Mozo Experts Choice Awards

Transcription

Mozo Experts Choice AwardsInsurance 2018Every day, Mozo keeps track of thousands of products in banking, insurance andenergy. We use our knowledge and experience to identify those products that offergreat value or market-leading features, and we recognise them with these awards. For product providers, it’s a third-party endorsement of their product. For consumers, it’s a sign that a product is among the leaders and is worthyof consideration.Our approach to insurance awards is to seek out and reward:ExceptionalValueInsurance that’s among the best-priced for the main featuresit offers, based on a comparison of prices for thousands ofdifferent customer scenarios.ExceptionalQualityInsurance that offers a wide range of cover and features, withgenerous limits, regardless of price. Wherever possible, wealso factor in customer feedback on the experience ofdealing with the insurer and Ombudsman data on disputeresolution.Not all customers are looking for the same thing, and different products havedifferent strengths. We think it’s important to show why a product has beenawarded.This report lists the winners and explains the judging methodology.1

Insurer of the Year - 2018SuncorpCar Insurance - 2018 WinnersExceptional Value Car InsuranceBendigo BankComprehensive Car InsuranceBeyond BankComprehensive Car InsuranceBudget DirectComprehensive Car InsuranceReal InsurancePay As You Drive InsuranceSuncorpComprehensive Advantages Car InsuranceSuncorpComprehensive Extras Car InsuranceWoolworthsDrive Less Pay Less Car InsuranceYouiComprehensive Car InsuranceRACComprehensive Car InsuranceExceptional Quality Car InsuranceGIOPlatinum Car InsuranceSuncorpComprehensive Advantages Car InsuranceNRMAComprehensive Plus Car InsuranceRAAComprehensive Car InsuranceRACVComplete Care Car Insurance2

Home Insurance - 2018 WinnersExceptional Value Home & Contents InsuranceANZHome InsuranceAPIAHome & Contents InsuranceBudget DirectHome & Contents InsuranceINGHome & Contents InsuranceYouiHome & Contents InsuranceRACHome & Contents InsuranceSGICHome Plus InsuranceExceptional Value Contents InsuranceSuncorpClassic Extras Home InsuranceWestpacEssential Care ResidentialRACQContents InsuranceExceptional Quality Home & Contents InsuranceQBEHome Cover PrestigeSuncorpClassic Advantages Home InsuranceWestpacPremier Care ResidentialNRMAHome Plus InsuranceSGICHome Plus InsuranceSGIOHome Plus InsuranceExceptional Quality Contents InsuranceAPIAApartment InsuranceGIOPlatinum Contents3

Landlord Insurance - 2018 WinnersExceptional Value Landlord InsuranceBudget DirectLandlord InsuranceINGBuilding & ContentsWestpacLandlord Insurance Quality CareWoolworthsLandlords InsuranceRACLandlord’s InsuranceExceptional Quality Landlord InsuranceANZLandlord InsuranceCommInsureInvestment Home PackageWestpacLandlord Insurance Quality CareRACVLandlord Insurance4

How do we judge the winners?Exceptional ValueOur assessment of Value is based on a comparison of quotes: over 10,000 differentquotes for car insurance, over 15,000 for home insurance and over 2,000 forlandlord insurance. From these samples we calculated the likelihood that a givenproduct would be among the top 4 quotes for an individual customer. A higherlikelihood means that a product is well-priced for a wider range of customers.To compare prices among products that offer broadly similar levels of cover, weperformed the quote comparisons three times:1. A comparison of all products in our pricing dataset, to find the verycheapest offerings. In this comparison we assumed no optional extras weretaken, and monthly premiums.2. A comparison of products that included the following items.a. In Car Insurance: no-excess windscreen cover and a hire car after anaccident.b. In Home Insurance: flood cover and accidental damage.c. In Landlord Insurance: flood cover, loss of rent, damage and defaultby tenant.In this second comparison we assumed extra premiums were paid to coveroptional extras where necessary, and we assumed annual premiums.3. A comparison of products that achieved a very high score in our QualityAwards assessment - as described in the next section.We awarded Exceptional Value Awards to products that scored in the top few inany of the three comparisons.5

