority/HUBProgram. The purpose of these activities is to inform minority/HUB vendors about opportunitiesto provide goods and services to the agency and its contractors. Outreach is performed primarily byparticipating in business opportunity forums and other events throughout the state. The TLC HUBCoordinator may also assist in planning and cosponsoring statewide events in cooperation withother state agencies. In addition, the agency conducts an annual HUB Forum to inform minority/HUB vendors about TLC procurement processes and to provide networking opportunities. Achart listing the outreach events in which the agency participated during FY 2019 is available inAppendix C (page 25).Other types of outreach activities include providing information to prospective vendors via the TLCwebsite, coordinating meetings with individual minority/HUB vendors, administering the agency’sMentor-Protégé Program, and assisting eligible businesses with obtaining state HUB certification.Contract ComplianceThe TLC’s HUB Coordinator, Purchasing and Contracts staff, and administering divisions workcollaboratively to maintain vendor compliance with contract terms relating to minority andHUB participation. The first step in this process involves assisting the agency with making HUBsubcontracting determinations for contracts with an expected value of 100,000 or more prior toreleasing solicitations. Pre-bid and pre-proposal conferences are held to highlight the TLC’s HUBpolicy and subcontracting plan requirements. The HUB Coordinator also assists evaluation teamsby reviewing HUB Subcontracting Plans submitted with bids/proposals to determine whethergood faith effort criteria were met. Finally, the agency’s subcontracting plans are monitored forcompliance following contract award.ReportingThe TLC’s minority/HUB expenditures are monitoredthroughout the year. Monthly internal minority/HUBparticipation reports are distributed to agency directors,and periodic updates are provided to TLC commissioners.In addition, HUB sub-contracting expenditures andsupplemental information are reported twice annuallyto the Comptroller of Public Accounts (CPA) forinclusion in the Statewide HUB Reports. HUBparticipation information is included inthe agency’s Strategic Plan, LegislativeAppropriations Request, and AnnualReport of Non-Financial DataM I N O R I T Y B U S I N E S S PA RT I C I PAT I O N R E P O RT F Y 2 0 1 93

E x e c u t i ve SummaryDuring FY 2019, the TLC continued its efforts toprovide opportunities for minority-owned businessesto participate in its procurement processes. Developingcontacts with minority-owned businesses in Texasand licensing minority retailers are essential to theagency’s initiatives.The TLC’s overall expenditures, as captured by theCPA’s Fiscal Year 2019 Texas Historically UnderutilizedBusiness (HUB) Annual Report, increased from FY2018 to FY 2019. During this reporting period, theCommission ranked 17th by overall expenditures amongthe 50 largest-spending agencies, as compared withranking 20th during FY 2018.FIG. 1MINORITY/HUB SPENDING(IN MILLIONS) 50 38.6 40(20.69%) 34.6(17.66%) 30 26.3(14.21%) 25 20FIG. 2MINORITY SPENDING* 15 40 10 36,872,478 Direct Spending 35 32,421,871 Subcontracting Spending 5 Total Spending 30 25 26,132,291 28,831,224 0 20 15 0FY 2017FY 2018 6,289,580 8,041,254 12,616,008 1,970,863 5FY 2019*Amounts have been rounded to the nearest dollar.4T E X A S L O T T E RY C O M M I S S I O NFY 2018FY 2019During FY 2019, the TLC achieved an overallparticipation rate in its minority/HUB contractingactivity of 17.66%. As shown in Figure 1, totalexpenditures paid to all minority/HUB vendorsdecreased from the previous fiscal year. The TLC’soverall minority/HUB percentage also decreased. 14,586,873 10FY 2017Figure 2 summarizes payments made to minorityowned businesses only (not including non-minoritywomen or service-disabled veterans). During thisreporting period, direct expenditures to minorityowned businesses decreased and subcontractingpayments decreased. Figure 3 shows the breakdownof FY 2019 minority/HUB spending by ethnic group.

