Writer's Phone: 847-948-4879 Eaxter - Nuclear Regulatory Commission

Transcription

Baxler International Inc.One Baxter ParkwayDeerfield, Illinois 60015-4633847.948.2000Fax. 847.948.3948Writer's Phone: 847-948-4879Writer's Fax:847-948-2552EaxterApril 9, 2008U.S. Nuclear Regulatory CommissionAttn: Regional AdministratorRegion I475 Allendale RoadKing of Prussia, PA 19406Re:Confirmatory Order (EA-07-132)Training Documents as agreed to under OrderLicense No.: 52-21 175-01Baxter Healthcare of Puerto Rico, Aibonito, Puerto RicoryruDear Sir,On March 28, 2008, we sent you a draft of our training document as agreed to in the abovereferenced Confirmatory Order (Item D(2)). The training focuses on a safety conscious workenvironment and raising issues without fear of retaliation.After some helpful comments from NRC staff on April 7, 2008, we revised the presentationslides.Enclosed please find the revised presentation that Baxter intends to provide.As noted previously, it is our intention to translate part or all of the presentation to Spanish,based on the audience. As appropriate, we may make slight revisions or enhancements to theenclosed material before or during the training to facilitate better learning.The training will be completed before June 30, 2008, as agreed to in the OrderPlease contact me at 847-948-4879 or the Plant General Manager, Mr. Enrique Moran, at 787735-8021, extension 2261, if you have any questions regarding this letter.Sincerelv.Peter EtienneSenior CounselPE:Ifbcc: Enrique Moran, BaxterKarl Farrar, NRC/enclosure146015-1

How can we collaborate to createa safe and compli nt workplace?BaxterAibonito, Puerto Rico2008

What “happened”?Some employees chose not to follow proceduresregarding radiation safety at the irradiatorThese employees did not conduct required inspectionsbut prepared documents saying that they didThere were allegations of falsified training recordsThe Nuclear Regulatory Commiss on (NRC) uncoveredat least three violations during inspections last MarchInspectors attributed the violations to “deliberate acts” byemployees2

What “happened”?i--” -I.-.--I* l l.--.--- --- -I.1-- ---- Baxter HealthcareCorporation of PuertoRico-Aibonitonhonored forEnvironmentalAchievements in 2002-J-.“.!1--LxI“ lll-.-.x- l lll-lI--”-- - --I-- “ l ll lNRC documented sixviolations of requirements in2005Baxter To Pay 15,000 FineFor Lax Testing in 20083

What “happened”?Employees did not alert management about issues withthe procedures or about other employees not followingthe proceduresBaxter incurred fines of 15,000, on top of 31,000 forviolations in 2004Some people have lost their jobs over itThe regulatory status of the irradiator and the plant is putat risk by these behaviorsNow our work is under scrutinym m munnecessarily4

What “happened”?PLEASE NOTE:This was our own doingNot an “act of God”Not a random or unavoidableaccidentUntil we accept responsibilityfor this, we cannot assure itwon’t happen again5

What “happened”?Learning?Actions of individuals take place within specific culturalcontexts. The cultural context we create will either promotecompliance and safety, and make it easy for all of us to dothe right thing-or erode it and increase risk.Bottom line:As a team and as a community, we failed to create the rightcultural context for full compliance, to help our comradessucceed, and to protect the people who use our products.6

“Everybody makes mistakes.It’s what we make of our mistakesthat makes us what we are.”. Anonymous

Do you know who you are?You are part of a plant that:Employs about 1,100 employeesManufactures about 110 million units of over 200different finished product codes each year.Is a global supplier of intravenous solution sets, bloodsets, and components for customers worldwide. Thank You!8

If you see someone doing something unsafe e.g., like afellow employee in the irradiator area who does notfollow procedure, talk to that employee and help him/herunderstand that all procedures must be followed.If you or the employee have a suggestion to improve aprocedure or any other suggestion to improve safety,share that with a supervisor or any manager.If you see an employee, visitor or contractor intentionallydoing something unsafe, including not followingprocedure, politely ask the person not to do so. If theperson refuses, tell a supervisor or any manager.9