Exceptional QualityOur assessment of Quality is based on how well the product scores on a largerange of different factors including the nature and extent of the insurance cover,and the inclusion of added benefits.We also took into account the underwriter’s record in handling disputes involvingthe Ombudsman, and in Car Insurance and Home Insurance we made anallowance for survey results where customers rate the experience of dealing withtheir insurer.See Appendix 5 for a full list of the factors we considered.Overall results are strongly weighted towards the product cover and benefits.To make our assessments of cover, we relied on product information in eachinsurer’s Product Disclosure Statements and on their websites.Customer experience scores were sourced from a national survey of 3,693Australians commissioned by Mozo and undertaken by IPSOS in April 2018, whichmeasured customer ratings of the experiences of getting a quote, dealing withcustomer service staff and making claims.Dispute data came from the information published by the Financial OmbudsmanService, showing the rate of dispute per 100,000 customers, the average FOS stagereached and the percentage of disputes resolved by agreement.Insurer of the YearIn addition to the winners in the individual categories we chose one insurer asInsurer of the Year. To decide this award we examined providers who achievedawards across multiple categories and insurance types. The winner was chosen forhaving won both Quality and Value awards in multiple categories.6

What products do we consider?We collected information for 58 car insurance policies, 125 home insurancepolicies and 34 landlord insurance policies across a combined 52 insuranceproviders. These are listed in Appendices 1, 2 and 3. In a few cases, sufficientpricing data was not available and a product was only assessed for Quality awards.The information collection was conducted in July 2018. To be considered forinclusion in these awards the PDS must be readily available on the insurer’swebsite.Products are considered and awards are made irrespective of a product provider’scommercial relationship with Mozo. We aim to include most providers in themarket in the Mozo Experts Choice Awards. However, not every product on themarket will be included in our review.7

How we manage conflicts ofinterestMozo Experts Choice Awards are based on objective verifiable facts and analysiswherever possible, and any assumptions made are set out in this report. Mozo’sresearch team analyses product data and determines the winners in each MozoExperts Choice category without reference to Mozo’s sales or commercialfunctions.A provider can participate in the Mozo Experts Choice Awards free of charge.Mozo charges a licence fee to providers should they wish to use the Mozo ExpertsChoice Awards badges in their own marketing activities. Mozo may also offerpromotional packages that may be purchased.A product provider may also choose to list its products on the Mozo website in away that may generate revenue for Mozo.Mozo Experts Choice awards are awarded irrespective of a product provider’scommercial relationship with Mozo.8

About MozoMozo Pty Ltd provides a comparison service with the goal of helping consumers tomake their own financial decisions and save money. Mozo offers consumers acomprehensive product comparison service that across the retail banking market,general insurance, life insurance, business banking, energy and more.Hundreds of thousands of Australians a month use Mozo’s comparison service.Mozo’s comparison technology and expertise has been used by some of Australia’slargest online publishers.Mozo holds an Australian Financial Services Licence and an Australian CreditLicence. Mozo’s management team have experience in consumer credit andfinancial services in a variety of roles from executive management, marketing,actuarial services and technology. Mozo’s team are often called upon to provideexpert media commentary in relation to the product areas they cover.Our Experts Choice Awards analysis is overseen by AJ Duncanson, Mozo’s DataServices Director. AJ has worked in financial services and product comparison forover 28 years in Australia and the UK and is a qualified actuary and ResponsibleManager on Mozo’s Australian Financial Services Licence and Australian CreditLicence.9