FIG. 3MINORITY/HUB SPENDING BY ETHNICITY 5,179,498Black American (2.64%) 26,915,255Hispanic (13.73%) 325,842Asian (0.17%) 1,276Native American (0%) 2,205,919Non-Minority Women (1.12%) 0Service-Disabled Veterans (0%) 0 5 10During FY 2019, the TLC continued to exceed the20% goal for its minority retailer base which is setout in Texas Government Code, §466.151. Minorityretailers now number 8,103, representing 44.39%of the agency’s total Texas Lottery retailer base (seeFigures 4 and 5). More detailed information onminority retailers by county is located in AppendixB (page 18). In addition, the TLC has maintained aminority retailer percentage of more than 40% for13 consecutive years.10,0009,0008,0007,8497,769(43.27%) 20 35 30 25432 (34.45%)Austin649 (42.06%)Dallas North676 (46.75%)Dallas South99 (21.95%)El Paso459 (33.68%)683 (52.46%)Houston East8,103(44.39%)Houston North930 (68.84%)Houston South1,020 (70.44%)Houston West7,000Lubbock6,000McAllen5,000San Antonio4,000Tyler959 (67.35%)190 (14.88%)482 (37.72%)659 (40.33%)470 (35.15%)395 (34.50%)Waco3,00002,000 40FIG. 5MINORITY RETAILERSBY DISTRICTFort WorthFIG. 4NUMBER OFMINORITY RETAILERS(43.98%) 152505007501,0001,2501,0000FY 2017FY 2018FY 2019M I N O R I T Y B U S I N E S S PA RT I C I PAT I O N R E P O RT F Y 2 0 1 95

K E Y C O NTRACTORSThe Commission’s key contractors during FY 2019 for contracts estimated to be 100,000 or more* includedthe following:Agencies of Change, LLC dba Technology Spa – Website Hosting ServicesAlliant Insurance Services, Inc. – Retailer Bonus Payment Management ServicesBarker & Herbert Analytical Laboratories, Inc. – Lottery Products Testing ServicesBeehive Specialty Co.** – Promotional ProductsBerry Dunn McNeil & Parker, LLC – Security Study ServicesDell Marketing, LP – SAN Equipment LeaseDK Partners, P.C. (fka Davila, Buschhorn and Associates, P.C.)** – Lottery Drawings CPA ServicesElephant Productions, Inc. – Drawing Studio and Production ServicesElsym Consulting, Inc. – Internal Control System and Related ServicesEubank and Young Statistical Consulting – Statistical Consulting ServicesGrant Thornton, LLP – Risk Review and Compliance Monitoring ServicesIGT Global Solutions Corporation dba IGT Solutions (fka GTECH Corporation ) – LotteryOperations and ServicesIGT Global Solutions Corporation dba IGT Solutions (fka GTECH Printing Corporation) –Instant Ticket Manufacturing and ServicesJohnson Controls Security Solutions (fka Tyco Integrated Security, LLC) – SecurityManagement System and Monitoring ServicesKampfe De Stijl, Inc. – Professional Architect ServicesKnight Security Systems, LLC – Surveillance Camera Products and ServicesKowert, Hood, Munyon, Rankin and Goetzel, P.C. – Outside Counsel Intellectual Property Legal ServicesLatinWorks Marketing, LLC dba Thirdear** – Advertising ServicesMcConnell and Jones, LLP** – Internal Audit ServicesNetsync Network Solutions – Hyper Converged Infrastructure with Server LeasePollard Banknote, Ltd. – Instant Ticket Manufacturing and ServicesRFD & Associates, Inc.** – IT Staffing Augmentation ServicesScientific Games International, Inc. – Instant Ticket Manufacturing and ServicesSHI Government Solutions** – Desktop Computer LeaseSHI Government Solutions** – Microsoft Software Enterprise AgreementSmith Protective Services, Inc. – Security Officer ServicesSoftware One, Inc. – Microsoft Software Enterprise AgreementWeaver and Tidwell, LLP – Annual Financial Audit ServicesWeaver and Tidwell, LLP – Lottery Drawings CPA ServicesXerox Business Solutions Southwest (fka Dahill) – Document Management Services*List does not include interagency contracts, property leases or licensed property contracts.**HUB certified contractors6T E X A S L O T T E RY C O M M I S S I O N