Please: Use these processes to ask questionswhenever something doesn’t seem right to you!This is the responsibility of each and every Baxteremployee, whomever or wherever you may be.9,10

What are “these processes”?One or more of us should have noticed that wewere not being diligent and alerted managementIn case of any ethics or compliance issue,please: voice your concern!FirstIf not, thenIf not, thenOryour supervisor, manager, or RSOHuman ResourcesPlant General ManagerEthics and Compliance Office11

.What are “these processes”?Baxter is utilizing EthicsPoint, an outside vendor toprovide you with ways to confidentially reportconcerns or seek advice on ethics and complianceissues.This service is available 24 hours a day, 7days aweek with representatives who can consult with youin Spanish.Baxcerlnvestiyators b -cYou are currently In the confidenbalan0 Secure reporbno structure of EthicsPOinl Below are the choices available toyou Pleaseckkonthe arrow()loselectthetypedreponywMuldlHre0meke.Ask a aucsllonEthics andMake a Report OnlineCompliance Helpline-- Select Ocganizarton -The work thatwe do is important-applying innovative science todevelop specialty therapeuticsand medical producrs that saveBaxter.The inaccurate recording and analysis ofthe business and financialuansacflons assonatad wiM generally accepted aocountlng practicesAccounting and Audkhg Matters (Earnpies indude miSSPdtamntof revenues. tniwatement ofexpenses. misstatement of assets. misapplicationsof GAAP principles.Brlbes, Kkkbacks, FCPAwrongful transacttons)Any unlawful payment of money or anything ofvalue. to influence thejudgment or conducf or to ensure a desired outcome or adion ofanyulnla.lnnr n i &ha. r n r r i i eIndlirwi tsi FMaking GtrgllshCasrc,c,.opca4,,,.2I I C M m m n s n u -I n m n o n rnnFooonlitmin ‘nnxrommanhl

What are “these processes”?You can contactBaxter’s Ethics andCompliance Helplinetoll-free, and request tospeak to someone inSpanish. Let’s try it now13

What are "these processes"?This wcbpage IS hmtcd or EthicsPoirt's sccurcd scrvcr ardISrot part of !hc Baxtcr wcb sib or irtrorctEthics andCompliance HelplineAsk a QuesllonSubmiiCall the Elhlcs 8 ComplianceHolpllnaDornalic Calk:U S , Canada. Guam. 8, PucrfoRWDUI 1.en.ma373tntematknat calls:Choose a CountryFrom ap u t l dlma dtalAt the prompt, dal877.1258373Chock tho Status Of YourReportReport Key or UsemamcPassword.'iubrnit Baxtcr's Ethics andCompllancs StandardsFraquanllyAskod QuestionsThe work rhai we do is important-applying innovative science todevelop specialty therapeuticsand medical productsthat saveand sustain patients' livesworldwide But equally importantis how we work-the behaviorsthat we demonstrate and thejudgments that we make on adaily basissubmit a question orconcern to the Ethicsand ComplianceHelpline via onlineform:Baxtefs corporate reputation isachieved by our individualbustnesscondua Every day ourco-workers. customers.suppliers, investors. and thecommunittes in which we liveand work evaluate us Everyinteramon is an opportunityforus to demonstrate that integrityis central to our businesssuccess-that "integrity workshere "The Baxter Ethics andCompliance Helpline is amethod for reporting actual orsuspected conduct that mayinvolve violatton of applicablelaws, rules, regulations.standards, poliues. andaccountmg procedures orotherwise inconsistentwithm a aLet's try it now14

What are “these processes”?EaxterWorldwidewww.baxter.com Doing Business with Baxter Business PracticesYou can contact the Ethicsand Compliance Helpline viaphone: 1-877-229-8373. Oryou can contact the CorporateResponsibility Office viapostal mail or e-mail as notedbelow. Let’s try it nowupervisor, manager or department leadersxterand its FoundaoonContribute Nearly,3 Million in 2007 to Address Critical Neebsically and Globally [ ’ h - ,l r C r ’* b’ 7Functional expertsRecent LinksinforniationUPDATE Baxter’sCOLLEAGInfusionPump With Links to CCustomer Letters(e.g., legal counsel,controller, H R,quality VP, etc.)Ethics & ComplianceHelpline1.877.BAXTER3(1.877.229.8373)On line atwww.baxter.com/complianceCopyrigM &Legal Disclaimer I PrivacyCorporate Responsibility OfficeCRO P.O. Box 154Deerfield, IL 60015 r.com15