Important InformationThe information published in this report is of a general nature only and does not take intoaccount your situation or needs. Before choosing a product, you should consider whether it’sappropriate to you and you should read all the information available from the product provider.The information contained in this report is governed by Mozo's standard Terms of Use. To theextent permitted by law, you indemnify and agree to keep Mozo indemnified against any loss orclaim arising out of your use of any information contained in this report. Where Mozo collectsinformation such as rates, pricing and product information we make every effort to ensure thatall information displayed is accurate. Mozo does not warrant that the information contained inthis report will be faultless or that all of the information displayed will be completely accurateand we accept no liability whatsoever for any errors or omissions.Copyright 2018 Mozo Pty Ltd. All Rights Reserved.ABN: 68 128 199 208. AFSL & ACL 328141Level 11, 263 Clarence St, Sydney NSW 200010

Appendix 1List of Car Insurance products considered in the awards.ProviderProduct1300 InsuranceGold Comprehensive1st for WomenComprehensive Car InsuranceAAMIComprehensive Car InsuranceAllianzComprehensive CoverANZComprehensive Car InsuranceApiaComprehensive Car InsuranceAustralia PostGold Comprehensive Car InsuranceAustralian Seniors Insurance AgencyComprehensive Car InsuranceAustralian UnityComprehensive CoverBank of QueenslandComprehensive Car InsuranceBankwestComprehensive Car InsuranceBendigo BankComprehensive Car InsuranceBeyond BankComprehensive Car InsuranceBingleComprehensive Car Insurance PolicyBudget DirectComprehensive Car InsuranceCGUComprehensive InsuranceColesComprehensive Car InsuranceColesComprehensive Plus Car InsuranceComminsureComprehensive Car InsuranceGIOComprehensive Car InsuranceGIOPlatinum Car InsuranceGuild InsuranceComprehensive Car InsuranceHBFComprehensive Car Insurance11

HSBCComprehensive Car InsuranceHuddleComprehensive Car InsuranceHume BankCar InsuranceNABComprehensive CoverNational SeniorsComprehensive Car InsuranceNRMAComprehensive Car InsuranceNRMAComprehensive Plus Car InsuranceOver 50 InsuranceComprehensive CoverOzicareComprehensive Car InsurancePeople's Choice Credit UnionComprehensive InsuranceProgressive DirectComprehensive InsuranceQBEComprehensive Car InsuranceRAAComprehensive Car InsuranceRACComprehensive Car InsuranceRACQComprehensive Car InsuranceRACTComprehensive Motor Vehicle InsuranceRACVComprehensive Car InsuranceRACVComplete Care Car InsuranceReal InsuranceComprehensive Car InsuranceReal InsurancePay As You Drive Car InsuranceRetirease InsuranceComprehensive Car InsuranceSGICComprehensive Plus Car InsuranceSGICComprehensive Car InsuranceSGIOComprehensive Car InsuranceSGIOComprehensive Plus Car InsuranceShannonsComprehensive Motor Vehicle InsuranceSt.GeorgeComprehensive InsuranceSuncorp InsuranceComprehensive Extras Car Insurance12

Suncorp InsuranceComprehensive Car InsuranceSuncorp InsuranceComprehensive Advantages Car InsuranceTIOComprehensive Car InsuranceVirgin MoneyPrice Saver ComprehensiveWestpacComprehensive InsuranceWoolworthsComprehensive Car InsuranceYouiComprehensive Car Insurance13

Appendix 2List of Home Building & Contents Insurance productsconsidered in the awards.ProviderProduct1st for WomenHome & Contents InsuranceAAMIHome Building & Contents InsuranceAllianzHome & Contents InsuranceANZHome InsuranceApiaHome & Contents Extra InsuranceApiaHome & Contents InsuranceAustralia PostGold Home & Contents InsuranceBankwestHome & Contents InsuranceBendigo BankBronze Home & Contents InsuranceBendigo BankGold Home & Contents InsuranceBendigo BankSilver Home & Contents InsuranceBeyond BankClassic Home Insurance (combined)Beyond BankPrestige Home Insurance (combined)Beyond BankVital Home Insurance (combined)Budget DirectHome & Contents InsuranceCGUAccidental Damage Home InsuranceCGUFundamentals Home InsuranceCGUListed Events Home InsuranceColesHome InsuranceColesHome Insurance PlusComminsureResidential Home PackageGIOClassic Extra Home & Contents14