F i s c a l Ye ar 2019 Highlights The Texas Lottery Commission’s minority/HUB expenditures in FY 2019 totaled more than 34 million. For FY 2019, the TLC ranked 17th among the 50 largest spending agencies in terms of overallexpenditures as captured by the CPA’s Fiscal Year 2019 Texas Historically Underutilized Business(HUB) Annual Report. Of the top 17, the TLC ranked sixth by overall HUB percentage (seeTable C, page 12). In FY 2019, the agency paid certified HUBs approximately 191,135 for goods and services inexpenditure categories not included in the CPA’s HUB Report. Two of the TLC’s key contractors increased subcontracting payments to minority/HUBbusinesses. Six HUB companies provided key contract services to the agency during FY 2019 (see page 6). The TLC awarded 23,745 in bid opportunities at the “Doing Business Texas Style Spot BidFair” held in conjunction with ACCESS 2019 in Irving, Texas. The TLC sponsored one mentor-protégé relationships during FY 2019. The TLC continued to assist vendors with the HUB subcontracting plan (HSP) processby offering one-on-one HSP workshops and reviews of draft HSPs. These efforts resulted ingreater numbers of compliant HSPs and increased competition. The TLC participated in five economic opportunity forumsand HUB-related outreach events statewide. The TLC conducted a successful annual HUB forumon May 15, 2019 which attracted minority/HUBparticipants from across the state. Roundtablenetworking sessions at this event allowedmaximum interaction between attendees,agency staff and key TLC contractors. The TLC participated in HUB DiscussionWorkgroup meetings that were held duringthe fiscal year. The TLC maintained a minority retailerpercentage of more than 40% for the 13thconsecutive year. This represents a lotteryretailer participation of more than twicethe established goal.M I N O R I T Y B U S I N E S S PA RT I C I PAT I O N R E P O RT F Y 2 0 1 97

FISCAL YEAR 2019 MINORITY/HUB EXPENDITURE SUMMARYTABLE AI. DIRECT MINORITY/HUB EXPENDITURESMINORITY/HUB GROUPDIRECT EXPENDITURES% OF TOTALAFRICAN AMERICAN 226,3060.12%HISPANIC AMERICAN 25,589,71213.04%ASIAN AMERICAN 319,4440.16%NATIVE AMERICAN 1,2760.00% 1,287,9920.66% 00.00% 27,424,73213.98%AMERICAN WOMENSERVICE DISABLED VETERANSTOTALTOTAL EXPENDITURES 196,101,001II. MINORITY/HUB SUBCONTRACTING EXPENDITURESSUBCONTRACTINGEXPENDITURES% OF NON-MINORITYNON-HUB TOTALAFRICAN AMERICAN 4,953,1912.96%HISPANIC AMERICAN 1,325,5420.79%ASIAN AMERICAN 10,8470.01%NATIVE AMERICAN 00.00% 922,0210.55% 00.00% 7,211,6034.31%MINORITY/HUB GROUPAMERICAN WOMENSERVICE DISABLED VETERANSTOTALTOTAL NON-MINORITY/NON-HUB EXPENDITURES 168,684,813III. GRAND TOTAL OF MINORITY/HUB EXPENDITURESMINORITY/HUBEXPENDITURES% OF TOTALAFRICAN AMERICAN 5,179,4982.64%HISPANIC AMERICAN 26,915,25513.73%ASIAN AMERICAN 325,8420.17%NATIVE AMERICAN 1,2760.00% 2,205,9191.12% 00.00% 34,627,79217.66%MINORITY/HUB GROUPAMERICAN WOMENSERVICE DISABLED VETERANSTOTALTOTAL EXPENDITURES 196,101,001NOTE: Fiscal Year expenditures were based on the reportable expenditure object codes utilized by the Comptroller of Public Accounts (CPA)for the State of Texas HUB Report. Totals may not sum exactly to CPA report due to rounding.8T E X A S L O T T E RY C O M M I S S I O N