What are “these processes”?.You can call anyoneon our Ethics andCompliance team!Dave Resnicoff847-948-4424Julie Brautigam847-948-2387Peter Etienne847-948-4879Brenda Hildreth847-948-4633Sheri Rudberg847-948-316616

Key TopicsYou can call or writethe NRC directly.(Phone number 1-800695-7403).Emergency PreparednessIrradiated GemstoresNevi Reactors.Radiatw ProtectionRadatton Source Securityand ReplacementReactor License Renewalrn-tlw navwdmmatl- on nactnequipmedweld. th.t raisedw s b o t m about whether mspeE(I011syore msded IM01mvtng plannedshuMmm this spring moreFor the RecordPrevious Key TopicsHighlightsRegulatory Information Conference on March 11 13,2008We encourage you toexpress your concernto someone at theplant or at Corporate.k TeachenNews Releases and SpeechesBudgetFV07 Performance &AccountaWlty ReportI& DieestMarch 14, ZOOSPhotoGalleryStatement of NRC Chairman Dale E Klem on theConfirmation of Gregory Jacrko to a Second TermStatement of NRC Chairman Dale C Klem on theConfirmation of Kristine Svinlckl as an NRCCommissionerNRC to Discuss 2007 Performance Assessment lorPalo Verde Nuclear Generatzng Statson17

The NRC and BaxterWhat is Baxter’s responsibility to the NRC?rn What is each employee’s responsibility to the NRC?rn What would happen if I was personally responsible for aviolation?rn Can / may I talk to an NRC inspector?Can / May I request an inspection?Both the law and Baxter policy prohibits retaliationagainst employees who raise safety concerns to theNRC. So you can raise concerns without fear ofretaliation.18

What do “confidential” and “anonymous”mean, exactly?See Frequently Asked Questions atQi. f f f r e p o an issue anline, can yc3u identify me thmugh my IP address?Art Internet portal never rdentfies a wisimr by xreer1 name. l ’ k Elhirs and Compliance Helplinesyshtzrn we use thruuyh our thiru party wndor kthicspuinl’ strips away 1P add-ssaanonymity is maintarred.Q, Is the telephone Ethics 8r Compliance Helpline system canfidential and ananymaus tm?Yes. You wll be a s M to provide the same infarmtion that you would pmide in an internelbawd rejmrt and an interuiwer will type your respansles into the Ethics and t crmplraneeHelplinesystem, These reports have the same sxurity and rmfidefitiali‘ly measures applied to them asthe Internet reports.

Afraid of reotalioaition?Harmful action to someone who has harmedYOUAction taken in return for an injury or offenseThe act of retaliating: reprisal, retribution,revenge, vengeanceIdioms:An eye for an eye. Tooth for a tooth.Like for like. Measure for measure. .20

Afraid of reotalioa'tion?Retaliation can take many forms:Demotion, firing, or harassed to quitDenial of raises or proper compensationSudden decline in performance ratingsExclusion from meetings and social activitiesAssignment of less desirable workTreatment as malcontents or trouble-makers21

Baxter’s NO RETALIATION PolicyNo one will be punished for asking about possiblebreaches of law, regulation, or company policy.Any allegation of a reprisal will be investigated.Baxter managers, as well as the CorporateResponsibility Office enforce this policy.Retaliatory actions must be reported immediately.Retaliatory behavior is subject to disciplinary action.22

If you have any questions or concerns about yourorganization’s business practices, including thoseof your leaders, you must raise them.Please: Use one or more of the availableprocesses to raise your concerns and ask yourquestions! And know that any retaliation for doingso is prohibited and will be dealt with swiftly.23