GIOClassic Home & ContentsGIOPlatinum Home & ContentsHume BankClassic Home & ContentsHume BankPrestige Home & ContentsHume BankVital Home & ContentsINGHome and Contents InsuranceNABNAB Home Insurance EssentialsNABNAB Home Insurance PackageNational SeniorsClassic Home Insurance (combined)National SeniorsPrestige Home Insurance (combined)National SeniorsVital Home Insurance (combined)NRMAHome InsuranceNRMAHome Plus InsuranceOzicareHome & Contents InsurancePeople's Choice Credit UnionAccidental Damage Home InsurancePeople's Choice Credit UnionListed Events Home InsuranceQBEHome CoverQBEHome Cover PrestigeRAAHome & Contents InsuranceRACHome & Contents InsuranceRACQHome & Contents InsuranceRACTHome & Contents InsuranceRACVHome InsuranceReal InsuranceEssential Home and Contents InsuranceReal InsuranceTop Home and Contents InsuranceSGICHome InsuranceSGICHome Plus InsuranceSGIOHome Insurance15

SGIOHome Plus InsuranceShannonsHome & Contents InsuranceSuncorpClassic Advantages Home InsuranceSuncorpClassic Extras Home InsuranceSuncorpClassic Home InsuranceVirgin MoneyHome & Contents InsuranceWestpacEssential Care Residential (Home & Contents)WestpacPremier Care Residential (Home & Contents)WestpacQuality Care Residential (Home & Contents)WoolworthsComprehensive CoverWoolworthsStandard CoverYouiHome & Contents Insurance16

Appendix 3List of Home Contents Insurance products considered in theawards.ProviderProduct1st for WomenContents InsuranceAAMIHome Contents InsuranceAllianzContents InsuranceANZHome InsuranceApiaApartment InsuranceApiaContents Extra InsuranceApiaContents InsuranceAustralia PostGold Contents InsuranceBankwestContents InsuranceBendigo BankBronze Contents InsuranceBendigo BankGold Contents InsuranceBendigo BankSilver Contents InsuranceBeyond BankClassic Home Insurance (contents only)Beyond BankPrestige Home Insurance (contents only)Beyond BankVital Home Insurance (contents only)Budget DirectContents InsuranceCGUAccidental Damage Home InsuranceCGUFundamentals Home InsuranceCGUListed Events Home InsuranceColesHome InsuranceColesHome Insurance PlusComminsureResidential Home Package17

GIOClassic ContentsGIOClassic Extra ContentsGIOPlatinum ContentsHume BankClassic ContentsHume BankPrestige ContentsHume BankVital ContentsINGContents InsuranceNABNAB Home Insurance EssentialsNABNAB Home Insurance PackageNational SeniorsClassic ContentsNational SeniorsPrestige ContentsNational SeniorsVital ContentsNRMAHome InsuranceNRMAHome Plus InsuranceOzicareContents InsurancePeople's Choice Credit UnionAccidental Damage Home InsurancePeople's Choice Credit UnionListed Events Home InsuranceQBEHome CoverQBEHome Cover PrestigeRAAContents InsuranceRACContents InsuranceRACQContents InsuranceRACTContents InsuranceRACVHome InsuranceReal InsuranceEssential Contents InsuranceReal InsuranceTop Contents InsuranceSGICHome InsuranceSGICHome Plus Insurance18

SGIOHome InsuranceSGIOHome Plus InsuranceShannonsContents InsuranceSuncorpClassic Advantages Home InsuranceSuncorpClassic Extras Home InsuranceSuncorpClassic Home InsuranceVirgin MoneyContents InsuranceWestpacEssential Care ResidentialWestpacPremier Care ResidentialWestpacQuality Care ResidentialWoolworthsComprehensive CoverWoolworthsStandard CoverYouiContents Insurance19