FISCAL YEAR 2019 ACCOMPLISHMENTSThe Texas Lottery Commission promotes fair and competitive opportunities for minority/HUB vendors interested in doing business with the agency and its key contractors. The TLCconducted an effective program during FY 2019 to inform and educate minority businesses/HUBs about opportunities to provide supplies, equipment, and services for the operation of theagency and to serve as licensed lottery retailers. The following sections detail some of the TLC’sachievements in FY 2019.Inclusion in Pro curementsThe TLC’s procurement-related initiatives included: Participating in forums and other outreach events to inform minority/HUB vendors aboutthe TLC’s contracting and subcontracting opportunities. Hosting an annual HUB forum to present procurement-related information to minority/HUB vendors and provide networking opportunities. Determining the probability of subcontracting and identifying potential minority/HUBsubcontracting opportunities for contracts with an expected value of 100,000 or more. Providing vendor support by offering one-on-one HUB subcontracting plan (HSP)workshops and reviews of draft HSPs. Evaluating good-faith-effort compliance with HSP requirements as part of the bid/proposalprocess. C onducting post-contract award follow-up with awardedvendors to discuss HSP requirements; monitoring contractsto ensure compliance. Providing procurement opportunities at HUBforums and other outreach events. Hosting meetings with interested vendors toassist them in becoming familiar with theTLC’s procurement processes. A ssisting eligible vendors to becomecertified as HUBs.M I N O R I T Y B U S I N E S S PA RT I C I PAT I O N R E P O RT F Y 2 0 1 99

FISCAL YEAR 2019 ACCOMPLISHMENTSBids/Proposals Received and Contracts Awarded:During FY 2019, the TLC received 60 competitive bids and proposals from HUB vendors, whichrepresented 75.95% of all responses. Overall, the agency awarded 185 total contracts to HUB vendors,66 of which were awarded to minority-owned business. These included contracts resulting fromnoncompetitive “spot purchases,” informal and formal quotes, bids, offers, and proposals receivedfrom HUB vendors.Outre ach ActivitiesOutreach Materials: The TLC provided information to minority businesses and HUBs that wereinterested in doing business with the agency. This included information regarding the agency’sprocurements, and contacts for both agency staff and key TLC contractors.Website: Information about the TLC’s HUB Program is available via the agency’s website(txlottery.org), which also provides links to Statewide HUB Program information.Forums: In accordance with legislative mandates, the TLC participated in conferences, forumsand events to provide information regarding the agency’s procurement opportunities. As part ofthe TLC’s outreach program, staff attended Economic Opportunity Forums (EOFs) sponsoredby state agencies and/or other governmental entities. These included forums presented by theStatewide Procurement Division (SPD) of the Comptroller of Public Accounts. In addition, the TLCparticipated in a number of forums, conferences and other vendor fairs coordinated by otherstate agencies and/or small, minority- and woman-owned business organizations. A summary ofthe agency’s outreach efforts is provided in Appendix C (page 25) of this report.The TLC conducted its Annual HUB Forum on May 15, 2019, in Austin. The forum drewminority- and woman-owned companies from throughout the state. Texas Lottery Commissionpresenters provided an overview of the agency’s procurement opportunities and processes, as wellas other information to assist HUBs. Roundtable networking sessions provided attendees withthe opportunity to meet face-to-face with agency management/staff and representatives fromsome of the TLC’s largest contractors. Vendors who attend the TLC forum consistently providepositive feedback regarding the meeting format and the opportunity to directly network withagency staff and contractors.Subcontracting Opportunities: In FY 2019, the TLC continued to identify subcontractingopportunities for minority/HUB vendors and to monitor HUB Subcontracting Plan requirements.Mentor- Protégé Pro gr amIn accordance with Texas Government Code, §2161.065, all state agencies with biennial budgetsof more than 10 million are required to have a Mentor-Protégé Program. The purpose ofthe Mentor-Protégé Program is to foster long-term relationships between prime contractors10T E X A S L O T T E RY C O M M I S S I O N