How can you tell if it’s “right”?Values test .Policy test.Law test .Does my proposed actionembrace our sharedvalues? Is it honest andtruthful?Is what I plan to doconsistent with Baxter’sGlobal Business PracticeStandards and companypolicy?Is my proposed actionlegal? Will it break any lawor regulations?Mirror test.Others test. .Press test. .What are the consequencesof my planned action? Howwill it affect others? How willI feel about myself if I takethis action?What will my manager,supervisor, co-workers orfamily think about what Iplan to do?If what I do is reported in anewspaper, or on television,will I be proud of myactions?24

WWWn 0 0v)WW0zWD0S - 000CQ CD rc-.0,30 UCQ 92 .('CD 0rc CD ' :v)v)s733 30"3SEl.-. 5-.i9,3 9, iD"9,7rCDv)S3-K0S0030CD3-. 9,3 CQ -.,CD 9v)rc-.CQ3v)rc9, 9,rc-.30 %3 03v)CDzTrcz9, 03Kv)s30Ik0309,3U00 CD30CDQi3D"-.rc-0--. USCDQ0v)09,X(D(DiD"v)-9, Tv)v)UJ39,CD-rc30CDU0s-. c TiD"0m3%3,-. 9309,3Q3335v)v)v)7rcYv)-.v)?ii070 0CD3v)3-.0 CDS9,7iiS0CDv)v)v)9,QQ309,9,Q 9, CQQCD%33-.300rcUJS--OCD-.v)3CDv)v)TI -.30(Dv,U03v,-.rc9,e.03v)CD05iv)39, 1. Q3 0 9,QEzv)(Dv,

Actions Protected by LawProviding the NRC or Baxter information aboutpossible violations of NRC regulations.Refusing to do something unlawful.26

How can we exercise ourleadership to create a safe andcompliant workplace?(f o r manage rs)Gamma Sterilization AreaAibonito, Puerto RicoApril 2008

How can we lay the groundworkfor trust and openness?Have an “open door” policy and make yourselfavailableBe aware of potential reluctance to raise concernsUnderstand the importance of identity protectionBe great listenersRecognize employees who identify and worktowards resolving safety concerns28

How can we lay the groundworkfor trust and openness?Find out what theindividual expectsState any constraintsyou have up frontExpress commitment toconfidentiality and nonretaliationExplain how the issue willbe handled, or developan action-plan togetherSet specific times to talkagainSummarize conclusionsand corrective actions29

How can we prevent retaliation?Thank all employeeswho raise concernsChoose comfortablesettings to discussGive your full attention!Preventing Reta lia tio nUsing communication skills to helpminimize the perception of retaliationAsk clarifying questionsUse supportive bodylanguageDiscussing potential ethical issues can be stressful, both for theemployee coming forward, and for the manager.Communicate effectively in those situations and minimize the chancethat the team member will perceive the situation as retaliatory.Trust dies &ut mistrust blossoms.Suykwlm (4g7 40W5 B.C.), Gmek lrdyc&dn1

wU

What does a safety-consciousenvironment look like?Are we evaluating whether responses areadequate and timely?Are we surveying employees to determinewillingness to raise issues?Are we evaluating, discussing, and addressingwhat we learn?Are we taking time to observe employeebehaviors?32

Let’s role play .Imagine a few likelydilemmas. .Issues not coming to foreSpecific incident occurredOther?What would you sayor do?What standard,procedure, regulation,or policy applies?33

enior Management CommitmentWe are committed to a safe, legal and ethicalenvironment at AibonitoWe will develop and maintain a safety-consciouswork environment hereWe know this is the responsibility of each of usWe will make sure that our contractors andvisitors act in accordance with our requirements34

Take away .Managers .are accountable for the ethical climate of theirorganizationmust create an environment where employees feelcomfortable raising issuesmust respond promptly and properly to all allegations ofwrongdoingbear some responsibility if their employees break the lawor standards35

In your opinion, what were the principal messages oftoday’s training?What information that you received today will have thegreatest impact on your conduct in the future?List three things you will do differently as a result of thistraining.36

enclosed material before or during the training to facilitate better learning. The training will be completed before June 30, 2008, as agreed to in the Order Please contact me at 847-948-4879 or the Plant General Manager, Mr. Enrique Moran, at 787- 735-8021, extension 2261, if you have any questions regarding this letter. Sincerelv. Peter Etienne