Appendix 4List of Landlord Insurance products considered in the awards.ProviderProductAAMIBuilding & Landlord ContentsAllianzBuildings & ContentsANZLandlord Building & Contents InsuranceApiaProperty & ContentsBendigo BankBuilding & ContentsBeyond BankBuilding & ContentsBudget DirectHome & ContentsCGUBuilding and ContentsColesBuilding and ContentsCommInsureInvestment Home Package - Building & ContentsGIOProperty & ContentsHBFBuildings & ContentsINGBuilding & ContentsNABBuildings & ContentsNational SeniorsBuildings & ContentsNRMABuildings & ContentsPeople's Choice Credit UnionBuildings & ContentsQBEBuilding & ContentsRAAHome & ContentsRACBuildings & ContentsRACQHome & ContentsRACTBuilding & ContentsRACVBuilding & ContentsReal InsuranceBuilding & ContentsSGICBuilding & Contents20

SGIOBuilding & ContentsSuncorpProperty & ContentsTerri ScheerLandlord Self ManagedTerri ScheerLandlord PreferredVeroProperty & ContentsWestpacBuilding & Contents Essential CareWestpacBuilding & Contents Quality CareWoolworthsLandlord Building & ContentsYouiBuilding & Contents21

Appendix 5List of Factors Considered in Quality AwardsItems shaded green we considered to be of high importance and those shaded white were considered to be of lowerimportance. Light grey items received various weightings in between.CAR INSURANCErental car after accidentrental car after theftphone claims 24/7choice of repairerwindscreen damage excesseschoice of agreed or market valuenew car replacementCustomer experience survey responsesFinancial Ombudsman Service dataroadside assistancechoice of repairerpersonal propertygenuine partsemergency repairsemergency accommodation and towingtrailer or caravanreplacement keyspersonal propertymonthly premiums at no extra costmodificationsrental car liabilitybaby equipmentaccidental deathlegal liabilityRideshare coverHOME INSURANCEphone service 24/7ContentsBuildingCombinedyyy22

accidental damage availableyyyunderinsurance protectionyyynew for old contentsynycustomer experience survey responsesyyyFinancial Ombudsman Service datayyyrange of excess choiceyyymonthly payment at no extra costyyybuilding materialsnyydebris removalyyytemporary accommodationyyydays building can be unoccupiedyyytwo addresses while movingynycontents in transitynygates and fencesnyyemergency storageyyydays building can be unoccupiedyyydemolitionyyyfusionyyypower surgeyyyaccidental breakage of glassyyycashynycredit cardynycd/dvdynycomputer hardware/softwareynylock replacementyyylandscapingnyyhandwoven carpetsynyantiques and valuablesynyjewellery cover limitsynyuncut gemsynyreplacement of documentsynyidentity theftynydeath and injuryyyypersonal medical equipmentynytools of tradeynystock and inventoryynyhome office contentsynycontents outdoorsynyitems away from homeyny23

veterinary expensesynytemporary pet accommodationyyylegal liabilityyyyLANDLORD INSURANCEloss of rentrent defaulttheft or vandalism by tenantmonthly payment at no extra costchoice of excesshousehold goods and appliancesbuilding materialslandscapinggates and fencespaved pathways and drivewaysdebris removaltemporary repairsFinancial Ombudsman Service dataaccidental loss and damageaccidental breakage of glassunderinsurance protectionlock replacementfusionpower surgestorm surgelegal liabilitydays building can be unoccupiedcarpetsmortgage discharge fees24

List of Car Insurance products considered in the awards. P r o v id e r P r o duct 1300 Insurance Gold Comprehensive 1st for Women Comprehensive Car Insurance AAMI Comprehensive Car Insurance Allianz Comprehensive Cover ANZ Comprehensive Car Insurance Apia Comprehensive Car Insurance