FISCAL YEAR 2019 ACCOMPLISHMENTSand HUBs. The ultimate goal of the program is to provide developmental assistance to HUBsthat will potentially increase their ability to contract directly with the state and/or to obtainsubcontract opportunities under a state contract. All relationships among mentors, protégés andthe program sponsor are voluntary, and participation in the agency’s Mentor-Protégé Program isneither a guarantee for a contract opportunity nor a promise of business.The TLC sponsored one mentor-protégé relationship during FY 2019. The Mentor- ProtégéProgram is an ongoing initiative, and the TLC will continue its efforts to form additionalrelationships during FY 2020.HUB Discussion WorkgroupThe TLC participates in the HUB Discussion Workgroup, an established group of HUB Coordinatorsfrom state agencies and institutions of higher education who meet on a regular basis. The workgroupshares program practices and ideas, supports outreach events, and provides input to the CPA on methodsfor improving the state’s HUB Program.Contr actor SupportContractors are encouraged to include minority businesses and HUBs when purchasing goods and/or services related to the fulfillment of their contracts with the TLC. When the TLC determines thatsubcontracting is probable for contracts with an expected value of 100,000 or more, respondentsshall submit a completed HUB Subcontracting Plan demonstrating evidence of good faith effortin developing the plan. The state’s Centralized Master Bidders List and HUB Directory are keyresources for identifying potential HUB subcontractors. Many of the TLC’s largest contractors alsoparticipated in the TLC’s FY 2019 HUB Forum, providing information and networking opportunitiesto HUBs. Through these efforts, the agency’s key contractors who utilized minority and/or HUBsubcontractors achieved the following results in FY 2019:TAB L E BCONTRACTOR NAMEMINORITY/HUB SUBCONTRACTINGEXPENDITURES*LATINWORKS MARKETING, LLC 10,293,687IGT CORPORATION 4,546,595POLLARD BANKNOTE, LTD. 1,588,893SCIENTIFIC GAMES INTERNATIONAL, INC. 680,747IGT CORPORATION (FKA GTECH PRINTING CORPORATION) 146,234AGENCIES OF CHANGE DBA TECHNOLOGY SPA 140,966ELEPHANT PRODUCTIONS, INC. 92,864DK PARTNERS. P.C. (FKA DAVILA, BUSCHHORN & ASSOCIATES, P.C.) 15,275*Amounts have been rounded to the nearest dollar.M I N O R I T Y B U S I N E S S PA RT I C I PAT I O N R E P O RT F Y 2 0 1 911

FISCAL YEAR 2019 ACCOMPLISHMENTSRank Among Largest-Spending AgenciesThe Texas Lottery Commission ranked 17th in terms of overall expenditures captured by the CPA’sFiscal Year 2019 Texas Historically Underutilized Business (HUB) Annual Report. Of the 17 largest-spendingagencies, the TLC ranked 6th by overall HUB percentage (see Table C).TABLE CANNUAL F ISCAL Y EAR 2 0 1 9 HU B REPORTS EVEN T EEN T H LA R G E ST- SPE N D I N G AG E N CIE S RAN KE D BY OV E RAL L H UB PE RCE N TAGERANKAGENCY NAMETOTAL EXPENDITURESTOTAL HUBEXPENDITURESHUB % OFEXPENDITURES1TEXAS TECH UNIVERSITY 203,161,025.25 48,473,833.7023.86%2TEXAS FACILITIES COMMISSION 206,397,187.96 46,180,075.0322.37%3UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN 526,573,103.02 109,881,467.1120.87%4UNIVERSITY OF HOUSTON 333,633,950.76 60,869,480.7418.24%5THE TEXAS A&M UNIVERSITY SYSTEM 673,584,952.17 119,680,270.0317.77%6TEXAS LOTTERY COMMISSION 196,101,001.88 34,627,792.1617.66%7UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS SYSTEM 357,027,808.47 62,618,540.9717.54%8TEXAS A & M UNIVERSITY (MAIN UNIV) 416,020,321.27 71,473,361.6617.18%9TEXAS DEPT OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE 215,859,729.23 33,040,994.1615.31%10UT SOUTHWESTERN MEDICAL CENTER 1,097,788,164.66 143,981,624.6913.12%11HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION 1,056,663,985.56 133,205,452.4012.61%12UT HEALTH SCIENCE CENTER – HOUSTON 221,940,180.56 23,677,372.4210.67%13TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION 8,204,946,231.89 863,887,533.6010.53%14DEPARTMENT OF STATE HEALTH SERVICES 200,754,144.88 17,465,894.298.70%15GENERAL LAND OFFICE 295,945,768.65 23,154,206.007.82%16UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS MEDICAL BRANCH 641,412,405.75 35,394,063.405.52%17UT MD ANDERSON CANCER CENTER 1,829,392,612.68 84,708,201.894.63%Note: The largest-spending agencies are determined by total expenditures made for object codes which are reportable in the CPA’sFiscial Year 2019 Texas Historically Underutilized Business (HUB) Annual Report. The state does not have an overall HUB goal,but utilizes six procurement category goals, in accordance with the State Disparity Study. These figures are unaudited and havebeen rounded to the nearest dollar.Minorit y RetailersThe Texas Lottery Commission’s minority retailer base consistently exceeds its statutory goal of 20%.In FY 2019, the agency’s minority retailers numbered 8,103, which represented 44.39% of the TexasLottery’s total retailer base (see Figure 4 and Appendix B). The agency has maintained a minority retailer percentage of more than 40% for the past 13 years.12T E X A S L O T T E RY C O M M I S S I O N

FISCAL YEAR 2020 RECOMMENDED IMPROVEMENTS Enhance the Commission’s Mentor-Protégé Program and develop new mentorprotégé relationships. Work with TLC technical staff to improve internal HUB reporting capabilities. Attend at least one outreach event that is focused on service-disabled veterans. Continue providing bid opportunities at the “Doing Business Texas Style” Spot Bid Fair. Include TLC Purchasing staff in additional HUB outreach events. Maintain active participation in the HUB Discussion Workgroup.M I N O R I T Y B U S I N E S S PA RT I C I PAT I O N R E P O RT F Y 2 0 1 913

T H IS PAGE IS I N T EN T IONA LLYLEF T BL A N K .14T E X A S L O T T E RY C O M M I S S I O N

A P PEND IC ESA . De f i n it ion s. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16B . M i nor it y Re t a i le rs by C ou nt y . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18C . Fi s c a l Ye a r 2 019 HU B , M i nor it y a nd Sm a l l Bu si ne s s O ut re a c h Eve nt s . . . . . . 25D. Fi sc a l Ye a r 2 019 Work force D ive rsit y Hu m a n Re sou rce s St ate me nt . . . . . . . . . . 2 6M I N O R I T Y B U S I N E S S PA RT I C I PAT I O N R E P O RT F Y 2 0 1 815

A PP E N D IX ADEFINITIONSAs defined in Texas Government Code §466.107 (b), “Minority Business”means a business entity at least 51% of which is owned by minority group members or, in the case of acorporation, at least 51% of the shares of which are owned by minority group members, and that:MINORITY BUSINESS:1) is managed and, in daily operations, is controlled by minority group members; and2) is a domestic business entity with a home or branch office located in this state and is not abranch or subsidiary of a foreign corporation, firm or other business entity.include African Americans, American Indians, Asian Americans, andMexican Americans and other Americans of Hispanic origin.“MINORITY GROUP MEMBERS”As defined in Texas Government Code, §2161.001subdivisions (2) and (3), “historically underutilized business” means an entity with its principal placeof business in the state of Texas that is:HISTORICALLY UNDERUTILIZED BUSINESS (HUB):1) a corporation formed for the purpose of making a profit in which 51% or more of all classesof the shares of stock or other equitable securities are owned by one or more economicallydisadvantaged persons who have a proportionate interest and actively participate in thecorporation’s control, operation, and management;2) a sole proprietorship created for the purpose of making a profit that is completely owned,operated, and controlled by an economically disadvantaged person;3) a partnership formed for the purpose of making a profit in which 51% or more of the assetsand interest in the partnership are owned by one

0 250 500 1,000 1,250 Austin Dallas North Dallas South El Paso Fort Worth Houston East Houston North Houston South Houston West Lubbock McAllen San Antonio Tyler Waco 750 190 (14.88%) 482 (37.72%) 659 (40.33%) . Netsync Network Solutions - Hyper Converged Infrastructure with Server Lease